2 ms·
I think it's just that there are large sections of the Islamic world where people feel they have no hope (which, largely, is accurate based on observing the wor
by rdl 14y ago
I think it's just that there are large sections of the Islamic world where people feel they have no hope (which, largely, is accurate based on observing the world around them), and so they don't value their own lives very highly, or those of others.
The problem isn't the people inherently, or the religion, as much as the situation they're in. In similarly-bad situations, other religions or cultures were used in the same way by other oppressed people.
The particularly fucked-up part of the situation is that while colonial powers and then US/USSR cold war used to be major external factors causing the horrible conditions, now it's pretty much internal -- some powerful people making other people suffer, all from (largely) the same groups. Adding energy to the system in the form of oil, other mineral, or heroin wealth keeps it self-sustaining.
- hnthrow_65321 14y agoSeems like a poor explanation given the astronomical wealth quite literally sloshing around in the Middle East, and the fact that all of the 9/11 hijackers were wealthy and educated and that many of the leaders of Al Qaida are western educated engineers.
- rdl 14y agoThe wealth in the middle east isn't particularly equally distributed, even in Saudi (especially in Saudi?). And, getting a government sinecure where it is essentially oil-funded welfare for life, if you're one of the winners, isn't character-building in the way that a middle class engineering job is in another country. Just being rich isn't going to make you better/less violent/etc. -- look at how unhappy lottery winners often are, or ghetto drug dealers, etc. The other interesting part about Iraq and Syria's Baath parties is that they were initially quite secular; in Syria, it's mainly an ethnic thing. In Iraq, it turned into Sunni v. Shia largely due to the Iran/Iraq war, but also was relatively secular before that, in the 1970s. Our nominal "allies" in Syria are actually fairly hardline Islamists (among others).