3 ms·
My father has been on Glivec for the last 7 years, and this is the only reason he is still alive - when he was diagnosed with GIST doctors told him he would hav
by gambiting 14y ago
My father has been on Glivec for the last 7 years, and this is the only reason he is still alive - when he was diagnosed with GIST doctors told him he would have 2 years left at best, but decided to add him to clinical trials of Glivec for GIST patients. The whole treatment is paid for by our national health care, I believe it costs....$3000 per month, that's how much a single box of Glivec costs here and my dad has to take a pill every day so he gets a new box every month.
Not really related, but I wanted to mention this, since some people really want to show Novartis as evil, and while they probably charge too much for their drugs in the US, their medicine actually saves lives, my dad being the best example of that.
- tuananh 14y agoi don't know about American but when it comes to health-related issues, people in my country tends not to bargain about the price. That's least of their worry as long as they can afford it.
- userulluipeste 14y agoNobody has a problem that "medicine actually saves lives" - that's what medicine is supposed to do, isn't it? The problem is when that life-saving medicine becomes unavailable due to it's pricing, which means sheer death!
- brazzy 14y agoHow exactly is extracting the maximum possible revenue from people for giving them something that saves their lives NOT evil?
- gambiting 14y agoAs far as I know, companies are supposed to make profit,they are not charities. Especially if you are so large that you sell shares in company, then you have a LEGAL obligation to the shareholders to always take decisions that maximise profit over everything else(unless you can show that selling your product cheaper is going to bring more money to the company in the long run). This is not "evil" - this is just how these companies work. It's like what Steve Jobs said,when he was asked by Obama what would it take to bring his business back to US, out of China. And Steve said very correctly, that there is nothing he can do - if the production is cheaper in China, they have to go that route,since they have legal obligations to work in the best interest of their shareholders. (and I am not saying this is a good thing. This is just how this entire system works, and if you opened your own company, you would have to play by the same rules,no matter how noble you were. If you want this situation to change, change the system) The only way to combat this is to have a national health care system,that sets their own prices for drugs it buys from companies. If my country says that the maximum it can pay per box of Glivec is $3000, then Novartis can't do anything about it. Well, they could decide to not sell the drug at all, but they would rather have some money than none.
- brazzy 14y ago> a LEGAL obligation to the shareholders to always take decisions that maximise profit over everything else [..] This is not "evil" - this is just how these companies work. Yes, it is very much evil. > The only way to combat this is to have a national health care system,that sets their own prices for drugs it buys from companies. No. All it takes is a different patent system that reduces the (artificial, granted by society) monopoly awarded to patent holders. Or, as a more radical change, eliminate monopolies for drugs entirely and fund research publically.
- gambiting 14y agoIf you opened your own company you would have to play by the same rules. Even if you wanted to sell your product cheaper, you would not be able to due to obligations to your shareholders,which have a legal binding. Is the system evil? Yes. Are you evil for following the rules? No. And as for the patents - how would you deal with a problem that after spending millions on research somebody could copy you and sell the same product for the 1/100 of the price? I know that the US patent system is broken, but this problem is very real. As for the publicly funded research - this is the best option, but some countries like US oppose this so strongly that I don't think it would work.
- brazzy 14y ago> And as for the patents - how would you deal with a problem that after spending millions on research somebody could copy you and sell the same product for the 1/100 of the price? I know that the US patent system is broken, but this problem is very real. note that I said "reduce" the monopoly, not eliminate it. Perhaps a limit on the markup or some sort of mandatory licensing scheme.
- Retric 14y agoThere is no legal requirement to maximize profits, just avoid doing anything stupid. Aka they can donate 5% of total annual profits to charity but not 50%. Drug companies often donate large quantities of medicine to 3rd world countries because it's vary cheap for them to do so and the management team is not evil.