10 ms·
AT&T Pretends It, Too, Will Build A 1 Gigabit Network
- jtchang 14y agoI am so glad Google is putting AT&T (and the other broadband providers) in the hot seat. Sadly I don't think San Francisco will get Google Fiber anytime soon. Why is it we don't even have Verizon FIOS?!
- alrs 14y agoBecause the FCC ruled that wired networks are subject to network neutrality rules, and that wireless networks aren't. Verizon has every incentive to move efforts to broadband wireless.
- jordanthoms 14y agoSome apartment buildings (Including mine) have webpass which is 100mbps up and down (and in some locations 200mbps) for $50 per month. Other than that internet in SF is surprisingly bad
- kogir 14y agoOr, in my case, 10Mb down and 55Mb up. It's like reverse Comcast.
- raldi 14y agoBecause this is what happens when you try to do stuff like that in the Bay Area: http://sfcitizen.com/blog/2011/11/15/no-att-lightspeed-internet-service-anytime-soon-nimbys-win-against-city-a-stay-from-judge-harold-khan/ http://sfcitizen.com/blog/2011/11/15/no-att-lightspeed-inter...
- mschuster91 14y agoThis is just a sick joke, I hope? These fools should be banned off into an Amish-like community.
- josh2600 14y agoSonic.net proposed gigabit in SF with 170 above ground repeaters compared to AT&Ts 800+. That also was voted down. It's not a sick joke, it's San Franciscan :/. I sometimes feel like we work in a city that's all things at once: tech bastion, hipster haven, and a home to a generation of hippies. There's a lot of culture and there's a part of it that hates ugly things and a part of it that hates technology and every time someone wants to build some cool tech like city wide wifi, this is the inevitable result.
- walshemj 14y agoUm you know that city wide wifi woudl require an insane amount of AP's and backhaul - hence why wimax doesnt seem to be going any where.
- josh2600 14y agoInsane is relative, backhaul is also relative. I don't think WiMax was meant to solve the problems to which people have applied it. If you look at WiMax actual range, it's quite good, but the advertised range is at least double (hence all of the big ClearWire lawsuits). I don't think setting up city wide wifi is unreasonable with present technology. I think it's an entirely attainable goal, the things that hold it back are bureaucracy and the same individuals who hold back things like project lightspeed. But my broad point in response to your comment is that the benefit of saturating san francisco with AP's are manifold, whereas the costs and risks are minimal.
- walshemj 14y agoSf has a population of over 6 and a half million and covers 600 square Km. I woudl love to see your estimate for how much that woudl cost to build and maintain.
- josh2600 14y agoLess than 100M to implement and under 10M to maintain per year. I definitely don't think it's expensive compared to the benefits. Personally, if I'm pipe dreaming, I'd rather have ubiquitous 1gigabit fiber, which google pegged at 11Billion for almost all of the US to be covered.
- vidarh 14y agoYou have to ask why they required those freestanding boxes, instead of negotiate access to basement utility areas in buildings across the network. Boxes like that may be necessary in less built up areas, but in densely built areas they're a cost-cutting measure. Maybe it wouldn't be profitable if they had to deal with extortionate landlords, but on the other hand it'd seem likely you'd find a sufficient number of building owners that'd be happy to allow space for cheap or nothing in order to ensure great access.
- raldi 14y agoThey need 24-hour immediate access to any box. That means it has to be somewhere accessible. And they can't bury them, because they need ventilation, and the ventilation unit would have to go above ground, and would be even bigger than the utility box was.
- jff 14y agoThe NIMBYs are pretty terrible. The best part is how you won't see a single solitary wind turbine in the "bay area" proper, but as soon as you start heading up Altamont on I-580, BAM everywhere. It's ok though, it's just the central valley out there, hicks deserve it.
- mschuster91 14y agoIs it just European bias or is the US largely near a 3rd world country in terms of internet broadband access?
- 51Cards 14y agoNo, that would be us here in Canada :) Especially on pricing and caps it feels that way sometimes.
- lemieux 14y agoInternet prices in Canada are awful... Videotron is charging me 50$/mo for 10 down / 1 up and a supplement of 30$ for unlimited download... and the other provider in Montreal (Bell) has exactly the same pricing scheme... we have a lot of choices.
- josh2600 14y agoStart an ISP. You'll make a lot of money.
- samegreatsleeve 14y agoYou're kidding right? The issue is not a lack of entrepreneurs.
- josh2600 14y agoForgive me for my ignorance, but if rural telcos are building their own networks, what is to stop you from also building your own Network? Am I missing something?
- samegreatsleeve 14y agowhat rural telco is building their own network? in canada, the taxpayers built the network, then a corrupt government signed it over to a private cartel so they could charge rent. it sounds like you're making some kind of Ayn Rand free market allusion. free markets dont apply when Dagne Taggart owns the government and closes all barriers to entry so that her railroads will never have meaningful competition.
- latimer 14y agoEven if they do end up following through on this, knowing AT&T it will be subject to the same 150 GB/month cap they have on U-Verse.
