4 ms·
Another wasted 'investment' by the government in so-called green energy. Between the billions of dollars wasted on Solyndra, Fiskar and that cohort, we could ha
by briandear 14y ago
Another wasted 'investment' by the government in so-called green energy. Between the billions of dollars wasted on Solyndra, Fiskar and that cohort, we could have cut taxes and made it easier for successful companies to grow and expand. Instead we subsidize losing products while increasing the regulatory and tax burden on small businesses making it an exceptionally difficult growth environment. Electric cars might be nice in theory but their environmental impact is far worse than the normal cars we have today. The components in the batteries for instance produce far more pollutants in ther manufacture than a gasoline car produces in 5 years. Yet, electric cars "feel" good despite the irony that they do nothing to improve the environment.
- tstactplsignore 14y agoWow, this is the most uninformed post I have ever read on HN. 1. Government investments in alternative energy have been extraordinarily successful: http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=10165 http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=10165 To quote: "the report examines 17 R&D programs in energy efficiency and 22 programs in fossil energy funded by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). These programs yielded economic returns of an estimated $40 billion from an investment of $13 billion." B. The Department of Energy's loan program has been an overwhelming success; failure rates have been lower than expected. http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/11/21/1038907/-Solyndra-accounts-for-less-than-2-of-the-DOE-s-successful-Loan-Program http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/11/21/1038907/-Solyndra-a... C. Electric cars have an overall lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plug-in_electric_vehicle#Air_pollution_and_greenhouse_gas_emissions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plug-in_electric_vehicle#Air_po... And, you are missing the whole point. As the grid becomes completely generated by renewable, then the carbon footprint of electric vehicles will be drastically reduced.
- yekko 14y agoNo, it is proven a total waste of taxpayer money. It did however made a few insider super rich.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoProof please.
- rdl 14y agoI'd prefer that the government tax bads/externalities vs. trying to encourage good, though -- a fossil fuel tax which is small but constantly increasing would be the single best environmental and energy-independence policy the US could have. (I'd also consider a tax on fossil fuel imports on top of that, and surtaxes on certain means of extraction to cover the environmental risks and other externalities, but a lot of that could come from mining fees from DoI -- and, the is a good case for "use up the foreign and low-cost sources first, retaining US reserves longer"). If the tax goes from 5-10% now to something in the thousands of percent over 100 years, it would lower fossil fuel use even as efficiency increases, while encouraging alternate fuels. The only losers would be primary producers (and I guess refiners, etc.) of fossil fuels; broad-spectrum energy companies should do ok since other forms of energy are still available and would gradually replace fossil fuels. There is not a shortage of capital. It's just that right now, energy investments in new technologies aren't always viable. Creating an escalating tax would instantly make a lot of new energy projects viable, and private capital would be happy to make loans/equity investments/etc.
- loganfrederick 14y agoFor anyone who reads this comment and is interested in this concept, it's economic academic name is "Pigovian Tax": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax
- rdl 14y agoPigovian taxes are just the "tax externalities" part. I think it's just as important that it be operational on a long term scale, with a steady and predictable increase, to influence decisions. It would be unfair to tax a company overnight at a high rate for this stuff, because it would strand a lot of current investments. Replacing capital goods 20y ahead of schedule might actually have an environmental cost higher than doing so in 5-10 years, since there's a lot of energy and other pollution embodied in the capital goods. It also picks winners and losers based on something which wasn't made clear to people in advance. Just as bad is saying "in 10 years, we're going to heavily tax or ban X", which would cost industry (say) $1t. "Good" participants, say half the market, spend $500b fixing things. "Bad" participants spend nothing on remediation but $10b on lobbying and then strand the $500b improvements made by the "good" participants. In the US, it would essentially require a treaty or constitutional amendment to bind the government to a long-term plan which might otherwise be overturned through lobbying. An escalating tax at least has the benefit of being minor pain up front, and viewed as "fair", so industry is more likely to cooperate. It's not worth going to the mattresses over a 5% tax, particularly if it takes an immediate ban or 50% tax off the table. Over time, the revenue stream will become important to the Government and to other positive government programs, so it'll be harder for industry to lobby to overturn it. At most, they might be able to lobby for a "temporary" freeze at a certain level.
- balloot 14y agoHearing Republicans hyperventilate about Solyndra et al drives me up a wall. Private VC firms invest all the time in companies that fail, but somehow the government is supposed to have a 100% success rate in its VC investments? Please spare us your concern.
- barry-cotter 14y agoThe government should not be in the VC business at all. It gets its cut of all economic activity so for a government controlling as much of global GDP as the US grants like DARPA gives are justifiable. Politically motivated "VC" is not. If you care about CO2 emissions the corn ethanol subsidies are bullshit and for much the same reasons so was Solyndra. Both are great examples of doing it wrong.
- zhaphod 14y agoYou know what. I will take 100 failed Solyndras over one war of lies and death and destruction.
- cmccabe 14y agoBecause the alternative to funding Solyndras is clearly wars? You do realize the disastrous ethanol subsidies were expanded during the Bush years, right? There's a lot of blame to go around for everyone on Capitol Hill. I don't see a problem with the kind of research Obama wants to fund, but the money should go to universities producing publicly available research.
- zhaphod 14y ago>> Because the alternative to funding Solyndras is clearly wars? What I meant was that it is important to have perspective. My problem is that Solyndra and Tesla are being held to a different standard altogether when it comes to Government spending. I am sick and tired of people complaining about these companies getting loan guarantees. Instead of looking at these loans in isolation they should look at the percentage of successful loans/guarantees made by the DoE. When you look at it from that perspective, money spent by DoE is the best bang for buck the Govt has got. We will never have a perfect scenario for Government spending. We should encourage innovation wherever it is happening be it a private company or a public entity as long as it fits in the overall strategy of moving the country forward. Upside to a successful Tesla cannot be valued in just dollars.