3 ms·
I think this is a really revealing story. Not revealing as in what the French Government were worried about specifically but as in the changing of the world.
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
I think this is a really revealing story. Not revealing as
in what the French Government were worried about specifically but as in the changing of the world.
Firstly the grey world of interesting classified information - it has long been the domain of Janes' Ships and similar publications - who themselves had been "trusted" not to go too far, and only occassionally (as in the reveal of the Stealth bomber as an airfix kit in the late '80s) does it come to mass public attention.
This resulted in a grey world where secrets were not actually secret - just private.
Secondly - the loss of privacy. We worry about it for individuals - but it is happening to governments too, and faster. And they, like us, have not accpeted the new reality - there is no privacy. Facebook can determine if you are having an affair, are gay or ill. Combined tracking of sites and queries can reveal almost anything about ourselves and our medical conditions. Concerned your employer might know you are rethinking your sexuality? Don't Google "gay bars". Don't friend anyone. Remove the battery from the iPhone before going out for the night.
The same goes for governments - if it is not a secret, it is
open. And it is not a secret because you say so - its a secret because no-one knows.
Thirdly this leads to a simple choice - decide on the things you are going to keep secret. And keep them secret with all the resources of the State. This clearly does not work in the "I say that is secret and you will now forget it" approach taken here. It works in the not F$%king telling anyone sense.
Fourthly - Most things will be open - its not feasible to hide a 100ft tower in the middle of the French countryside.
You cannot keep a plane secret. You cannot keep a prison secret. In fact there is not much in an open andinquisitive society you can keep secret.
What does this leave? I am not too sure. Secret rendition flights are monitored by plane-spotting enthusiasts and soon will just be a google-satellite search away.
I think it will be a better world - less secrecy usually means better function, but there is a really big threat - the tempting way to keep things secret is to keep everything secret. Shut down the open, democratic society. Shut down inquisitiveness. Piece by piece.
And we do need to fight that at each and every turn because until governments get it - this is their default, tempting solution. Fighting terrorists? Lets torture some. Nuclear strike warning network under threat? Put wikipedia under French control.
My only suggestion is as follows: define National Security. Something like a reasonable belief that this things will threaten to destroy 2% of GDP or 1000+ deaths of citizens.
Embarrassment to Politicans? Loss of a couple of agents? Not likely. So when someone quotes National Security, people listen. And if you quote it for a wikipedia article - woe betide you.
If we do it right we shall slowly find that like online security, you get it right by actually being secure.
Lesson here - security by secrecy, is no security at all.
- tripzilch 14y ago> And we do need to fight that at each and every turn because until governments get it I read an interesting article somewhat related to this: http://krypt3ia.wordpress.com/2013/03/22/digital-natives-digital-immigrants-exo-nationals-and-the-digital-lord-of-the-flies/ http://krypt3ia.wordpress.com/2013/03/22/digital-natives-dig... It uses Anonymous and Wikileaks as examples (which you may or may not disagree with), but I'm linking it for the general discussion about a sort of digital generation gap, how the "governing class" of people hasn't caught up with this digital era quite yet.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoTo be fair, its not just the governing class - I don't think anyone really gets it - the almost total loss of privacy for any digital "native" is stunning. This is a little mental exercise for me so bear with me please. Imagine that all the digital footprints I leave are available through nice open APIs and easily accessible (its not, it wont be but...) Then I know that these are collected without any malicious or surveillance intent: 1. Physical location - iPhone collects this every 5 mins by default. Thats almost everything you need right there. I also log into different wifi hotspots, duck in and out of cells. You can infer an enourmous amount about me by knowing where I am, and even more by knowing who is there with me. My sex life, my business deals. 2. Interests - google searches for itchy skin rashes, my debit and "loyalty" cards with costa coffee and the supermarkets who know what itch cream I just bought. Do i have a cat - I buy cat food at Tescos so its a good guess. One of my two cats just died, which is very sad, but Tesco will know soon as my purchases halve and stay that low. When I buy puppy food Tesco can sell me pet insurance. 3. Networks - who I email (gmail knows all), who I phone (skype, cell provider), Facebook, linkedin, and most insidiously this cross-website-cookie business that is coming up (there is a name for it but basically how ad networks know to show me ads on different sites). If my iphone and one of my contacts iphones meet up, am I preparing to leave my employer? Would you want to know who is in the same location as Google's HR people if you were Zuckerberg? 4. Real world monitoring - CCTV is too poor to convict bank robbers most of the time, but Stanford did a study where a good camera could identify faces and match them to Facebook photos 1 in 3 times. You know the bit in CSI:NY where they search for the baddie and two dzoen photos flash by and suddenly they have an address. Thats real. Just not in neon blue lights with good looking lab assistants. 5. travelcards and train tickets, Uber taxi cab bookings from my mistresses flat to my wife's house. (NB I dont actually have a mistress but you get the point. <- you see the paranoia is getting to me, just in case my wife reads HN :-) I could go on, but really, all this is starting to fall into place - I could happily do an Research MSc on pulling these sources together... Anyway - privacy, gone. And that leaves us with two circles in our Venn diagram of life. Anything that can be found out by someone somewhere in the world , and if there is anything left over it is a secret. Oh and I think my Phd would be on inference of privatives - that is being able to spot the "black holes" in a persons digital footprints that tell you something they want to keep secret is going on. Really, if the Intelligence Services lived up to their names, this is the stuff they should be eating up. (And those vast NSA computer farms....oh yes, of course :-)