3 ms·
We've had hundreds (or thousands, if you count sub-design-yield) detonations since 1945, including several in space (Hardtack Teak and Orange, and USSR equivale
by rdl 14y ago
We've had hundreds (or thousands, if you count sub-design-yield) detonations since 1945, including several in space (Hardtack Teak and Orange, and USSR equivalents).
And lots of them were for purely posturing purposes, with little scientific or direct weapons-testing value.
The US probably could have pulled off something like Orion in the 1990s or maybe even today, since there's not a direct cold war threat. Domestic politics probably kill it, though, but if it were branded as "nuclear pulse drive" with sub-10kT pulses, it might be possible.
- btilly 14y agoYou can't launch an Orion spaceship without violating the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partial_Nuclear_Test_Ban_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partial_Nuclear_Test_Ban_Treat.... Also given the estimated 0.1 to 1 human deaths from cancer per launch (I am using Freeman Dyson's estimate here), it is hardly a politically viable vehicle.
- berntb 14y agoDidn't Dyson's son write in the book that part of the reason for the treaty's signing was internal politics to kill a competitor to NASA? 1. Those 0.1-1 dead is from a period of much worse cancer treatments than will be available a few decades after an Orion launch. 2. It is bad risk counting. The cost per life is a factor whenever e.g. roads are built and speed limits are set. ("We will get ~ X less deaths/decade if we build the motorway differently, but it would cost over our limit for $/life".) Also, just transporting materials/people when designing/building an Orion ought to be a lot more than one dead.
- rdl 14y agoThe cancer increase would be for launching from the ground/atmospheric use, which is a non-starter. I'm talking about use to run an orbital shuttle/tug/etc. between Earth and Mars. It would never enter atmosphere, and probably be constructed in space. The US has enough weapons that it could comfortably withdraw from the treaty, or claim that these launches are not "tests" but rather some other use.
- btilly 14y agoThe cancer increase was from fallout. If you use it within Earth orbit, you still have significant fallout.
- ars 14y agoYou don't really get fallout in the space. The fallout is from neutron radiation of the ground, which doesn't happen in space. The amount of direct radiation from the uranium that is used is actually quite small. And it would be trivial to point the exhaust away from earth. Space is full of radiation anyway, from the sun.
- btilly 14y agoI would not have thought this, but you are right. I would guess that the EMP would be dangerous to satellites, but I'm sure there are ways to mitigate that as well.
- ars 14y agoThere's no EMP in space: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5526333 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5526333
- uvdiv 14y agoThe fallout is from neutron radiation of the ground, which doesn't happen in space. The amount of direct radiation from the uranium that is used is actually quite small. Can you cite this? I think the major dose component of nuclear fallout is from fission products, not neutron activation products. For example, skimming through these appendices on dose calculations from historic nuclear weapons tests [1](e-h), most of the significant radioisotopes are either fission products, or transuranic activation products from the weapon (e.g. Am-241). The environmental activation products discussed, C-14, Mn-54, Fe-55, and Co-60, are much less significant. [1] http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/radiation/fallout/ http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/radiation/fallout/
- 14y ago
- schiffern 14y ago>given the estimated 0.1 to 1 human deaths from cancer per launch (I am using Freeman Dyson's estimate here), it is hardly a politically viable vehicle. Considering that one coal plant statistically kill about 70 people per year due to air pollution, I think it's more a matter of insufficient political power than the product of rational policy.
- opminion 14y agoWe've had hundreds [...] detonations None of them intended to kill other people, which is kind of the whole point of the taboo, not the detonation itself. Plus, currently there is a kind of informal moratorium.