4 ms·
The cancer increase would be for launching from the ground/atmospheric use, which is a non-starter. I'm talking about use to run an orbital shuttle/tug/etc. be
by rdl 14y ago
The cancer increase would be for launching from the ground/atmospheric use, which is a non-starter. I'm talking about use to run an orbital shuttle/tug/etc. between Earth and Mars. It would never enter atmosphere, and probably be constructed in space.
The US has enough weapons that it could comfortably withdraw from the treaty, or claim that these launches are not "tests" but rather some other use.
- btilly 14y agoThe cancer increase was from fallout. If you use it within Earth orbit, you still have significant fallout.
- ars 14y agoYou don't really get fallout in the space. The fallout is from neutron radiation of the ground, which doesn't happen in space. The amount of direct radiation from the uranium that is used is actually quite small. And it would be trivial to point the exhaust away from earth. Space is full of radiation anyway, from the sun.
- btilly 14y agoI would not have thought this, but you are right. I would guess that the EMP would be dangerous to satellites, but I'm sure there are ways to mitigate that as well.
- ars 14y agoThere's no EMP in space: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5526333 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5526333
- uvdiv 14y agoThe fallout is from neutron radiation of the ground, which doesn't happen in space. The amount of direct radiation from the uranium that is used is actually quite small. Can you cite this? I think the major dose component of nuclear fallout is from fission products, not neutron activation products. For example, skimming through these appendices on dose calculations from historic nuclear weapons tests [1](e-h), most of the significant radioisotopes are either fission products, or transuranic activation products from the weapon (e.g. Am-241). The environmental activation products discussed, C-14, Mn-54, Fe-55, and Co-60, are much less significant. [1] http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/radiation/fallout/ http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/radiation/fallout/
- ars 14y agoIt's a matter of quantity - a ground burst produces enormous amounts of radioactive material. An air (or space) burst only has a few KG of radioactive material. From: http://www.fas.org/nuke/intro/nuke/effects.htm http://www.fas.org/nuke/intro/nuke/effects.htm "Air Bursts. .... there is essentially no local fallout from an air burst." "Surface Burst ..... In contrast with air bursts, local fallout can be a hazard over a much larger downwind area than that which is affected by blast and thermal radiation."
- uvdiv 14y agoI think you're misunderstanding that reference. The amount of radioactive material is not that different; the distinction is that a ground burst localizes some of it at ground zero. It creates a small area which will be an acute radiation hazard for a short time. An air burst gives a very large, diffuse, atmospheric plume. In the maps from the CDC link, large areas -- whole states (check out pages f29-f35) -- are contaminated with low levels of airborne radioactive fallout. From the isotope data, it's clear most of this is from the weapons, not environmental activation products. The doses are too low to be immediately dangerous (<1 mSv), but can have chronic health effects, as a slightly increased cancer risk.
- rdl 14y agoYou can tune your weapon to have MUCH lower fission products; essentially the smallest size fission primary you can (ideally, with boosters), and then a big fusion stage and no U-238 tamper. Conventional thermonuclear weapons are usually fission-fusion-fission since a U-238 casing for the third stage is a cheap and compact way to scale up the weapon, but that last fission stage is responsible for >95% of the fission products/long lived pollution. A "neutron bomb"/ERW/etc. is one application of the low-radioisotope weapon (and a "dirty bomb", a non-critical radiological weapon, is the other extreme). I'm still hoping fission-free fusion weapons are not possible before I can live somewhere other than Earth, since all arms control essentially rests of preventing access to fissile materials. Once you eliminate that gate, it becomes much easier for a clandestine group to build a weapon. Pure fusion weapons would be amazingly destabilizing and, if they were approximately as hard to make as seems likely, would absolutely get used by some group.
- jff 14y agoThat's not really how fallout works. Fallout occurs primarily when you detonate a bomb near the ground or the water, causing it to suck up a bunch of dirt/water, irradiate it, and distribute it throughout the atmosphere. With a fusion bomb, you could end up with some leftover plutonium from the fission stage, but that's not the primary source of fallout.