3 ms·
The law should be changed, or overturned as unconstitutional, but that is a higly uncertain and lengthy process. In the meantime, could we start a grassroots c
by zaroth 14y ago
The law should be changed, or overturned as unconstitutional, but that is a higly uncertain and lengthy process.
In the meantime, could we start a grassroots campaign to get companies to explicitly state at the top of their ToS that a violation of the ToS may be arbitrated only and does not constitute a 'unauthorized access' under CFAA?
Obviously the EFF would have to draft the exact clause, so that actual destructive hacking can still be prosecuted.
This sounds tricky, but if the EFF can't write something we could put in the ToS to protect users from the Feds trying to extort cooperation from users by abusing CFAA (a la Aaron) then how can we expect legislators to get it right?
Specifically some things the ToS should define is how "damages" will be defined, proper ways to disclose vulnerabilities, things which are NOT considered subverting access control, and a lower standard for trespass of online chattel which required actual damage or dissemination.