3 ms·
Yeah, it's pretty obvious here that the problem lies with Hearst Media having ridiculously stupid terms and conditions, as much as the EFF would like to chastis
by notahacker 14y ago
Yeah, it's pretty obvious here that the problem lies with Hearst Media having ridiculously stupid terms and conditions, as much as the EFF would like to chastise the DoJ for retaining (but not exercising) the right to cite them in a prosecution.
It's "reasoning" on a par with citing lawyer-spam emails as evidence of the need for tort reform.
[To clarify, since I seem to be attracting downvotes, I'm not saying there isn't a potential problem with lack of clarity over whether any ToCs can be used as a basis for criminal prosecution (or for that matter with frivolous litigation). I'm saying that highlighting an absurd ToC that nobody would be remotely interested in enforcing is a poor argument against the enforceability of ToCs per se (similarly: legal threats so spurious they're actually embarrassing don't actually say very much about civil law). Worse still, it's actually counter-productive since the lack of any interest in prosecuting absurd ToCs could be construed by those in favour of criminal penalties for ToC violation as showing the DoJ's discretion works.]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]