7 ms·
It's First Amendment material, and I doubt the Supreme Court will uphold any of these laws. The problem is that there will be problems for people in the years
by jrockway 14y ago
It's First Amendment material, and I doubt the Supreme Court will uphold any of these laws. The problem is that there will be problems for people in the years between when the laws are passed and when a good case finally makes it to the Supreme Court.
(The bit about making violating your employment contract a criminal act sounds exactly like the law that makes you a criminal for violating a website's ToS. Which has pretty much been struck down. But hey, there's no penalty for passing bad laws, so why not try? It makes your handlers happy!)
- Justsignedup 14y ago...And of course if the supreme court refuses the case...
- mtgx 14y agoThis is what I like about other countries which have Constitutional Courts that check for the a bill's constitutionality before it's passed into law. How many years does it have to pass in US before the Patriot Act, NSL's and FISA are verified by the Supreme Court? We're already into the second decade of their existence now.
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoAmericans have this persistent idea that their Constitution is somehow superior to the constitutions of other industrialized liberal democracies, when the reality is that the American system, notwithstanding amendments to fix certain practical failures, remains essentially stuck in 18th century ideas about liberty and governance.
- philwelch 14y agoYes, it's a pity we never did things like make "hate speech" exceptions to freedom of speech, ban firearms, abolish double jeopardy, or revoke this silly notion that you're not required to talk to the police. The only problem with the American constitution is that the federal government isn't very good at following it. Other than that, it's far more liberal than most liberal democracies even try to get away with.
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoThis is exactly what I'm talking about. The US has no monopoly on the right to free expression, silence when talking to the police, protection against double jeopardy and so on. It is a peculiar kind of American exceptionalism that imagines other liberal democracies suffer under quasi-tyrannical legal systems by comparison. The US Constitution's protection of the right to firearms, which actually is an outlier among liberal democracies, is also a case in point of its essentially 18th century conception of rights and governance. The Second Amendment is based on the quaint idea that individual liberties can only be secured through the constant threat of civilian rebellion and violence against the government. Nearly every other liberal democracy regulates and restricts ownership and use of firearms far more than the US does, and those countries have no more fallen into tyranny than the US has - in fact, those countries tend to have governments that are more responsive and accountable to their citizens than the US, in addition to having rates of gun violence that are orders of magnitude lower. I would respectfully submit that the common American assumption that the government cannot be trusted to do anything right is self-fulfilling.
- saraid216 14y ago> I would respectfully submit that the common American assumption that the government cannot be trusted to do anything right is self-fulfilling. This, pretty much. It has bottomed out civic participation such that the majority of civic participation comes from businesses whose engagement is about gaming the system. I admittedly do not have stats to back that sentence up, but I suspect I could find them.
- JohnBooty 14y ago> I would respectfully submit that the common > American assumption that the government cannot > be trusted to do anything right is self-fulfilling Yes. American here, and I feel the "self-fulfilling" aspect is key and is often overlooked. With such a significant portion of the country deeply suspicious of government, we steer away from government in the name of "freedom" but actually just place more power in corporations' hands. I feel as though our country is (perhaps stuck in) our awkward teenage years. You know how teenagers often resist anything teachers and parents tell them? We rail against government just because we can regardless of whether or not it's actually a good idea. In our defense, the last two presidential elections have shown a willingness of the country (particularly among younger voters) to begin to move away from some of the mistrust in government.
- zanny 14y agoI'd argue they are 19th century, since they were the first in a long line of democratic (r)evolutions. But they are still outdated. <Insert the Thomas Jefferson quote about having a new constitution every generation>
- solistice 14y agoThat's not entirely right. The American Revolution and the Founding Fathers borrowed some ideas from the French Revolution, which would make that revolution the first in line. Yes, it was major, but it wasn't the first.
- carbocation 14y agoThe French Revolution comes a full 13 years after the American Declaration of Independence, 2 years after the adoption of the US Constitution, and several months after the US Constitution was ratified and went into effect.
- Locke1689 14y agoThis should be obvious, given that the primary backer to the American Revolutionary War was the French monarchy. grumble grumble kids these days...
- solistice 14y agoThen either my history teacher told me something absurdly wrong or I simply remebered it the wrong way round. I'm really sorry about that.
