10 ms·
Until Today, If You Were 17, It Could Have Been Illegal To Read Seventeen.com
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoAs a seventeen-year-old myself, I am now even more glad that I do not reside in the United States. I wonder if anyone reads T&Cs, though. Perhaps I should prohibit over-18s from using my websites.
- fyi80 14y agoover-18s are adults, and so it should be easier to stick criminal charges on them. Only problem is that victims can't press criminal charges, only the state can. So these laws are purely tools of the corrupt state actors and their cronies.
- peterwwillis 14y agoIt would be great to see access log statistics of big websites' terms of service pages.
- fyi80 14y agoHow can a TOS tell someone (a minor) that the person is forbidden to accept an agreement, while simultaneously holding that person subject to that agreement? It's a paradox in the space-time continuum. Has any court tested the theory that a minor can be held in violation of a TOS? Contracts entered into by minors are void on their face. This seems a lot like having a "NO Trespassing" sign in the bathroom of a coffee shop, and then prosecutors charging people who walk in the front door.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoHmm, it's an interesting problem. Does the ToS cover the ToS page? Am I breaking the ToS by viewing the ToS?
- Digit-Al 14y agoGood point. If you put a final clause on your ToS that said "Reading these terms of service is a criminal offence" could you make criminals out of everyone who reads your ToS? :-)
- _kst_ 14y agoIt wouldn't have to say "Reading these terms of service is a criminal offense". It would merely have to say "Reading these terms of service is a violation of these terms of service".
- rmc 14y agoWell if you're in a real country with real laws (like, y'know everywhere), only governments can make criminal offences, not private individuals. You can put that "Reading this sentence makes the sky yellow" in your ToS if you want as well. Doesn't make it true.
- thedufer 14y agoThe point of this article is that breaking a ToS is illegal, so ToS's themselves are de facto laws.
- freehunter 14y agoYou cannot be held legally liable for reading a contract if it is presented to you. If ToS is meant to be a contract, then no. However, minors cannot consent to a contract, so it would fall on their parents to enforce the contract on the minor. However, if the ToS is meant to be law, then yes. But courts are known to throw out ToS sections that are written in bad faith. Anything like weev and Aaron are far edge cases with big money and names behind them. Hearst and the DoJ would be highly unlikely to pursue even civil action for breaking the ToS.
- BenAlabaster 14y agoIt's about more than having holding someone to an agreement they're legally forbidden to accept. It's holding someone to an agreement they don't have facility to read without breaching the agreement. Their terms of service are on the website which the minor cannot read without accessing the website... by which time they are guilty of breach of the terms of service. I don't think I'll never understand the idiocy of American law.
- apg 14y agoYou could also say that the agreement is void w/r/t a minor, because they don't have capacity to contract, via Statute of Frauds. Of course there are plenty of times when they can contract, but TOS in general seem completely obtuse and not actually conducive of anything worthwhile.
- ctdonath 14y ago"You hadn't exactly gone out of your way to call attention to them had you? I mean like actually telling anyone or anything.' 'But the plans were on display...' 'On display? I eventually had to go down to the cellar to find them.' 'That's the display department.' 'With a torch.' 'Ah, well the lights had probably gone.' 'So had the stairs.' 'But look, you found the notice didn't you?' 'Yes,' said Arthur, 'yes I did. It was on display in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying "Beware of The Leopard".'" -- Douglas Adams.
- cdrxndr 14y agoCheck out the Oglaf.com landing page for a funny play on this paradox (somewhat NSFW ... really funny, too). It amounts to: * If over 18: Select "Over 18". * If not over 18: Get your parental guardian, who is over 18, to select "Not 18" on your behalf.
- dangrossman 14y agoContracts entered into by minors are not void, they are voidable, and only by the minor before the age of majority or a reasonable time thereafter. Minors enter into contracts every day -- millions of them work, for one, and child actors' contracts are in their name, not their parents'.
- Digit-Al 14y agoThe law seems to be fundamentally broken when it comes to minors. This is basically saying "we don't think you are mature enough to look at this content, but if you do look at it we will consider you mature enough to take criminal responsibility.", which is absolute bull. Surely we should either say that they are responsible or that they are not.
- aethertap 14y agoPerhaps it's time for a new SOPA blackout style campaign based on changing terms of service. If a large number of popular sites modified their terms of service so that it became illegal to view those sites for anyone in public office, maybe the absurdity of the whole thing would become evident to the people behind this.
- erichocean 14y agoThat's actually an interesting idea: Would a ToS hold up in court that specifically denied access to the company's service by government employees? If a company had that in their ToS, and they discovered that a government employee had used their service, could they sue for damages? Are businesses in the US obligated to provide service to government employees?
- aethertap 14y agoI don't think that government employees hold any special privilege in terms of private contracts, but I don't know. At the very least, it would be interesting to find out. I know that recently there have been some gun shops that have been refusing to serve government employees, so there is at least a small amount of precedent.
- DanBC 14y agoWhy isn't this being used to aggressively prosecute spammers? Sending unsolicited bulk email has been against the ToS of many service providers for very many years. There's real financial harm done. And spam is disliked by very many people.
