3 ms·
See the original Krugman article. It goes further into explaining efforts to try and rectify their economy, as well as a general discussion on the principles in
by Jtsummers 14y ago
See the original Krugman article. It goes further into explaining efforts to try and rectify their economy, as well as a general discussion on the principles involved.
- crazygringo 14y agoWell, right. They added more coupons, which fixed the problem. But I don't see how that's significantly different from allowing the price of babysitting to float -- I know doubling the number of coupons isn't exactly the same as making them half as valuable, but it's similar. But since bitcoins simply adjust in value according to market demand, I, as well, don't understand how Krugman's story applies to bitcoin. If everyone thinks bitcoin's value will always go up, because it's deflationary, and everybody hoards -- well not everybody will, right? There must be other factors at hand, surely?
- rayiner 14y agoAllowing the price of baby sitting to float relative to what? It's babysitting all the way down. That's one of the great things about this hypothetical, is that it forces you to think of the underlying barter transactions instead of misleading yourself into treating the currency as having intrinsic value.
- dmm 14y agoThe price of an hour of babysitting on a random day in April is 1 unit. The price of an hour of babysitting on New Years eve is 5 units. On some nights the demand for babysitting is higher. On those nights the price is higher. Does that make sense?
- rayiner 14y agoHow does that fix the problem of people hoarding coupons by not going out, decreasing the underlying economic activity that creates the need for the coupons in the first place?
- dmm 14y agoIf nobody goes out then the price of babysitting approaches zero: everyone want to babysit, no one wants to go out. Once the price is 0.0001 units, why not go out? The benefit of staying in is minimal.
- Danieru 14y ago"I will babysit for you 2 hours if you babysit 1 hour for me today". For the coop this would work by paying extra 30 minute coupons. e.g: one hour of baby sitting on saturday might be paid with three 30 minute vouchers. Thus encouraging buyers to prioritize weekday outings. No idea if this would solve the liquidity though.
- dmarklein 14y agoIt happens all the time in real economies -- virtually every recession. Uncertainty leads to hoarding, which leads to a smaller supply of liquid money with velocity, which leads to deflation. Even in a world with zero hoarding, bitcoin will deflate indefinitely forever, because production will continue to grow while money supply remains constant.