5 ms·
Newsflash: it's extraordinarily unlikely that you live in a country with stronger protection of freedom of speech than the US. In fact, if you live in Europe yo
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Newsflash: it's extraordinarily unlikely that you live in a country with stronger protection of freedom of speech than the US. In fact, if you live in Europe you almost certainly don't.
- hmottestad 14y agoAny references?
- dagw 14y agoReferences to what? The fact that Europe has lots of laws restricting free speech?
- hmottestad 14y agoEurope has almost no laws. We are not like the US. The EU does enforce a bunch of laws. So does the EEA. So I would like a good example of a law from a european country that is not the UK or eastern europe.
- ubernostrum 14y agoTry publishing information about a criminal trial, or about an auction of WWII memorabilia, in "almost no laws" places like France or Germany, and let me know how it goes.
- sergiosgc 14y agoCriminal trials, in much of Europe, are protected by privacy of justice laws, until the proceedings are complete. Then, the information is free. I view that as a good thing, as it prevents mob justice on the media. Let the courts decide, on their own timing, we can analyse the result later; instead of condemning someone in the public view, only to find out later she is an innocent with a forever tarnished reputation.
- redblacktree 14y agoYou didn't address the WWII memorabilia. Also, are you free to say that the holocaust didn't happen?
- sergiosgc 14y agoI am in Europe and, yes, I'm free to deny the holocaust publicly and I'm free to sell WWII memorabilia. Portugal does not suffer from public order problems with neo nazi groups. It will take probably one more generation for Germany to be able to lift those restrictions. WWII was a big event, and it is emotionally charged still today. I think their approach to limiting free speech is an extraordinary measure to deal with extraordinary circumstances. It is not an easy decision, was heavily discussed among Germans, and is widely accepted by the population. While not ideal, it's acceptable and well managed. And limited in time.
- mayneack 14y agoSo which country are you talking about then?
- jasonlotito 14y ago30 seconds into Wikipedia: > So I would like a good example of a law from a european country Germany "Insulting of Faiths, Religious Societies and Organizations Dedicated to a Philosophy of Life if they could disturb public peace (Section 166)." On topic, Switzerland tried to censor essentially the same thing (livestock farming practices) and was sued for it. They lost.
- mattsfrey 14y agoAs despicable as it may be, you will be jailed in Germany for espousing anti-Semitic views or denying the Holocaust etc, and in Britain you can be jailed for "hate speech" e.g. making racist statements. Personally I think it is insane that you can literally be jailed over speech, regardless of how unsavory it is. Canada has the hate-speech law as well.
- Uchikoma 14y agoIf you live in a free county, say fuck on TV. If not don't lecture others about free speech.
- aegiso 14y agoYou can do this in most parts of the Western world. Make your own TV station and say "fuck". Nobody will stop you. Freedom isn't the right to inject arbitrary programming into someone else's commercial enterprise.
- Uchikoma 14y agoIn most countries you can say what you like if no one can listen to it (imagine a desert or the largeness of the taiga). If the commercial enterprise is the only way that people can hear you, and those oligopolies censor you with a peep or take down your website for commercial reasons, it doesn't matter your government is strong on freedom of speech.
- nkozyra 14y agoWe have plenty of channels using the word "fuck" on tv at any given moment. In fact, it's highly likely that you regularly watch a few of those shows.
- Uchikoma 14y agoActually no. I prefer shows from the UK.
- thisone 14y agoAfter the watershed in the UK, strong language[1] may be used on telly. [1, contains actual strong language]http://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/page/guidance-language-full http://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/page/guidance-langu...
- nkozyra 14y agoYou don't watch a single US-produced television program. I believe this.
- linuxhansl 14y agoThat's nice and all. But it didn't help in this case, didn't it?