- Vivtek 14y agoBecause spam doesn't threaten anybody who counts. Next question?
- jiggy2011 14y agoHow many spammers are even in the US?
- snowwrestler 14y agoBecause courts have ruled that it's not actually illegal to violate terms of service. Note how the headline says it "could" have been illegal--if the Justice Dept. had decided to prosecute a teenager on these grounds (never heard of that happening), and if a federal judge had handed down a conviction on those grounds (the 9th Circuit actually ruled the opposite).
- DanBC 14y agoAs explained in the article the Justice Department uses fierce interpretation of the law. While the law stands in its current unclear state people are still at risk of prosecution. Conviction might be improbable, but it's still an unpleasant situation to be in. Courts show that judges are not unanimous about this. (https://www.eff.org/cases/u-s-v-nosal https://www.eff.org/cases/u-s-v-nosal) Note that the Nosal case was a person who was permitted to access to computer, but who then misused information got from it, and not someone who was prevented from accessing the computer. (https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/01/rebooting-computer-crime-law-part-1-no-prison-time-for-violating-terms-of-service https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/01/rebooting-computer-cri...)
- rmc 14y agoBecause it's very very hard to track down spammers.
- _kst_ 14y agoI wonder if particularly serious violators would be tried as adults.
- apg 14y agoWith the right case, I don't see how this would withstand Supreme Court review. The Ninth Circuit doesn't seem to like it (Drew/Duval). My guess is the the SCOTUS wouldn't approve of private parties drafting their own criminal laws.
- kefka 14y agoDo you want to run foul on multiple felonies (1 per day per ToS violation) along with dozens of other "felonies" that you undoubtedly commit without knowledge..... Just so you can petition the Supreme Court to take your case, knowing that they can just sit back instead and do nothing? Wasn't there this Aaron kid that got hit by that very tactic? Hmm. He didn't take the "decades in prison" so well, did he?
- diminoten 14y agoAaron was sick, don't pretend like anyone under that kind of pressure would simply kill themselves.
- rayiner 14y agoYes, because I try to evade a major defense contractor's attempts to kick me off their network dozens of times a day.
- mpyne 14y ago> He didn't take the "decades in prison" so well, did he? So the example you take from what happened to Aaron Swartz is to apply yet more propaganda from the other side, instead of facts? It's not even something you have to mislead about; 2-3 years in prison as an upper-end estimate is bad enough to make your point without being evasive, and even the ~6 months upper limit that the prosecution had offered in a plea bargain is said to be serious enough to make your point. You could even mention that Aaron would have been a "felon" should he have been convicted or plea guilty on those charges and you'd have been accurate. And yet you choose the only outcome that wasn't actually possible to push your point forward...
- hmottestad 14y agoI wish someone would take the HTTP codes literally: "200 OK" = You just gave me irrevocable permission. Or you know, if anyone sues you for copyright infringement, you should sue them back for hacking, since you obviously put the following in your terms of service "you may not access this site if you sue me in the future".
- antihero 14y agoWhat would 500 Server Error mean, legally, if you did SQLi and it broke the script? This isn't a hugely well thought through idea.
- shitlord 14y agoI don't mean to be disparaging, but HTTP status codes have been well-documented. The only issue is that they are used poorly/incorrectly so often. If you can't use HTTP status codes properly, then you simply aren't in a position to subjectively characterize someone's request as impermissible/unauthorized. This is especially the case when the server's choice to grant access conflicts with your intentions.
- mpyne 14y agoWhat would you do in real life if you found a vending machine that was somehow locked into giving out free drinks if you pushed a button, despite listing a price for each soda?
- hmottestad 14y agoFor all I know it's a stunt by the vending machine company to make people addicted. Free stuff for 1 week, then people have to start paying. Actually Telenor in Norway recently sold a few hundred tablets for 1,- kr a piece 16 cents US, and this without a contract. First they said, no, no, no, it was a mistake in our computer system, but they ended up having to sell them anyway because they would have such a hard time proving that every one of the customers knew well and right that there must be a mistake. Anyway special case scenarios would never be covered by your server saying 200 OK. However, day to day scenarios would. If your server gives people access to a file, and the user has no reason to believe the server is making a mistake. Then the 200 OK holds. It's like walking into an unlocked building. Many buildings are supposed to be unlocked and people walk in and out as they please. If you put up a big sign saying public library, then you can't go to the police and say someone broke in when you made no attempt to hinder them, then 200 OK holds. The server is giving the file away. Yes, I asked for it. But unless it's a very limited special case where I seriously went out of my way to trick the server (like a scam artist would in real life), then you can't put a little note under the doormat saying thief.
- sabat 14y ago"The more you tighten your grip, Tarkin, the more star systems will slip through your fingers." —Leia This is a good summary of the absurdity of 20th century law trying to stretch around the modern world. One point, though: Thankfully, the Ninth and Fourth Circuits have rejected the government’s aggressive interpretation of the CFAA The Ninth and Fourth Circuit courts just as much "the government" as the Executive branch. Most of the time, I'm thankful for that fact.
