5 ms·
So far "the internet" seems to be on this artist's side, apparently because her work was stolen by a corporation. Recent history suggests, however, that if Andy
by leephillips 14y ago
So far "the internet" seems to be on this artist's side, apparently because her work was stolen by a corporation. Recent history suggests, however, that if Andy Baio[0] or Shepard Fairey[1] had ripped her off, she would be excoriated for asserting her rights and lectured about the wonders of remix culture.
[0]http://lee-phillips.org/music/whoIsTheDick/ http://lee-phillips.org/music/whoIsTheDick/
[1]http://articles.latimes.com/2012/sep/08/entertainment/la-et-cm-shepard-fairey-20120908 http://articles.latimes.com/2012/sep/08/entertainment/la-et-...
- GuiA 14y agoWell, while Alice from "Alice in Wonderland" is now a "public domain" character, the depiction of her with a blue dress, white belt, and blonde hair with a black bow in it was very much created by Disney. In this case, the artist herself is remixing a visual design elaborated by Disney. So, yeah. It's murky, and the remix argument goes both ways.
- jlgreco 14y agoHer depiction of Alice seems like more of a potential trademark issue, while Disney lifting the design seems like a clear-cut copyright issue.
- ukandy 14y agoTenniel illustrations are in the public domain. The original work is about 150 years old. As you say, very a clear-cut copyright issue with Disney lifting the design. I'll be interested to hear the outcome of this.
- cromulent 14y agoThe similarities are much more than "blue dress, white belt, and blonde hair with a black bow in it". In any case, Disney did not "very much create" that image. Here's Tenniels from 1866. http://www.goldmarkart.com/it-can-t-go-straight-you-know-if-you-pin-it-all-on-one-side-alice-said-as-she-gently-put-it-right-for-her.html http://www.goldmarkart.com/it-can-t-go-straight-you-know-if-... Blonde hair, white belt, black bow? Looks that way to me. Blue apron? Not very derivative.
- GuiA 14y agoHa, good point (and same to the other post making the same remark below). I wasn't fully aware of Tenniels' drawings. One could argue it makes the situation a little more clear cut then.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- knowtheory 14y ago> the depiction of her with a blue dress, white belt, and blonde hair with a black bow in it was very much created by Disney. How do you figure? Have you seen the original illustrations? Because they depict Alice in essentially the same getup that Disney stylized with their own art style. However the character design (which is what we'd call it now) is essentially John Tenniel's original design: http://www.alice-in-wonderland.net/alice2a.html http://www.alice-in-wonderland.net/alice2a.html
- jrajav 14y agoI don't pretend to know anything about the relevant IP laws, but from a lay perspective I think there's a big difference between taking one piece of art and making a new derivative piece of art from it, and taking the same piece of art and making salable merchandise.
- leephillips 14y agoThat might be true, but in both my examples, the copy-and-paste artists were making salable merchandise from the works that they appropriated.
- cromulent 14y agoAndy Baio didn't make that image [0], and it's not a copy-and-paste - look at the tie for example [1]. [0] http://waxy.org/2011/06/kind_of_screwed/ http://waxy.org/2011/06/kind_of_screwed/ [1] http://waxy.org/random/images/weblog/kind_of_bloop_comparison-20100701-172352.jpg http://waxy.org/random/images/weblog/kind_of_bloop_compariso...
- leephillips 14y agoI know that Baio commissioned the art, and didn't personally create it. The decision to just take it rather than negotiate for rights was his. It should be pretty clear from the context of this discussion that I don't mean literally "copy-and-paste". The Disney ripoffs are also not identical to the source - does that mean that there is no issue?
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoSo, you think we should all grab our pitchforks and torches and go get her? What are you getting at?
- leephillips 14y agoThat we "should"? No, I'm basically on her side, although I think GuiA, in a comment above, has a good point that this particular case is murky. What I was attempting to get at is that the sympathies of the internet mob seem to depend not on the merits of any particular copyright case, but on who is doing the copying. Sorry if this wasn't obvious.
- yew 14y agoNot seeing how "it would be nice to live in a world without the current incarnation of intellectual property law" is incompatible with "but we don't, so we're going to hold you to the standards you've created". They seem imminently consistent to me.
- jlgreco 14y ago> the standards you've created And that is particularly applicable since the company in question is Disney.
- leephillips 14y agoI wish I could share your optimism, but, alas, I fear that it will take a bit more time before consistency is achieved.
