3 ms·
According to Wikipedia [1]: Whether deflationary spirals can actually occur is controversial. Now I'm not an economist, but I have yet to see a solid, intuiti
by crazygringo 14y ago
According to Wikipedia [1]:
Whether deflationary spirals can actually occur is controversial.
Now I'm not an economist, but I have yet to see a solid, intuitive argument as to why deflation is necessarily a bad thing for Bitcoin.
Suppose the value keeps going up, and a few years from now it's at $1,000 / bitcoin -- lots of poeple have been buying bitcoins wherever they can, and not spending them. Well, at some point people will decide that the price is ridiculous, because it's all based on speculation -- suppose it's $10,000 / bitcoin. And it will either stop increasing in value, or crash a bit.
Well, I don't see how this has prevented it from acting as a currency at any point in this, since it always has a value. There are always going to be some people willing to trade some bitcoins for some price -- and that's just the price, and whether you're dealing with whole bitcoins, or millionths of bitcoins, I don't see what further consequences this has.
And when you're talking about the macro-economic level, running a whole economy on bitcoins would be a separate issue, but there could be tools to deal with that too. For example, not denominating debt or salaries or goods in Bitcoins, but in a multiple of a consumer-price-index or something, that can change relative to current Bitcoin values.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Deflationary_spiral http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Deflationary_spiral
- brown9-2 14y agoWhat you have described sounds like the opposite of a stable currency. Also, the fact that the supply of bitcoins is fixed by the population of the human race is not means that bitcoins are inherently deflationary.
- itsprofitbaron 14y agoI have yet to see a solid, intuitive argument as to why deflation is necessarily a bad thing for Bitcoin So deflation is a general decline in prices which usually caused by the reduction in the money or credit supply (in Bitcoin’s case it’s the Money Supply). However if prices are falling through deflation then, you’re not incentivised to spend because; you’re going to get a better deal tomorrow. Now as currencies are supposed to be used as a medium of exchange to facilitate transactions, spending is really important because it’s how the market participants interact with one and other (and considering Bitcoin isn’t backed by a commodity this is important). Once people are reluctant to spend then, the economy will stay depressed because, people expect deflation AND deflation will continue because the economy remains depressed. In order for an economy to get out of the deflationary trap and to counter deflation, fiat currencies can use monetary policy to increase the money supply and deliberately induce rising prices, causing inflation. Raising the prices is the essential foundation of an economic recovery because; businesses can increase their profits which takes pressure off debtors etc and an example of this is the fiscal stimulus used by the Obama Administration with the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009[1]. However, Bitcoin can only produce 25 Bitcoins every 10 minutes (which is being halved every 4 years from 2017) and this can create a liquidity trap because the injections of cash fail to stimulate economic growth – as a result, if Bitcoin is in a recession and is unable to stimulate economic growth it will eventually turn into deflation & deflation is only bad for people who cannot borrow more and unlike fiat currencies who can borrow more, Bitcoin has a fixed supply (and isn't even backed by a commodity) which means that, there could potentially be serious issues for the economy’s wealth. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvestment_Act_of_2009 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvestm...
- crazygringo 14y agoThanks for writing all that up. What I still don't understand is, > Once people are reluctant to spend then, the economy will stay depressed because, people expect deflation AND deflation will continue because the economy remains depressed. Well, if people are expecting deflation, then that expectation becomes built into the value of the currency, such that there exists an equilibrium between people expecting it to deflate further, and people expecting it do the opposite, because it's already overly valuable. I can't see how everyone would just hoard it until there's infinite demand and zero supply, and a bitcoin has infinite value. There's always a semi-stable price. And like I said, I don't see how the standard macroeconomic arguments apply, because right now bitcoin is just a currency "on the side", totally unable to affect economies on a large scale. And if it ever did reach that scale, governments could do things like force contracts to be denominated in some government-controlled ratio to bitcoins, so that the government would still be able to "control" the money supply, and increase or decrease it as desired. (That's just one crude example of how.) Just because people are using bitcoins, doesn't mean that long-term contracts have to be denominated in bitcoins. So I guess this is what confuses me about people saying that bitcoin deflation is bad. Deflation=bad arguments seem to rest on entire countries being solely dependent on a single currency, which is not the case with bitcoin. And even that became the case, it would presumably take place in a whole new way. But I still don't see anything inherently wrong with a deflationary currency, especially one used alongside "official" ones.
- itsprofitbaron 14y agoSo by the "economy" think of Bitcoin like they are a country (a really small one) and that’s the only currency for them and in some cases deflation can be beneficial to some people in an economy. For instance as I was saying in the previous comment it's beneficial for those with the cash and income streams as they become more valuable as time goes on and its good for the debtor. However, you are correct in that there is always going to be a semi-stable price (or a price floor) when the money supply starts to help create inflation and grow the economy again. In terms of how it’s bad for Bitcoin building on the previous comment, let’s pretend that people have bought coins at $200 and deflation kicks which means that, people either hoard it (to try and get something cheaper tomorrow) OR once it hits a certain level everyone tries to recover their losses and starts selling the coins which causes an economic crash to a highly volatile market (a $500k trade can usually cause a lot of issues) and the market will not level out until, there are enough buyers interested to buy back into Bitcoin.