2 ms·
I would actually venture the opinion that the South did have the legal right to rebel and secede. The North just reconquered the South and readmitted it to the
by philwelch 14y ago
I would actually venture the opinion that the South did have the legal right to rebel and secede. The North just reconquered the South and readmitted it to the Union state by state.
In other words, you can try to rebel. You don't have the right to win though ;)
- snowwrestler 14y agoI see what you're saying, although I'd quibble with the word "legal." It certainly seems very American to think that people have a right to rebel...that's how we got our country, after all. But I'd say that's more of a natural right than a legal right--one that supercedes the typical concept of legality in its very nature. What I meant above was more that the U.S. Constitution does not provide a power, right, or mechanism for states or individuals to violently rebel. It's certainly not the reason we have the 2nd Amendment (quite the opposite, actually).
- philwelch 14y agoSure. It's a logical absurdity to suppose a legal right to rebel, since the act of rebellion is the act of rejecting that legal authority in the first place. I would actually say, though, that the Second Amendment is likely intended to put governments at explicit risk of rebellion, especially when it comes to day-to-day enforcement. It's not so much about rising up and marching on DC when they decide to oppress people. It's more about not being able to send in the cops to oppress people in the first place, because if they do, they'll end up being shot. Even within this century, the Black Panthers used the Second Amendment to protect blacks from police brutality: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/09/the-secret-history-of-guns/308608/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/09/the-secr...
- ensignavenger 14y agoAnd used effectively in the Battle of Athens, too. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Athens_(1946) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Athens_(1946)
- rvkennedy 14y agoThey had the right to self-determination, just as the 13 rebel colonies did in seceding from Britain. But they gave up that right a-priori by enslaving an entire section of their population. The same could be argued about the American Revolution, but Britain had not raised any significant complaint about colonial slave-holding, so had no real standing from that perspective.