4 ms·
While the $500/month and milage figures can be misleading, they failed to acknowledge the upside: - the savings from fuel/maintenance/etc are very real, not wi
by ricardobeat 14y ago
While the $500/month and milage figures can be misleading, they failed to acknowledge the upside:
- the savings from fuel/maintenance/etc are very real, not wishful thinking. The math is true for total cost of ownership
- no downpayment due to the tax refunds
- guaranteed buyback, not something you'll find anywhere else
In the absolute worst case it's a standard lease + buyback guarantee, so how can it be "expensive"?
- vacri 14y agoNo fuel costs? What about the eventual battery pack replacement? That's not cheap. Similarly the buyback is only for a very short window of ownership. It'll be interesting to see how they remind owners of this window - will it be months in advance, or will it be "Hello, as of today..."?
- gregpilling 14y agoSome cost information about Prius battery packs (not a Tesla, but relevant) http://www.tirebusiness.com/article/20121120/NEWS/121129994/replacing-hybrids-battery-not-as-costly-as-you-think http://www.tirebusiness.com/article/20121120/NEWS/121129994/...
- vacri 14y agoThe Tesla batteries are more expensive - at around $10k a pop, it's not so trivial http://green.autoblog.com/2012/11/30/tesla-adds-replacement-battery-pack-costs-to-price-increase-deta/ http://green.autoblog.com/2012/11/30/tesla-adds-replacement-...
- darklajid 14y agoI consider the ad/program very fishy (especially the 15.000/12.000 mile part), but I don't get your point: Are you really saying that you'd replace the battery pack on that car? In three years, starting with a brand new one? Or are you talking about keeping that car afterwards, ignoring the buyback option (and why would you do that)?
- ErrantX 14y agothey failed to acknowledge the upside Looking at it, it's Tesla that failed to emphasise these benefits properly. For a firm that is supposed to be innovative and disrupting the industry, this "deal" looks like standard car salesman fud. The only innovative thing is the buy back scheme, which is a little lost beneath the $500 stuff. They'd be better off saying; look, the Tesla S will cost you ~£1,000 per month, but based on what you've entered the best alternative you could have would be $600/mo car, with $400/mo fuel cost (maybe pick some example cars in that price range to compare against directly). And emphasise the ability for you to get a premium car for your money. In fact; this true cost of ownership thing could have worked if they hadn't stamped a big $500 on the front of it. I understand why they have done it this way - fuel costs aren't a fixed cost for most people (by which I mean, you probably couldn't recall offhand exactly what you pay per month, or when you pay it) and so is a cost which people don't appreciate as much as their credit lines. But, still.
- cube13 14y ago>- the savings from fuel/maintenance/etc are very real, not wishful thinking. The math is true for total cost of ownership No, it's really not. If I'm paying $1200/month for a BMW, and the cost of gas+maintenance is $400/month(ballpark), then my total cost per month is $1600. If I'm paying $1200/month for a Tesla, and the cost of maintenance comes out to $200/month, then my total cost per month is $1400. The cost of gas should not be subtracted from the Tesla's cost, because that cost is $0. It can be used as a comparison point between the BMW and the Tesla, in which case the BMW does cost $200 more per month than the Tesla, but it absolutely cannot be subtracted from the Tesla's cost.
- pbreit 14y agoIf you're comparing a $1200 BMW lease and a $1200 Tesla lease, you either need to add the gas costs to the BMW or subtract them from the Tesla. Duh.
- adestefan 14y agoGuaranteed buyback is pretty common on leases on luxury cars.
- pc86 14y agoIsn't guaranteed buyback part of the definition of all leases, not just on luxury cars? Every lease I've been a part on (none luxury) has the buyback price in the contract.
- ricardobeat 14y agoIn a lease you don't own the car until it's fully paid, there is no buyback at all.