6 ms·
Wake me when someone creates an TB expansion worth having at costs that aren't prohibitive. The only thing that TB can do that USB3 can't right now is either r
by r00fus 14y ago
Wake me when someone creates an TB expansion worth having at costs that aren't prohibitive.
The only thing that TB can do that USB3 can't right now is either running multiple very high-res displays, or putting the graphics card off-motherboard.
I'd love to pair a MB Air with a "desktop dock" that had it's own graphics system and replacing all my connectors other than power and TB.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoAnd more RAM. It's be awesome to be able to dock to 128-256GB of RAM with my Macbook Air.
- mbell 14y agoUnfortunately I doubt that would work very well, even thunderbolt 2.0 is no where near the bandwidth of internal RAM and more importantly for many applications, the latency would be terrible.
- joenathan 14y agoThis is no where near fast enough for RAM, for DDR3 you need at least 50Gbps for the slowest PC3-6400, while for much more common PC3-12800 your looking at 100Gbps.
- mbell 14y ago> putting the graphics card off-motherboard. Honestly its still not very good at that. Its 'doable' but for intensive applications, it can't come even close to internal connections. For comparison a PCI Express 3.0 x16 link provides 16GB/sec in each direction to main to memory. Thunderbolt '1.0' only offers 1.25GB/sec in each direction per channel, use both channels and you get to 2.5GB/sec putting you in the neighborhood of the old AGP x8 protocol in terms of total bandwidth. Double it for 'thunderbolt 2.0' and its still only 5.0GB/sec. And then there is latency....
- wcfields 14y agoAgree with this. While the steps Thunderbolt is going is great, it's still too much money for what it doesn't deliver. I'd love to have a TB attached SAN for my Macbook Pro, but what I need is usually sufficed by FireWire 800* or USB 2.0 external drive. * Even a FW800 external drive / enclosure is many times cost prohibitive.
- mturmon 14y agoToo much money is a function of how bad you want the performance. I have a Promise RAID attached to my MBP using TB, and it's really fast -- it makes firewire 800 look unacceptably poky. It's been a long time since I measured throughput, but it's like a factor of 10. If you work with large datasets, it's a clear win.
- r00fus 14y agoHow does that compare, though to a raided SSD tied directly to the PCI board? I've been led to believe that 300k IOPS is possible using sub-$1000 gear from OCZ [1]. Combined with an agressive backup to spinning disk, this sounds like it'd scream like a monster and be stable to boot. [1] http://ocz.com/consumer/revodrive-3-x2-pcie-ssd http://ocz.com/consumer/revodrive-3-x2-pcie-ssd
- mturmon 14y agoThese two devices (external TB RAID vs. internal PCI SSD) operate in somewhat different parts of the (high end) of the bandwidth/capacity plane. Anand (http://www.anandtech.com/show/4489/promise-pegasus-r6-mac-thunderbolt-review/6 http://www.anandtech.com/show/4489/promise-pegasus-r6-mac-th...) found ~700MB/s sequential read/write performance of the TB RAID. He didn't test IOPS directly, although he did put SSDs into the TB RAID and test that (~1000 MB/s). You have to give him credit for that. In short, the sequential performance is pretty close to the real-world sequential performance of the OCZ unit. Which is quite impressive. The Promise RAID-6 I use has 8TB usable (and I got it 2 years ago). The units you mention have just 1TB usable (and no redundancy, which is a problem for big data sets). All this is somewhat academic for my use case, because I dropped my desktop two years ago when TB came out.
- wtallis 14y agoThunderbolt can currently drive only one 30" monitor. This update will allow it to drive two 30" monitors, or one 4k monitor. After this update, it will be possible to drive 4 monitors at 1920x1200, or 5 at 1920x1080, but neither of those really counts as very high resolution.
- GHFigs 14y agoThunderbolt can currently drive only one 30" monitor. Not exactly. It depends on the controller and GPU. The MacBook Air (probably the most common Thunderbolt device) can drive one. The MacBook Pro can drive two.
- wtallis 14y agoA current Thunderbolt port provides a DisplayPort 1.1a connection, which has 8.64Gbps. A 30" monitor currently means 2560x1600 at either 24bpp or (more commonly) 30bpp. Even at 24bpp and using CVT-RB, that requires 6.45 Gbps per display. The MacBook Pro only supports two 30" monitors by having them connected to two separate Thunderbolt ports, rather than daisy-chained as is possible with lower resolutions. EDIT: It looks like the provisioning of bandwidth for a Thunderbolt connection is more complicated, and it's hard to tell from Wikipedia exactly how it works. Thunderbolt and DisplayPort both support 4 high-speed lanes. In Thunderbolt, the lanes are currently 10Gbps, configured as two pairs of input and output lanes carrying PCIe traffic. In DP, they're 4 outbound lanes at up to 5.4 Gbps per lane (for DP 1.2). It appears that Thunderbolt, despite not yet supporting DP 1.2, can operate in DP mode at DP 1.2 speeds of 5.4Gbps per lane, but it's not clear if Thunderbolt supports the multiple stream transport (MST) feature of DP 1.2 that is necessary to drive more than one display over a single DP connection. If a TB cable is configured to provide two DP connections of two lanes each, then it would work, but then it seems that further daisy-chaining of TB devices wouldn't work. If Thunderbolt can drive a monitor with all lanes configured to carry PCIe traffic, that's news to me, and I want to know how Intel and Apple pulled that off.
- zaphoyd 14y agoA MacBook air with 1 current generation thunderbolt port can drive two 2560x1440 thunderbolt displays via daisy chaining.