2 ms·
> CO2 is not a rare chemical. Never said it was. The point is, that you can just pull it out of the Martian air in industrial quantities. > We don't know enou
by stcredzero 14y ago
> CO2 is not a rare chemical.
Never said it was. The point is, that you can just pull it out of the Martian air in industrial quantities.
> We don't know enough about Martian soils to be sure that we can grow crops there.
Many experts would disagree.
> All successful settlements of Europeans in the new world had some economic purpose for existing.
Yes, there would be a considerable initial economic barrier. But given the potential payoff, and that it's well within the budgets of current major powers, it's bound to happen. Just a matter of time and political will.
> Even something like light bulbs would be hard to do.
With current tech, we need a population of about 500 million to sustain a comparable technological infrastructure. This is going to go down with advances in technology, however.
> None of this is to say that I don't want to see permanent human settlement on other planets, but I think that comparing it to the settlement of the Americas is very unhelpful.
Because you're mistakenly using the analogy as a descriptor of difficulty. You're right that it's much more difficult in both an absolute and comparative sense. However, it's meant entirely as a descriptor of potential payoff. Compare the investment involved in establishing initial colonies and the value of interventions that resulted in British hegemony over North America with the value generated by the US economy. For English speaking western civilization, the payoff has been astoundingly huge.
I strongly suspect that there are people in China and other emerging powers who are well aware of this as well.
- KerrickStaley 14y agoWhat I had in mind when writing the original post is that there are many places on Earth that are far more accommodating which we will probably end up settling first (e.g. Antarctica, Siberia, the surface of the ocean, and all the interstices between where people are already living)
- stcredzero 14y ago> What I had in mind when writing the original post is that there are many places on Earth that are far more accommodating which we will probably end up settling first It's not a matter of "how accommodating." It's a matter of how accessible. It's the space equivalent of geography. There are vast energy and material resources in the solar system off-Earth. A Mars-centric civilization will have much better access to those than an Earth-centric one.