- axusgrad 14y agoThis law seems analogous to allowing arbitrary code execution; a public website can write it's own law for anyone visiting the site, and hit them with a felony.
- larrys 14y ago"But the real problem is the CFAA, which allows prosecutors to use these silly terms to manufacture computer crimes." This is all ridiculous. While I understand the point of the post, and it makes for great mainstream media play, it's total hyperbole. The fact that prosecutors can do something and what they would reasonably do are two different things. To wit exceeding the speed limit by 1mph could get you a ticket but almost never gets you a speeding ticket.
- aethertap 14y agoI think the part people are worried about is the "almost" in "almost never gets you a speeding ticket." People will probably almost never be prosecuted for this kind of thing, unless they're looking for an excuse to prosecute someone. I take little comfort in the idea that I'm relying on prosecutors and judges to be reasonable, and I think it's worth taking action when laws like this make arbitrary enforcement possible.
- unimpressive 14y agoYes, but heres the thing, on a bad day, if the police decide to single you out, you can get a traffic ticket for being 1mph over the speed limit. Usually it doesn't make the news because the consequences are something between having to stand up to the police in court and a 300 dollar fine. Nobody cares if you get a speeding ticket over nothing. The way that the CFAA is written, you can levy felony charges against basically any internet user with impunity. So if the Department of Justice decides to single you out, they can hit you with crazy multi-decade felony charges for the lulz. And then you end up on the front page of the New York times for killing yourself.
- diminoten 14y agoPolice don't enforce laws, judges do. A judge would throw this out (this being either the 1mph over ticket or the 17-year-old reading Seventeen), and the prosecutor who brought it forward would end his career.
- unimpressive 14y ago
- gamblor956 14y agoEvery time I think about opening up my wallet and donating to the EFF for their various successful efforts, they turn around and post something stupid like this. They should stop letting 1st year law students write these ridiculous rants. Courts have almost all rejected attempts to criminalize website TOS violations. Indeed, courts have generally held that TOS is binding only against the company, since the company by the terms of the TOS is free to change the terms at will without prior notification to visitors.
- CamperBob2 14y agoFellow named Aaron Swartz might disagree with you there. A big part of the charges against him centered on violation of the JSTOR ToS. Relying on courts to interpret a law the way that you happen to like seems, well, pretty goddamned stupid. Let's fix the law.
- Zimahl 14y agoThe bulk of the Aaaron Swartz case was around distribution of copyrighted material which he was allowed access to but not distribution of. This is not merely a ToS issue as there are laws against distribution of copyrighted material.
- cowsandmilk 14y agoNot a single violation in Aaron Swartz's indictment [1] is about copyright law. In fact, they nearly all refer to US Code 1030, which is the CFAA you are claiming the Aaron Swartz case was not about. In fact, you are incorrect that "he was allowed access" in that the wire fraud counts in the indictment (page 10) is based on the idea that he should not have been given access to JSTOR in the first place. (I'm not claiming that Aaron's access to JSTOR was illegal, but rather that the case against Aaron argued his access was not allowed, while the parent argues that Aaron's case was based on the idea that he was allowed access, but was not permitted to distribute) Your description of what the Aaron Swartz case is about is completely incongruous with the charges filed by the prosecutor. [1] http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2012/09/swartzsuperseding.pdf http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2012/09/swartz...
- squozzer 14y agoTOS violations can be analogized into one of several types of real-world crimes -- trespassing, vandalism, or theft. Generally all of these crimes require the victim to press charges. Except they occur through that lovely Internet, so the feds involve themselves and who knows under what circumstances they would disengage? Certainly Hearst did not intend to keep teen girls away from Seventeen -- who else would read it? The option to press charges is probably all that's needed.
- tenpoundhammer 14y agoWhat do you get when combine horrible lawmakers with horrible corporations? ▲ |
- dromidas 14y agoIt's a good thing nobody actually reads seventeen.com... except advertisers who are trying to figure out what people much younger than them are supposed to like. Which of course is all wrong because it's created by older people.
- GHFigs 14y agoWhich of course is all wrong because it's created by older people. I wouldn't be so sure of that. The demographic for many magazines are people aspiring to be something they're not and actively seeking to know what they should like. e.g. The demographic for Seventeen is 10 to 16 year old girls that want to feel older and more mature; the demographic for GQ is mostly men that can't afford most of the things on display in GQ.
- zaroth 14y agoThe law should be changed, or overturned as unconstitutional, but that is a higly uncertain and lengthy process. In the meantime, could we start a grassroots campaign to get companies to explicitly state at the top of their ToS that a violation of the ToS may be arbitrated only and does not constitute a 'unauthorized access' under CFAA? Obviously the EFF would have to draft the exact clause, so that actual destructive hacking can still be prosecuted. This sounds tricky, but if the EFF can't write something we could put in the ToS to protect users from the Feds trying to extort cooperation from users by abusing CFAA (a la Aaron) then how can we expect legislators to get it right? Specifically some things the ToS should define is how "damages" will be defined, proper ways to disclose vulnerabilities, things which are NOT considered subverting access control, and a lower standard for trespass of online chattel which required actual damage or dissemination.