3 ms·
Wouldn't this, ironically, stabilize Bitcoin, if others try to take advantage of its growth and try to bring it down again?
by mtgx 14y ago
Wouldn't this, ironically, stabilize Bitcoin, if others try to take advantage of its growth and try to bring it down again?
- fennecfoxen 14y agoIt would indeed stabilize Bitcoin, but I don't see what's so ironic about it. Short-selling and other derivatives substantially stabilize a lot of markets, popular delusion to the contrary notwithstanding.
- runT1ME 14y agoBut now there is double the incentive to artificially drop the value of BitCoin as much as possible, no? I don't know how trading bitcoins work, but won't this increase volatility both ways in addition to overal stability (taken as an average).
- derefr 14y agoYes--basically, short-selling just creates the same kind of "flight to quality" gravity that kills markets when people start to feel pessimistic about them, but pulls in the opposite direction: so now, on average, everything will "draw a straight[er] line", but moment-to-moment you'll just have price spikes that kill the short positions in the same way price-plummets kill the long positions. What Bitcoin really needs to smooth out its volatility, as far as I can tell, is HFT market-makers trading tiny amounts of BTC by the millisecond. Which should theoretically be easier with an all-digital currency--but, if done in "real" BTC, requires probably at least a million times the block-chain growth velocity Bitcoin currently has. It could still probably be done with "BTC liabilities" on a private exchange, though.
- unclebucknasty 14y agoThat's an interesting question and I think it's hard to say. If by "stabilize", you mean reduce volatility, I would bet no. I would say we could possibly see even more volatility once leverage and shorting enter the picture. But, if by "stabilize", you mean put some downward pressure on the price, then I would guess maybe or even likely. Under the traditional rules I would have more confidence in the latter than just maybe, but with bitcoin, it seems like we've long ago tossed the traditional rules.