- jthol 14y agoLet me just download this stuff at 1Gbps... annnnnnd we're out of internet.
- CaptainZapp 14y agoThis reminds me a bit of the situation we had in Zurich. The (city owned) electric utility had a few hundred million reserves and decided to invest it into a fiber network. Actually - since the utility was owned by the city - the decision was based on a popular referendum, which sailed through. Needless to say that the established telcos and cable providers fought tooth and nail to kill the referendum. The interesting thing was that Swisscom (the largest telco and ex-federal monopolist) argued that fiber is not necessary and too costly. After EWZ (the utility) started construction the private providers went into hyperventilation mode and started their own construction. Later the networks merged into one fiber network. The network is managed, and I think wisely so, in a way that EWZ grants equal access to private ISPs which then compete for customers. They don't act as an ISP. While in the first step construction was in the most dense areas of the city the network is now extended to the entire city. Extension was also accepted by popular referendum. Would construction not have been started by a government owned utility (well, that's us the citizens - we don't necessarily see government as the enemy) we could be sure to wait an additional 10 years until private entities would have deemed it profitable enough to step in.
- kalleboo 14y ago> The network is managed, and I think wisely so, in a way that EWZ grants equal access to private ISPs which then compete for customers. They don't act as an ISP. This is the model I see as ideal and it always baffles me why it's so rarely mentioned as an option. Make the fiber network a public grid like roads, water, sewer, power. Then sell access to private companies to deal with the connectivity, services (TV/VoIP) and support. I'd say the technology is mature enough that we don't need competition to pick what kind of network works best anymore. edit: Rephrased: I don't understand why the cities would give so much free stuff to Google for them to set up their fiber network instead of just... setting up their own fiber network that's then actually owned by the public.
- jthol 14y agoThat is simple. The city doesn't know what it's doing. They know Google does. They don't have to give any money to do it, just not charge Google to put their stuff in. Essentially they have to do nothing, get an ass-load of credit for doing it, and if it all goes wrong... well how can you blame them for trusting the company that some people literally think IS the internet?
- s3th 14y agoWhen I saw the original press release earlier today, I thought the company name was a typo. It's clear now that AT&T is making a political statement instead of announcing a premeditated expansion plan. Regardless, this seems like one of the worst possible ways to draw attention to purported "special incentives" that the city of Austin is granting Google. There is a large chance that AT&T won't come through on the plan at all--and when all this has blown over, AT&T is much more likely to be remembered for reneging on their plan than for being a proponent of fair regulatory laws.
- derefr 14y ago> AT&T's expanded fiber plans in Austin anticipate it will be granted the same terms and conditions as Google on issues such as geographic scope of offerings, rights of way, permitting, state licenses and any investment incentives. Sounds more like AT&T is expecting to make a deal with Google to resell bandwidth off Google's own fiber after Google puts up all the initial expense to lay it. That would indeed give them "exactly the same terms and conditions as Google."
- sliverstorm 14y agoHey, if they want to do that and Google will co-operate, sounds fine & dandy to me.
- tomflack 14y agoIf Google slyly becomes America's fibre wholesaler like that, I will tip my hat to them.
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoIsn't Google laying minimal fiber infrastructure because they bought a bunch of existing dark fiber years back?
- jauer 14y agoTFA talks about favorable deals for telcos. Telcos have received one-time incentives to do things that they may or may not have done, depending on who you read. The recurring incentive is usually to keep phone service working in rural areas. What Google got (at least in KC) that AT&T wants is no franchies fee (typically cable companies and fiber providers pay the town a percentage of their revenue for the right run lines), no pole-attach fees, and cheap/easy permitting. The impressive thing that Google has accomplished is not delivering Gig to the home. It is convincing cities, in a budget crisis economy, that the mere presence of gig is important enough to not only give up a traditional revenue stream (franchise fee) but also to give up cost recovery charges like pole-attach and permit fees. Apparently they still have a 5% fee in Olathe, but I'd bet they have other concessions that make up for it. This: http://techliberation.com/2012/08/07/what-google-fiber-says-about-tech-policy-fiber-rings-fit-deregulatory-hands/ http://techliberation.com/2012/08/07/what-google-fiber-says-... and this:
- sophacles 14y agoI don't know, I find it impressive that Google is doing this without begging for money, then canceling the project after doing no work on it because of hand wavy "expenses", like AT&T and their crowd have traditionally done with putting fiber everywhere.
- slacka 14y ago> "this press release confirms exactly the message that AT&T has been trying to deny for years: that when there's real competition, then AT&T will invest in making a better service." In this cyber week in Congress, I wish our loyal representatives would pay more attention to this instead of focusing on taking away our rights or ramming another CISPA/SOPA down our throats.
- noonespecial 14y agoAs I recall, the telcos already got their chance to hook everyone up with fiber with super favorable terms from governments and huge tax breaks in the 90's. They made the promise, took the money and ran. http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20060131/2021240_F.shtml http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20060131/2021240_F.shtml Google's turn.
