4 ms·
Initial impressions: * The pitch shapes encoded in the notation are fun and probably help learning, but I think they'd be distracting past a certain point. The
by ajdecon 14y ago
Initial impressions:
* The pitch shapes encoded in the notation are fun and probably help learning, but I think they'd be distracting past a certain point. They don't convey any extra information that the staff doesn't, and if they didn't match it's one more thing to trip up on.
* The sharp and flat signs are way too subtle, compared to the traditional accidentals. I'm not going to see those when I'm sight-reading.
* This is also true for the eighth notes and shorter. Those flags are tiny!
* No key signatures?!!
I love that someone's playing with ideas for notation, but this notation is worse for experienced musicians because it makes important information harder to see at a glance. (Yes, sure, I'd get used to new shapes, but the distinguishing marks on the page are smaller?!!)
I can't comment on whether it'd be easier to learn, but this is notation you're going to be using much longer than you're going to be learning it. Optimize for long-term usefulness.