3 ms·
"Bitcoin is based on math and deep computer science." The tech certainly is, but the value is not. The value is based on simple supply and demand. Currently, b
by onion2k 14y ago
"Bitcoin is based on math and deep computer science."
The tech certainly is, but the value is not. The value is based on simple supply and demand. Currently, because the price is rocketing, there's huge demand. That will end when people get scared of the bubble bursting. Then the price will tumble. This is Economics 101 stuff.
The difficulty in creating an economy is not tech. That's relatively easy. The hard bit is creating a system that people can trust in the long term. That's not something anyone is going to crack overnight.
- astrodust 14y agoExactly. It doesn't matter if it was based on puppies and rainbows, the valuation of it is entirely based on speculation. There's zero intrinsic value to a Bitcoin. The "math and deep computer science" part is mostly an anti-cheating mechanism. If it was too easy to produce Bitcoins, they'd be worthless. If it was too hard, nobody would care. The mining process is an attempt to balance between these two concerns. In any event, even debased fiat paper money can be burned to heat your house. What exactly can you do with a mostly random string of data, anyway?
- nsomaru 14y agoBe careful when you use words like 'intrinsic.' It may be argued that fiat-currencies are 'intrinsically' without value either. This 'anti-cheating' mechanism is a big part of what makes a currency valuable.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> Be careful when you use words like 'intrinsic.' It may be argued that fiat-currencies are 'intrinsically' without value either. No, that's not arguable, its part of the whole point of fiat currencies is avoiding intrinsic value and replacing it with fiat. Commodity currencies rely on the intrinsic value of the commodity to provide certainty that the currency will be exchangeable for goods and services (providing a lower limit on exchange value.) They also rely on the inherent supply characteristics of the underlying commodity to control the supply of the currency. Fiat currencies rely on the issuing government (or participating governments, in the case of something like the Euro) accepting it for taxes, fines, and government services for the same purpose, as paying some or all of these is common enough that it provides demand for the currency, and rely on active management by a central bank to control supply of the currency. Bitcoin's mechanism for control of the supply of the currency are algorithmic, and much has been said about them, but the value basis is ... less clear.
- atleta 14y agoIntrinsic value is highly subjective. Paper money has about 0 (you can burn them for a few seconds, right). Gold has some uses, true, but value is (as someone said above) is simply created by demand. (Gold is worth zero if no one wants to buy gold. Its perceived intrinsic value can disappear (well, most of it) as soon as people stop thinking that its valuable. Of course, its very unlikely to happen, because we're programmed since childhood to think that gold is valuable.
- MacsHeadroom 14y agoOP made no mention of the price, for good reason. The price has little to nothing to do with the Bitcoin economy, which has just about quadrupled in size in the past two months (vs the price going up x12). Bitcoin has a lot fof potential. Sure the price is going to fluxuate in the short-term from hedgefunds and investment bankers getting into it. But even if 90% of those who got into it in the past 3 months got out right now, the price would be tripple what it was three months ago and the economy would be doing swimingly in comparison.