3 ms·
I like the concept of disrupting old industries, and travel has a lot of stupid parts which should be fixed. However, I don't get the economics here as stated.
by rdl 14y ago
I like the concept of disrupting old industries, and travel has a lot of stupid parts which should be fixed. However, I don't get the economics here as stated.
I can park at Park SFO for $10/day. Off-airport parking at other airports is generally similar.
My car costs me about $0.25/mile ex-fuel to operate (depreciation, maintenance). That's pretty standard; for a new car, it's easily more than that.
I value my time after arriving back from a long flight at $100-200/hr (in general I don't, but in the specific case where I'm exhausted, I do). That's why I drive to the airport, so I have my car waiting for me on arrival. If I didn't, I'd just take BART (and sometimes do).
At 90 miles/day mileage limit, I lose money ($22.50) if someone rents my car, even including free parking ($10) and the rental payment ($10). If I leave my car parked for a month and no one rents it, I'm ahead for sure (the cost of parking). If I had a car with only legal minimum liability insurance and someone destroys it, I'm also probably ahead based on their liability policy (I hope).
Speeding/red light/etc. stuff would be totally obnoxious.
The hassle of having to remove everything from the interior of the car, trunk, etc. and then replacing it after, as well as documenting condition pre and post rental, and any dropoff/pickup hassle vs. the Park SFO or SFO Long-Term Parking options, pretty much kills it for me anyway, but those aren't universal, so I'm not including those. Maybe some people value the free car wash more than the hassle of those things.
The only way this would really make sense for me vs. parking would be if the payment were substantially higher, OR if you got some non-cash benefit for renting out your car -- such as cheap/free rental of an equivalent vehicle elsewhere. I can sometimes get awesome cars from Hertz for $20-30/day, but in other cases, it's $100. Being able to "trade" my car for an equivalent car in another city at little or no marginal cash cost would be compelling. The cars could be other customer cars, but could also be from car dealers trying to demo/sell new models or something.
- shrig94 14y agoIf executed well, we're a lot more convenient than the third party lots and even more convenient than airport owned long term parking. (EDIT: So we think the value of $10/day is quite low--it's more like an $18/day value (airport long term parking price), plus the cost of an extensive exterior and interior cleaning and the time benefits--we want FlightCar to be a free and magical experience. That's our goal.) We really messed up Edward's experience and as a result ruined the entire value proposition. Generally speaking, your car is very unlikely rented for every day of your trip and even more unlikely to have its miles maxed out (and if they went over, you're being compensated for $.35/mile). We're aiming to be the industry leader when it comes to service in airport parking. We provide free Starbucks coffee to every parker and renter along with bottled water and our black car service. We also clean the cars inside and outside quite thoroughly so that owners come back to a car in a condition better than they left it. We've been able to clean off exterior scratches and clean out heaps of pet hair and everything in between. We wouldn't be working on this if we didn't think it was a positive return for both sides of the marketplace. We really believe that having two garages at the airport, one with cars accruing parking charges and one with cars being rented for insane prices is incredibly inefficient, and we want to help consumers by changing that. We're working on improving our user experience and benefits to parkers (non-cash), so please feel free to email me, shri@flightcar.com, if you have any great ideas on how to sweeten the deal for the parkers! Cheers, Shri
- rdl 14y agoAh -- if you think of the car wash as "light detailing" vs. "automated car wash at the gas station", that's a big difference in the value proposition. (~$5 vs. ~$40). I agree convenience could easily trump the financial returns from renting the car (or even vs. airport parking costs). It looks like you have some good ideas on that front.