3 ms·
I think individual copyright is reasonable for one's lifetime. I'd be ticked if somebody used my photos from 10 years ago for profit. Corporate or collective w
by wpietri 14y ago
I think individual copyright is reasonable for one's lifetime. I'd be ticked if somebody used my photos from 10 years ago for profit.
Corporate or collective works, though, I agree. I think a 7-year expiration would be fine. I expect that approximately zero investment decisions on new movies or TV shows turn on the money they expect to make in year 8. And even without copyright, modern studios are adept at producing new versions and higher-end editions that would get new 7-year terms.
- darkarmani 14y ago> I think individual copyright is reasonable for one's lifetime. What is individual copyright? It becomes debased if you are saying it cannot be sold to corporations. Lifetime is a ridiculous capricious standard.
- wpietri 14y agoI'm ok with saying it can't be sold. Note that a lot of writers, for example, don't sell copyright outright. They instead license somebody to be, say, the US hardback and paperback publisher for their work. A lifetime standard is only as capricious as life itself. Given that the laws are made to serve human needs, I'm ok with it drawing a distinction between serving living ones and dead ones.
- dredmorbius 14y agoAnd how are we to know who the author of a photograph was, and or when s/he died? Which is, actually, pretty much precisely the issue with a large number of works presently under copyright: their owners cannot be identified and their copyright status not determined. These are the so-called "orphan works".