6 ms·
The depressing truth about web stardom
- CalmQuiet 18y ago"A more puzzling question is why the producers persist in the face of declining audience figures. " i.e., why don't "one-shot wonders" recognize themselves as such and... give up? It's a basic principle of the psychology of learned behavior: intermittent reinforcement: Having occasionally been rewarded, s/he persists in trying to be rewarded (cf: win the big one in the lottery).
- RiderOfGiraffes 18y agoThat aspect of human behavior is also mentioned here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=485797 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=485797
- Batsu 18y agoDoesn't this fall into the category of correlation and not causation? In either case, it's not the destination, it's the journey :) Being a 'star' might be important to some people, but I would argue that most will not waste their time if they didn't enjoy doing it.
- sscheper 18y agoI completely agree with you. The only thing that keeps me blogging every other day is that it sharpens my mind. It requires me to think, create and get thoughts onto paper. It's almost like a daily meditation. My wife does the same thing with politics :)
- josefresco 18y agoI hope she's debating/participating and not simply watching cable news politics.
- jgrahamc 18y agoAny chance that the if you upload a lot of content to YouTube that you are uploading ripped off content, or minor modifications, whereas if you upload a few videos you may actually be uploading stuff you produced?
- mechanical_fish 18y agoAnd in fact video producers receive higher ratings for their later videos, even as their success rate declines. Ah, so people are less successful over time if we define "success" as "sheer number of hits". Just because they're not reaching the widest audience doesn't mean that these people aren't reaching their audience. Isn't this how you want it to work? The point of publicity is to get everyone to look at your work once. But there's no way that all of those people are going to stick, unless your product is heroin. (Even then, some people are smart enough to say "no, thanks" to your first offer.) If nearly 100% of the people who first see your product stick around, the most likely explanation is not that you have invented heroin. More likely, you have not reached enough people yet: Your product is still spreading solely via word of mouth, and there are potential fans among the general population who you would pick up if you cast a wider net. (Though, obviously, casting such a net has a cost. Your true fans may accuse you of "selling out" once your ads start appearing on daytime television.) The important thing about a viewership curve is not that it declines over time. The important question is: What's the asymptotic value, and is that equilibrium number of fans large enough to keep you happy in perpetuity? If it isn't... what's the rate of decline, and is there enough area under the curve to keep you happy while you work out the next thing you want to do? The first scenario is The Simpsons. The second is just about every other successful TV series in history.
- diN0bot 18y agoreference: http://arxiv.org/abs/0904.0489 http://arxiv.org/abs/0904.0489
- dxjones 18y agoIf you look at Figure 4 in the actual article, you see that persistence DOES pay off on YouTube. Although the probability of a particular video becoming insanely popular declines, the overall probability that at least one video from your collection becomes popular continues to rise as you keep uploading them. If your first lottery ticket has a 0.01 chance of winning, but your next lottery tickets have a declining chance of winning, the overall chance of winning the lottery can continue to rise. In their example, it rises from 0.01 to approaching 0.20. Doesn't sound all that irrational, does it? Persistence increases your chance of becoming popular by a factor of 20X. It just takes many more than 20 uploads to accomplish that increase. In fact, ... when you think about it, ... it could not turn out any other way. If the probability of your next video getting you in the "top 1%" on YouTube stayed fixed, ... then EVERYONE could be in the "top 1%". ... sounds like everyone wanting their kids to be "above average" in school. It's just not possible. -- dxjones
- Encosia 18y agoIt seems like a mistake to directly equate persistence and quantity.
- josefresco 18y agoThe former suggest you weigh the results of your previous attempts and make improvements in order to increase your odds of success. The latter suggest simply applying the same approach over and over without major reconsideration.
- stcredzero 18y agoDidn't Warhol say something about this once? (15 minutes...)
- Gibbon 18y agoI posted essentially the same article by Kevin Kelly, a week ago : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=541394 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=541394 It includes a link to the original paper.