3 ms·
> Servers bring over a tablet with a BitPay app that lets merchants accept Bitcoins as a form of payment. The app converts the dollar value of the bill into Bit
by shmerl 14y ago
> Servers bring over a tablet with a BitPay app that lets merchants accept Bitcoins as a form of payment. The app converts the dollar value of the bill into Bitcoins and gives customers a bar code...Customers would use their smart phones to scan the bar code that will deduct the amount from their Bitcoin accounts. BitPay will credit that $15 to the bar.
This is kind of counter the spirit of direct P2P of bitcoin. I'd expect the transaction to happen directly between the customer wallet and the wallet of the bar. Why is the intermediary / conversion needed at the time of the transaction?
- caf 14y agoThe bar doesn't want to price its drinks in bitcoin, and it doesn't want to hold bitcoin either. The BitPay intermediary is needed to display the bar's USD price as a bitcoin price to the customer, and to convert the customers bitcoin payment into a USD receipt for the bar.
- shmerl 14y agoPricing doesn't need to be in bitcoin, the rate can be obtained at the time of purchase, but the purchase still can happen wallet to wallet. If the bar doesn't want to hold bitcoins - that's a different story of course.
- nandemo 14y agoOf course the bar doesn't want to hold bitcoins. Rent, booze and salaries are still denominated in U$.
- shmerl 14y agoSure, it doesn't need to hold them forever, but they can manage them in their own pace, instead of instantaneously converting them to $. This is just a sign that bitcoins are still very volatile and don't have wide usage (otherwise the bar wouldn't rush to convert them instantaneously through an intermediary, but instead would find how to use them for their needs as bitcoins, converting them to $ only when needed to pay the salaries and etc.). It's still great that they even offer an option to pay in bitcoins.
- caf 14y ago"Manage them in their own pace" entails accepting exchange rate risk, at least until their inputs are priced in bitcoin. Their core business is mixing drinks, not currency speculation, so it makes perfect sense that they don't want to hold bitcoin. From the bar's point of view this is really no different to a Canadian coming in to the bar and buying a drink with their Canadian credit card - in that case, the customer is debited a $CAD amount by their bank (plus a currency conversion fee) and the bar receives $USD in their account.
- shmerl 14y ago> "Manage them in their own pace" entails accepting exchange rate risk, at least until their inputs are priced in bitcoin. That's exactly my point. Dollars are viewed (and are) way more stable and less risky at present. For real bitcoin economy to expand though, this needs to change, so more and more bitcoins are used for direct transactions, rather than for such instantaneous conversion.
- baddox 14y agoIt's not much different than any other currency in this regard. You can trade USD cash for goods directly in person, which is easy and works fine, but you can also choose to use any of various financial services built on top of USD, like credit cards. Bitcoin is still superior to USD cash in many ways, however, because the "direct P2P" transactions are virtually immune to fraud (e.g. counterfeiting) and can be done online. Of course, the financial services for bitcoin are relatively new, which means there aren't any particularly experienced and trustworthy options. It takes time and a long transaction history because the average person will trust a financial service provider—remember that credit card companies used extensive advertising campaigns in their efforts to get people to think of them as normal everyday USD transactions.
- shmerl 14y agoRight, but there is a slight difference. Credit cards work as virtual money and enable credit as an extra service attached to them. Direct bitcoin transactions are more similar to debit cards (rather than cash) in a sense that they enable virtual money and you pay from what you have (except that you don't need any service to back that up, unlike the debit cards which require banks to enable them). I.e. ideally in the bar example, one wouldn't need to use any financial services, but would still be able to pay with virtual money a la just using a card, of course for that the circulation of bitcoins needs to be more active, so bar could actually use them, instead of opting for instantaneous conversion.