2 ms·
> ... along with Jacques essay ... Tiny, irrelevant nitpick. Assuming that Jacques Mattheij is using the French pronounciation of his first name, the possessi
by jacques_chester 14y ago
> ... along with Jacques essay ...
Tiny, irrelevant nitpick.
Assuming that Jacques Mattheij is using the French pronounciation of his first name, the possessive version of Jacques is Jacques's.
This is because in French the final letter of most words is silent, and in English the possessive form of spoken nouns not ending in an audible "s" is rendered in text as <singular>'s.
Phoenetically:
zhahk -> zhahks
Not:
zhahks -> zhahks.
Regards,
another Jacques.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoDang, I'm surrounded by Jacqueses! (Jacuqi?) Thank you. I changed it to the Americanized form of possessive for words ending in s (pronounced or not) I think this could go either way, but I screwed it up no matter which choice an author might take.
- jacques_chester 14y agoWell in all fairness, outside of La Francophonie, "Jacques" is not a common name. And for English speakers it's just chock full of exciting traps. My favourite is putting 'c' and 'q' next to each other. In French that's a single sound; in English it says "new syllable, please! edit: > Jacqueses! (Jacuqi?) Jacqueses would be closest (-ii is a Latin pluralisation, Jacques comes from Jacob which is Hebrew). There's an impedance mismatch here: English stores plurality in the word, French stores it in the sentence.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoWould a good translation of La Francophonie be "the French-speaking world"?
- jacques_chester 14y agoIt'd be clearer, but much less fun to put it that way :D
- Gmo 14y agoI do think he is from Dutch origin though (Because he talked in the past about one of his experience with QNX in the Netherlands)
- jacques_chester 14y agoI was under the impression he was Belgian.
- Gmo 14y agoHa yes, also possible :)
- jacquesm 14y agoDutch is correct.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoOnly HN could get from API to the Greengrocer's Apostrophe. There is no fully agreed upon means make words ending s (x or z) into possessive - the below site gives example of Dumas' and Dumas's as valid. My general response has been if it looks ok with just an ' leave it and move on. I can open my own shop with the left over apostrophes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostrophe#Nouns_ending_with_silent_s.2C_x_or_z http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostrophe#Nouns_ending_with_si...
- jacques_chester 14y agoThanks, interesting reading. Still, I prefer my rendition. The problem here is the incompatibility between the rules of pronounciation -- French permits silent letters to end a word, English in general does not. In translating to English you must choose either to honour the French or the English rules of pluralisation and possession. Because I don't write many English sentences with de la, du or d', I figure that sticking to the English rule is the best move.