5 ms·
Not enough. If something can predictably end in disaster and horrible things and someone does it anyway, that person is just as evil as if they had planned it f
by scarmig 14y ago
Not enough. If something can predictably end in disaster and horrible things and someone does it anyway, that person is just as evil as if they had planned it from the beginning.
If someone throws rocks at oncoming cars, you can't claim innocence because "I didn't mean to kill a family in a car crash!" If you invade an oil-rich Middle Eastern country and cause half a million excess deaths, it's just as bad as if you personally murdered each and every one of them.
- omonra 14y agoMeta advice - there is no need to turn every discussion into one about Iraq war. On the actual statement - I disagree 100%, but we're talking ethics, so rational arguments can't go very far :)
- GHFigs 14y agoDo you consider legal systems which distinguish between degrees of culpability to be unethical?
- sesqu 14y ago> you can't claim innocence If you read very carefully, you'll notice that person you're replying to was delineating between evil and culpable.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoNo, we don't say that drunks are evil when they get drunk and then drive their car over someone. We do still throw them in prison though.
- duncan_bayne 14y agoWe? You might not, but I certainly do.
- omonra 14y agoLet me explain the problem here. What you are doing is diluting the 'evil brand'. If you call a drunk driver evil, you have nothing left for the likes of Hitler and Pol Pot. What are they then - double evil?
- duncan_bayne 14y agoIt's a spectrum. It's possible to be 'slightly evil' or 'very evil', or - in the case of Hitler or Pol Pot - 'one of the most evil humans who ever lived'.