- yew 14y agoI wouldn't call it optimism. Both of the 'infringers' you linked to paid plenty of money for it. I can't say that article of yours makes your point nearly as well as you might like, either. I hope it doesn't represent your general attitude towards derivative works (or just derivative works you don't appreciate aesthetically, whichever).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ANTSANTS 14y agoI've got little to add to the larger discussion, but you know, this is kind of funny: I can ignore all kinds of crap that people on the internet get riled up over, and even the occasional personal insult, no sweat, but your assessment of Kind of Bloop and the chiptune scene in general actually made me angry. There's an interesting (albeit tired -- we've been having the same conversation since at least the dawn of the sampler) question in there about where the line between "remixing" and "ripping someone off" gets drawn, but you didn't have to shit all over a subculture and genre of music to pose it. EDIT: I'll add that there is a pretty direct parallel to be drawn here to the long-running controversy around hip-hop's heavy usage of sampling. Your article, then, read a bit like someone attempting to begin a thoughtful debate about this old "remix culture vs. copyright law" issue with a characterization like "hiphop is a primitive and culturally bankrupt musical 'genre' consisting of a sad excuse for poetry shouted on top of other people's music, and its creators are crooks who appropriate the hard work of others for a less sophisticated audience." There are people out there that actually believe things like that (maybe even you?), but most of them have the good sense not to say so in public under their true identity. I'd like to think that has something to do with the common decency of not demeaning cultures that one is completely unfamiliar with, and not just fear of appearing to be a racist.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- JDGM 14y agoWhat was it specifically that made you angry? I enjoy chiptune music and listened to some of the linked samples thinking they were pretty good, but I still found the level of boldness in his "assessment of Kind of Bloop and the chiptune scene in general" quite refreshing and rather entertaining, even though I don't exactly agree with his opinion. I enjoy a good articulate rant from someone who is making it in good faith, as I believe the author was. That "most of them have the good sense not to say so in public under their true identity" only makes it all the better - the argument is usually of such passion and ferocity that it must be confronted rather than sidestepped. If your reaction is one of anger then perhaps something he said was a little close to true and you're defaulting to an emotional response in defense.
- will_brown 14y ago"Fairey settled his civil case with the AP out of court." Looks like Fairey paid up, and I imagine AP gets a royalty (and past royalties) for every sale of the image, not just a lump sum for damages. "...Fairey maintain his work fell under fair-use laws." It would have been interesting had the civil case actually gone to verdict - I tend to think a Judge or Jury would have ruled in Fairey's favor, like you allude to in your post. In ETW v. Jireh, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit rejected a right of publicity claim brought by Tiger Woods against an artist who depicted Woods and other golf legends, holding that the transformative nature of the work exempted it from right of publicity liability under the First Amendment. Thus, this is not even a fair-use defense, but a first amendment defense, and the first amendment should be even more protective in the case of political speech where Fairey's work was of the leading candidate for POTUS at the time.
- fpgeek 14y agoI could be wrong, but I strongly suspect the artist here would be thrilled to be getting a reasonable licensing fee from Disney for use of her work. Meanwhile, in Andy Baio's case, Jay Maisel was reportedly unwilling to license the photo for pixel art, period. Presuming I'm correct, that's an important difference.
- vacri 14y agoYour second link doesn't indicate any internet-derived excoriation, but instead shows an artist being taken through the legal system by AP, along with the artist obstructing the judicial process. I don't think it supports the point you're making.
- Shinkei 14y agoI didn't know the conclusion of the Fairey case and I had never even heard about the Baio case, so thanks for these links. I don't think you can generalize "the internet" in this way because the forums I read are fairly liberal and will tend to favor the underdog, 'David' or whatever allusion you want to depict the lowly, individual up against 'the man.' So, by that thinking, we should be expected to favor Fairey (vs AP), Baio (vs Maisel ) and the current article's artist (vs Disney). You may say that Maisel is not so black and white, but consider that he still represents the establishment. Just to specifically address Lee Phillips' article. He clearly has a personal bias that doesn't help his argument with lines like this referring to 'chiptune': "I don’t get it either, but if people want to create music where part of the aesthetic is that it’s supposed to sound bad, I believe they have every right to." I have plenty of fond memories to music from Battletoads, Mega Man and Final Fantasy so I think he's fighting a losing battle if he's going to try and convince people that there is no merit to 8-bit music production.
- leephillips 14y agoI understand the "rooting for the underdog" tendency, and that might explain two of the examples. But how does Maisel represent the establishment? He's just an individual artist.
- Shinkei 14y agoI agree that it's a stretch and I would not personally characterize him that way, it seems to be the perception that is being sold to the masses. I think how artists deal with these forms of 'infringement' speaks to their character. For example, I love Bill Watterson (Calvin & Hobbes), but I also think it is somewhat petty that he so angrily hides his creations from the world in any form. I mean he wasn't able to stop millions of stickers being made depicting Calvin pissing on car logos, but yet he wouldn't allow children to purchase a plush toy of Hobbes? It may be his prerogative, but when something artistic has impacted the lives of millions in such an important way, I believe that artists need to live with the fact that there will be derivative works. I mean I could argue that Warhol should not have been able to use the Campbell's soup logo based on the same reasoning in this article... I think the pixelation of the original image constitutes a greater abstraction than simply enlarging the image and changing the colors. BTW, I am adopting the term "meatspace." I love it.