- carbocation 14y agoEither way, it's nothing to worry about. Don't let this hold you back from participating in the future, by the way. Being wrong sometimes is a powerful motivator for learning.
- thisrod 14y ago
- dsfasfasf 14y agoFor your comment to not come off as xenophobic you need to provide examples and counter-examples. Otherwise your comment is not constructive and is pure vitriol.
- peejaybee 14y agoI dunno, it seemed like pretty highly-diluted vitriol to me.
- snowwrestler 14y agoIdeas don't get old, like fruit left on the counter. They're still with us because they are still good.
- saurabhnanda 14y agoDoesn't US have the equivalent of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL), like in India?
- DannyBee 14y agoThe US supreme court doesn't like facial constitutional challenges (IE challenging statutes as unconstitutional on their face with no actual injured person orset of facts) There is actually a mildly good reason for this, which is that facial challenges basically have no fact records, and involve a lot of speculation. One of the principles of judicial restraint is: Courts should neither "anticipate a question of constitutional law in advance of the necessity of deciding it" nor " formulate a rule of constitutional law broader than is required by the precise facts to which it is to be applied." Ashwander v. Tennessee Valley Authority, 297 U.S. 288, 347 (1936) (Brandeis, J.) (I borrowed this cite from wikipedia, so i didn't check it, but it looks rights at a glance). A good explanation of the list is here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashwander_rules http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashwander_rules However, in practice, IMHO, this excuse is used to punt cases more than really viewed as a valid principle
- trhtrsh 14y agoSure, but we have obvious "chilling effects" when a law is explicitly written to combat a specific recently witnessed fact pattern, and the law is unconstitutional not only in some theoretical future fact pattern, but also in its well-documented primary intent.
- DannyBee 14y agoThe argument here is that then it should be pretty easy to find a person it is impacting, and then it's no longer a facial challenge, but an as-applied one.
- jrwoodruff 14y agoBack in my journalism school days, ABC v. Food Lion was referenced as the precedent for undercover reporting. In this case, Two ABC reporters got jobs working at a Food Lion in North Carolina and taped footage of the store selling spoiled meat. Food Lion sued for unfair trade practices, fraud, breach of contract, etc. ABC was fined $5.5 million, but that was later reduced to about $300,000, according to a quick Google search. This was used to illustrate why journalists must disclose that they are journalists and should avoid undercover methods, as written in the journalism code of ethics. Sources: http://lawclassolemiss.wordpress.com/2010/04/05/food-lion-inc-v-capital-citiesabc-inc/ http://lawclassolemiss.wordpress.com/2010/04/05/food-lion-in... http://www.poynter.org/uncategorized/2125/abc-and-food-lion-the-ethics-questions/ http://www.poynter.org/uncategorized/2125/abc-and-food-lion-... http://www.nytimes.com/1997/03/09/arts/beyond-abc-v-food-lion.html http://www.nytimes.com/1997/03/09/arts/beyond-abc-v-food-lio... http://www.spj.org/ethicscode.asp http://www.spj.org/ethicscode.asp Edit: Also interesting, but not quite as relevant, is the Chiquita/Cincinnati Enquirer scandal that happened around the same time. http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/newsdesk/2011/07/chiquita-phone-hacking-scandal.html http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/newsdesk/2011/07/chiqu...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 14y agoThis is very interesting and I didn't know about it. Isn't $300,000 pocket change, though?
- jrwoodruff 14y agoOh definetly. In the Chiquita case, Gannett was willing to settle out of court for eight figures. IANAL, but my understanding is its more about the precedent set, as other similar cases will reference these judgements.
- spizzo 14y agoI don't understand why this is bad, though. In that case food lion got publicly busted and undoubtedly had to tighten standards. What's the alternative in a system where you can't engage in undercover reporting? ABC: "Hey food lion. ABC here. Do you guys sell rotten meat?" Food Lion: "no. no we do not." ABC: "Mind if we check?" Food Lion: "Sure, just give me a minute to clean up some things so you're not seeing how we operate day-to-day. I'll schedule your visit." ABC: "Huh. Everything looks above board" Food Lion: "Yes, they do look that way today. On your visit. Don't come back without notice."