3 ms·
It's not continuous, it's pulses. But that doesn't actually matter, attach this thing to a big wheel and pulse it to run a generator. Or a few of them pulsing i
by ars 14y ago
It's not continuous, it's pulses. But that doesn't actually matter, attach this thing to a big wheel and pulse it to run a generator. Or a few of them pulsing in sequence.
But I wonder if the radiation exhaust might be to high to be practical on earth.
- arethuza 14y agoThe fusion products are presumably fairly hot - so why not use them to heat water and drive a steam turbine generator combination? [NB This is in reply to the idea of using whirling fusion generators as a means of generating power, not part of the discussion on using it as spacecraft propulsion!]
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI think the suggestion is that the fusion is achieved only around the tiny pellet, and that the fusion acts against the magnetic containment to actually propel the pellet out the back. That's my guess - which slightly beats the idea they have achieved sustainable net positive energy fusion but cannot be bothered to solve all the worlds energy problems and become trillionaires.
- lutusp 14y agoIf this idea had been reduced to practice, it would mean the end of the National Ignition Facility, which after decades of effort, has yet to produce more power than is required to start the reaction: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility If the described method actually worked, it would force a complete reevaluation of the other approaches to fusion, none of which have actually worked (in a practical sense) after decades of effort. That's why I doubt that the described method has moved beyond the theoretical phase. If this isn't true, then people would try to create a continuous-power version of the technology, in which prior energy releases and high temperatures would be used to sustain new fusion energy releases. I've been reading about fusion power research for decades, I know the problems, and I remain skeptical.
- sebbi 14y agoI think you are missing the point that this kind of fusion requires huge amounts of power. It isn't self sustained. The benefit being that you can electricity instead of chemicals to propel your craft. Mankind has been able to fuse atoms for quite some time now, the only problem remaining - for power plant usage - is becoming energy positive.
- ars 14y agoIt's actually surprisingly difficult to capture the heat energy. The energy is released as neutrons, neutrinos and gamma rays, all of which tend to escape rather than heat the surrounding area. But all of them are magnetically neutral, so I wonder how they propose to capture their momentum.