- ditojim 14y agothat ain't right. let's ask for our money back..
- ck2 14y agoAll marketing lies. Make any company seeking such guarantees put up a $1 Billion bond that will be forfeit if they don't complete in a few years and watch AT&T back down. And for pete's sake stop giving tax deferments on the FRONT END. If a company claims they are going to make jobs or supply a service do not give them the tax break until that actually happens.
- josh2600 14y agoAll great ideas, except for lobbyists. In reality, it's probably not reasonable to force someone to put up a bond to build a network. And a billion dollars is probably an order of magnitude (or two) higher than what it'll cost AT&T to completely build out Austin. I believe google recently said they could build out most of the major population centers in the US for 11 Billion, so that gives you some context for a single city out of the top 100 metros.
- ck2 14y agoBillion is just an example of something meaningful, and they'd get it back upon completion. If not, the amount should be used to complete the network for them and then the government would own the network or auction it off. So the amount should be what it costs to build the network for the location.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- songzme 14y agoWhat's incredibly unfair is that Austin will now have 2 Gigabits of internet while the rest of the world is bottlenecked at megabits.
- cmccabe 14y agoMakes sense-- pretending to provide service is AT&T's core competency.
- seldo 14y agoThis is the really important takeaway of this piece: "AT&T just admitted that they'll offer better service if there's real competition, so how do we make sure there's real competition?" AT&T and the others have been claiming for years that they are doing the best they can and raking in huge profits; this kind of abrupt turnaround just shows what a lie that was.
- jdietrich 14y agoHere in the UK, we have a peculiar paradox regarding the rollout of fibre. We have what amounts to a telecoms duopoly, split between the old telephone monopoly (BT) and the sole national cable company (Virgin Media). BT cover every home, but Virgin Media serve only the most populous areas. BT are progressively upgrading their POTS network, while Virgin's network was FTTC from the start. BT only bother upgrading areas to fibre where they've got competition from Virgin Media, so people tend to either have the choice between two 100mbps fibre providers or none at all. The disparity in broadband speeds is growing rapidly, because the areas not served by Virgin Media tend to be those furthest from BT's exchanges and hence having the slowest ADSL speeds. I'm not normally one to advocate government intervention, but the situation seems absolutely absurd.
- jiggy2011 14y agoYes, not to mention some rural areas which have no broadband at all and are still on 56k or satellite. In some cases locals have taken it into their own hands and established coops to build their own broadband systems. Even if you have no interest in the internet, stuff like that has to hurt your house price.
- officemonkey 14y agoThat is exactly what is happening where my parents live (in upstate New York.) The local telephone company now has fiber throughout the village and a WIFI network for customers that's accessible from most places in the village. Their base-line internet service is roughly five times faster than my base-line internet service (from AT&T) in Chicago.
- ukandy 14y agoThe government targets for rural areas is a joke, and damaging to the economy. Not helped by 4G rollout 'issues'. We have a microwave link on the church tower to cover the village here. It really shouldn't be left up to the locals to manage their own network.
- ricw 14y ago
- tehwalrus 14y agoThat's a poor poker face, AT&T.
- macspoofing 14y agoI love the disclaimer at the bottom: "Information set forth in this press release contains financial estimates and other forward-looking statements that are subject to risks and uncertainties, and actual results might differ materially. "
- cloverich 14y ago> Municipalities have been giving AT&T and other incumbents incredibly favorable deals for years, and AT&T has tended to return the favor by providing the bare minimum in quality of service to its broadband customers, while focusing most of its efforts on trying to block any hint of competition from showing up. I"ve heard this a lot - I'd love to see some objective background information on this.
- talmand 14y agoThere are many news stories about such companies suing local municipalities to prevent them from building their own network because the companies refuse to service the area properly. Just pick whichever news source is the most objective to you.
- ausjke 14y agoOnce again it approves competition is good. ATT has the chance to do it years ago, sigh.
- jmharvey 14y agoIt might worth it to AT&T to actually build a 1 gigabit network to dissuade Google from encroaching on their territory in other cities. As the only gigabit player in a location, Google can charge users much higher rates than if they're one of two providers in the market. If AT&T sends the message that they're going to be in a two-player market in any location where AT&T is the incumbent broadband provider, Google might go after other markets, first. Of course, that assumes that Google is rolling out fiber to the most profitable cities first, which might not be a valid assumption.
- mullingitover 14y agoThis whole thing is really sad. Fiber is such a long-term investment in a city's infrastructure that it should be a public utility. Let all the ISPs compete to sell service over the public fiber infrastructure, don't let the infrastucture rollout languish in the hands of people who are only looking for short-term profits.
- rammark 14y agoFor those fortunate Austinites who will face the difficult decision of choosing between two gigabit fiber ISPs: AT&T is a founding member of the Copyright Alert System scheme [1][2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Alert_System#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Alert_System#History [2] http://www.copyrightinformation.org/about-cci/ http://www.copyrightinformation.org/about-cci/