4 ms·
> The second storm is that the Framers of the Constitution set up our system to vote for individual politicians in individual seats by first-past-the-post votin
by JoshTriplett 14y ago
> The second storm is that the Framers of the Constitution set up our system to vote for individual politicians in individual seats by first-past-the-post voting.
> The problem here is that we have a two-party system in the first place, because that is a fixed point of the voting process and the system converges to its fixed point over iterated voting.
For more details on this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law
"plurality rule elections structured within single-member districts tends to favor a two-party system"
We could fix so many problems with a sane voting system, but it remains one of the most difficult things to change. Between the current system having elected everyone in a position to change it, the public perception of "one person one vote" as the most fair rather than one of the worst systems in common use, and the most popular alternative system being one of the only worse ones, I don't know if we'll ever manage to move to a better system on any large scale.
- dllthomas 14y ago> the most popular alternative system being one of the only worse ones Which is this?
- JoshTriplett 14y agoInstant runoff voting. Ask everyone for a ranked list of preferences, then completely ignore those preferences and only look at everyone's top choice unless their top choice has been eliminated. Numerous inherent problems, notably non-monotonicity, where voting a candidate higher can cause them to lose. The biggest practical problem with IRV: it encourages people to vote for their preferred third-party or independent candidate first followed by their lesser-of-two-evils choice (common examples using US political parties: Green>Democrat>Republican or Libertarian>Republican>Democrat), but IRV then ignores the preference for the second choice over the third, which means voting for a third-party candidate still risks "throwing your vote away" and having your greater-of-two-evils win. So, IRV not only breaks fundamental properties that any sane voting system should have, it still doesn't actually address the single biggest problem we have with voting systems, and worse yet it pretends that it does. I'd advocate approval voting if you need a system that's simple to use with existing infrastructure and doesn't require much explanation, or Condorcet if you have no infrastructural or political concerns blocking you from choosing the best option.
- cpeterso 14y agoI like the simplicity of Approval Voting, but the optimal voting strategy is still to vote for only one candidate.
- dllthomas 14y agoThat's not been my understanding. Citation?
- cpeterso 14y agoThe problem is that if your candidate preference is A > B >> C and you vote for A and B (and not C), you might cause B to win, even though you preferred A. The tactic for just voting for candidate A is called "bullet voting", according to [1]. An interesting analysis [2] of the 2007 French presidential election claims that Approval Voting was the voting system that was second least vulnerable to strategic voters (behind the authors' own voting system, of course :) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Approval_voting#Strategic_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Approval_voting#Strategic_voti... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tactical_voting#Approval_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tactical_voting#Approval_votin...
- dllthomas 14y agoHmm, I don't agree that IRV is worse than FPTP, but wholeheartedly agree that approval is much better.
- dougk16 14y agoOne system that I've been pondering lately (maybe it has an official name), is that you directly choose where a portion of your tax dollars go. So on your tax return, 50% (just pulling a random number here) automatically goes to the government as it does now, to spend as they see fit. The other 50% is yours to spend, so to speak, within the constraints of maybe a few dozen pre-selected options. If you want it all to go to the military, then that's your call. Some to infrastructure, and some to healthcare, then, boom, done. In an ideal system, you'd have 100% control, but you can only trust the public so far. Which brings up the point of whether one of the basic theories of "pure" democracy is sound: that the public can rationally govern itself. I don't think current democracies really prove it one way or another, but if the theory doesn't hold water, then my idea would probably be a disaster. Fine-tuning the percentages could yield some interesting results though, effectively reducing the importance of who gets elected in the first place.
- mortenjorck 14y agoWhat you're proposing is a specific implementation of direct democracy. It sounds nice, but it's fraught with the very same problems that representative elections face; every tax option would have its own campaigns with distortion-filled ads, people would likely vote to funnel vast amounts of money toward things that actually don't need it based on emotionally manipulative ads they saw... I'd rather try to fix representative democracy than experiment with direct democracy.
- dougk16 14y agoI don't see it as necessarily replacing representative democracy, but complimenting it, giving people more of a say in how things are done on top of traditional voting. If I could explicitly choose how even 5% of my taxes were spent, that would give me a very tangible feeling of influence that I just don't get from voting, at least at the higher levels of government (as an american). It would also push me to do my homework about issues a lot more, but that might not translate to the public at large. Agreed about the potential for the system to be hacked by powerful entities though, perhaps even worse than it is now...tough to get around that one.