2 ms·
I wonder if there's a fancy (latin?) word for someone who attempts to defeat someone else's argument by making points which actually reinforce the opponent's ar
by rdl 14y ago
I wonder if there's a fancy (latin?) word for someone who attempts to defeat someone else's argument by making points which actually reinforce the opponent's argument.
e.g.: the "more of the Earth is dangerous to walk today with an iPad than in 1950 with a typewriter" is patently false. Anywhere in USSR, China, etc., a white man with a typewriter would be pretty doomed. In a lot of colonial areas, too. Now, outside North Korea, it's crime which is the only real threat.
There are definitely parts of today which are worse than 1950, but the big problems are the higher derivatives -- growth slowing, and rate of improvement going negative, or at least rate of growth of rate of growth going negative) -- not absolute status.
In the US, being a black man with a typewriter might have been a serious problem in large areas in 1950, too.
Mencius is generalizing, incorrectly, from the horrible anti-growth, anti-civilization policies of San Francisco (and California, and to some extent, the US) and claiming they're universal.