6 ms·
And people wonder why some people think the government is basically a bunch of brainless fuckups who couldn't pour water out of a boot if the instructions were
by mindcrime 14y ago
And people wonder why some people think the government is basically a bunch of brainless fuckups who couldn't pour water out of a boot if the instructions were on the heel.
This is, simply put, one of the most absurdly brain-dead stupid things I've ever heard in my life. And I've heard some really stupid ideas in my life.
Whether this goes through or not, it's a perfect example of why we need to end the income tax and eliminate the IRS.
- ketralnis 14y ago> it's a perfect example of why we need to end the income tax I don't follow what this has to do with income tax, it's presumably a different benefits tax > and eliminate the IRS Well no. It's an example of one thing that the IRS can do. If you think it's silly (and I agree), it's an example of a silly thing that the IRS can do. But it's hardly evidence that the whole taxation system is broken. Assuming a government needs to be funded, I don't think eliminating the income tax would even get rid of the IRS, since it would still need revenue of some sort.
- mindcrime 14y agoMeh... I was about to reply to this and just realized I let myself get drawn into another political debate. I enjoy this as much as anybody, but HN really isn't the place for it. Let's just say I have radically different ideas about the proper nature and scope of government than a lot of people.
- ksherlock 14y agofree lunch is treated as compensation and is taxed as income.
- ipince 14y agoCare to explain why?
- mindcrime 14y agoFor more reasons than you can shake a stick at, not the least of which include the fact that not every employee receives the same value from this "benefit", and the fact that valuing it is ridiculously subjective. Add in the deleterious effect it would have on companies (who would probably just scrap free lunches altogether if this goes through) and it's hard to see it as anything other than totally brain-dead stupid.
- patrickgzill 14y agoBureaucracy's main purpose is to create more bureaucracy. As a side effect, they collect taxes or issue you your driver's license, it is just a means to the end of self-perpetuation. Eliminating the income tax and going to a much more transparent method like higher fuel taxes (everyone pays them because everyone uses transportation) or some other broadly based consumption tax, would be excellent.
- gorbachev 14y agoPlease. There is a reason why most reasonable people don't actually seriously consider implementing such tax schemes. I know it's hard for people with good lives and great salaries to understand why, but please ask the people who clean your desks next time you see them what would happen to him/her, if fuel was taxed higher.
- rverghes 14y agoWhy is it a stupid idea? Company A pays an employee $100 per day, and provides a lunch which costs the company $10. Company B pays the employee $110 per day, but the employee has to provide her own lunch. Is it really fair that Company B has to pay more tax than Company A? Compensation is compensation, whether in kind or in cash.
- nazgulnarsil 14y agoI agree, eliminate the taxes on company B.
- BrianEatWorld 14y agoThe cost of the lunch is $10, but is the value to the employee $10? The problem with taxing a product is that the actual value is unknown. In your example, taxing the lunch as $10 of income is actually giving the benefit to Company B due to the "reverse inequality of exchange". IE if you buy a $10 lunch, you actually value it more than the $10.
- anthonyb 14y agoYou could say the same thing about $10 - the value of a $10 note to (eg.) a millionaire is a lot less than it is to most people. If the employee is hungry, then they'll value lunch more. For accounting purposes though, it's $10.
- rverghes 14y agoSure, but the cash has the value of being flexible. For example, if you were looking to save money, you could brown bag a lunch from home and pocket the extra $10. That flexibility might be more valuable to the employee than the nice lunch.
- willholloway 14y agoMy favorite reform would be an end to the difference between business and personal expenses. I would like to see a tax code where all expenses were 100% deductible and only savings were taxed after an annual threshold was reached (similar to the current IRA rules). Allowing all expenses to be tax deductible would reduce accounting overhead incredibly, and would incentivize consumption and trade.
- sokoloff 14y agoThis seems backwards from what we actually want to do, but also has significant compliance concerns. It's obvious how to tax consumption. It's (fairly) obvious how to tax income. How would you tax savings? Is buying stock in a company "saving" or "consuming"? Is buying Bitcoins "saving" or "consuming"? What about gold coins/bars? What about guns and ammo? What about a collector car? Artwork? What about a house for personal residential use? What about a house for rental/income use? What about just holding suitcases of $100 bills? It seems like there would immediately spring up a system of "not treated as savings" savings mechanisms. I seriously doubt that you'd accomplish your intended accounting simplicity...
- anthonyb 14y agoI think "savings" is probably the wrong word - "profit" might be better. If I have a car to drive to work, then I should be able to claim some proportion of it as a deduction. Currently that's not allowed (at least in Australia, where I'm from).
- maxerickson 14y agoHomes are routinely taxed. They are also routinely taxed at different rates depending on whether they are owned for personal use or for renting out. There are even countries that have a modest tax on bank accounts.