4 ms·
> App should just save automatically. Oh god please no. Apps that save automatically are the worst idea ever. I want to be able to make exploratory modificatio
by kstenerud 14y ago
> App should just save automatically.
Oh god please no. Apps that save automatically are the worst idea ever. I want to be able to make exploratory modifications, and then commit to disk AT A TIME OF MY CHOOSING. The computer doesn't know what I'm thinking, and it can't tell the difference between "messing around" content vs "serious" content.
I can see it now: I hit undo a bunch of times to get back to a previous state, copy some content that I wanted to bring back, then redo a bunch of times to get back, except I fatfinger it and hit paste by mistake. Now my whole redo path is gone, and I can't even reload to the state I was at before hitting undo thanks to the braindead program that "helpfully" saved my document behind my back.
Or even worse: I make some exploratory changes, then decide after changing a LOT of things that it won't work. The app crashes/the computer dies, whatever. I reopen the app and it's saved all the changes I don't want anymore. Maybe if I'm lucky it would have saved an undo path (unlikely), but even then, how far do I have to undo to get back to the sane state I was in?
Save means "I'm sure this is what I want. Persist these changes".
- csihar 14y agoPersonally, I think in a perfect world there would be a more widespread distinction between "save" (something that happens automatically whenever changes are made, to "save" the data from some unexpected calamity like power failure) and "commit" (what you're talking about, which most people think of as "saving"). I doubt it would realistically catch on any time soon outside of tech circles, though, due to the confusion it could cause the average user - "New, open, print, commit, exit... now where the hell is the damn save button?!"
- kybernetikos 14y agoActually, it's the concept of 'save' that is unintuitive. The EPOC systems just kept your data, and it's one of the nice features that sublime gives you. In an ideal world, a document would keep its entire change history as a graph (not just a single line), and you wouldn't 'save' a copy, you'd name a particular revision of it so that it was easy to get back to later.