3 ms·
It'd be interesting to see a review of Lulu that didn't seem to be mainly made of "dude with baseball cap, suddenly concerned that he might be called to account
by wpietri 14y ago
It'd be interesting to see a review of Lulu that didn't seem to be mainly made of "dude with baseball cap, suddenly concerned that he might be called to account".
To me, the emotional heart of this piece of writing is his concern with "men kowtowing". I looked at his other articles and his personal site, and I didn't see anything where his writing was half this passionate. And certainly nothing where he'd expressed concern for sexism.
I suspect if I looked into Lulu I'd also not like it. But this article is so full of the author that I really can't see the subject.
- jimzvz 14y agoWow
- jrajav 14y agoUm.... So because the author doesn't normally soapbox about this hot-button issue but felt unusually compelled to call this instance out, you're less inclined to take him seriously? Never mind that either side of that is the worst kind of ad hominem.
- wpietri 14y agoExactly. Because that, along with the article itself, suggests that the unusual compulsion is not a strong opposition to sexism. Ad hominem concerns apply to rational arguments. This piece is not cool, rational discourse. It's a highly emotional piece, written to incite emotion. Inquiring about the source and nature of the emotion that drives it is fair.
- theorique 14y agoHe probably didn't notice sexism until it became personal. Why is that wrong? Most people become activists when something personally gets in their face, rather than through some abstract idea of "justice".
- wpietri 14y agoIt's not wrong as such. It's just shallow. Hopefully it's the beginning for him of understanding sexism more deeply. I do think it's wrong for a writer, though. If you're going to set yourself up as writing an article about a topic, I think you should actually know something about the topic. This would have been a better piece if he'd made it more explicitly about his own feelings all the way through, rather than trying to make it about bigger things.