3 ms·
I'd disagree, I'd say these are not the underlying problem, they're symptoms. The underlying problem is the disengagement of the electorate and the horrible pr
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
I'd disagree, I'd say these are not the underlying problem, they're symptoms.
The underlying problem is the disengagement of the electorate and the horrible process of running a campaign. There are lots of reasons for those things but if you want one big villain to point a finger at, then it should be the media. The media have turned elections into a scandal-driven celebrity-driven mess, almost completely divorced from the issues. Sane people avoid running for office partly because of the horrible negative impact the media will have on their lives.
And then you get a process where good candidates are actively driven away early and where nothing of substance is seriously discussed in the media. And we wonder why the system is full of narcissistic glory seekers who think they can get away with anything.
- wvenable 14y agoWhat you're saying is the underlying problem is human nature. I could agree with that. But you are not going to change human nature.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoHardly. What I'm describing is a dynamics problem. Right now we are at one equilibrium point due to various factors, many of them related to the particular nature of the popular media today. However, there are other equilibrium points (many of them more desirable) which are within our reach if certain changes happen.
- wvenable 14y agoThe media reflects human desire. Elections are a scandal-driven celebrity-driven mess because that's what people watch. This is not unique to our time in human history either. But, like all things these days, media so much more efficient, centralized, and responsive.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThat's a simplistic way of looking at it, and it's not entirely untrue, but it's also not the whole truth. The media represents a reflection of human desire filtered and lensed through the particular business models and technological limitations that reign. And the distortion that has been caused by those things, especially ad driven broadcast media, has had a huge impact. I don't excuse the electorate their responsibility in this either but the impact that the media has had on the process has been enormous and in most ways largely negative, especially over the last half century or so. As technology changes, as business models change, as expectations change we may see some big differences in the interface between candidate campgaigns and the electorate but it's too soon to tell how all that will shake out and whether it will lead to an improvement or worsening in matters.