7 ms·
Cleaning House
- cpeterso 14y agoWill Android and Windows become "tier 2" platforms in Apple's WebKit tree? Who, besides Google's Chrome team, cared about WebKit on Windows?
- amackera 14y agoWell, Apple does. They use WebKit to render the iTunes store.
- glasshead969 14y agohttps://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-dev/2013-April/024429.html https://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-dev/2013-April/024... It seems like it up to QT port to handle windows.
- Someone 14y agohttps://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-dev/2013-April/024432.html https://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-dev/2013-April/024...: We are also maintaining the WebKit1 Windows port at Apple.
- greenyoda 14y agoApple also supports Safari on Windows. http://support.apple.com/kb/DL1531 http://support.apple.com/kb/DL1531
- mbrubeck 14y ago"Supports" maybe (is it up to date with WebKit security fixes?), but definitely no longer maintains or develops. Safari 6 is not available for Windows. There have been no updates to Safari for Windows in almost a year, and no new feature releases in almost two years.
- yuhong 14y agoOn that matter, I wonder why they didn't continue to provide security updates for 5.x when they decided to continue support for Snow Leopard, like MS did with IE.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mbrubeck 14y agoMaxthon and Qihoo are both major browser vendors in China who provide dual-engine (Trident and WebKit) browsers for Windows. I don't know whether they contribute code to the Windows WebKit port, or whether they do/will use Chromium/Blink.
- pyre 14y agoHow do dual-engine browsers work? Do you manually switch between engines? Is there some sort of automatic "this page looks better in this engine" determination that happens?
- w1ntermute 14y agoThere's probably a whitelist of sites that still require Trident. The reason for this is that there are a lot of Chinese websites that are still only IE6-compatible (this is a result of many Chinese installs of Windows being pirated copies of XP running IE6 - they don't want to upgrade to new versions of IE or Windows for fear of losing their OS validation). The Chinese internet is currently in a transitional period, with many established sites still working only with older versions of Trident, while newer sites (particularly mobile sites, and particuarly those targeted at the middle- and upper-class) support modern engines. Such dual-engine browsers help to ease that transition.
- deminature 14y agoValve's Steam gaming platform uses Webkit to render their Store and have a 40-million strong userbase at most recent count http://gamespot.com/news/steam-crosses-40-million-users-6348281 http://gamespot.com/news/steam-crosses-40-million-users-6348...
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoSteam doesn't use bare WebKit but Chromium, presuming they stay up to date (my install registers as Chromium 18, so doubtful) and don't switch, they'll be running Blink instead. https://developer.valvesoftware.com/wiki/Chromium_Embedded_Framework https://developer.valvesoftware.com/wiki/Chromium_Embedded_F... (Unrelated: their embedded Chromium seems to be hard-coded to Windows-like shortcuts; even in the address bar)
- Negitivefrags 14y agoA bunch of games use webkit for in game UI. Many of them run on windows. I think quite a few use Webkit directly but there are some middle-ware libraries for the purpose. Awesomium I belive is reasonably frequently used. Their website says that it uses "Chromium/WebKit" though so I suppose that they may be moving to Blink as well.
- bonzoesc 14y agoThe Steam overlay uses WebKit, as well as every Source game that renders HTML.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pjscott 14y agoThere doesn't have to be a victim. This looks like an amicable fork that gives some quick benefit to all parties involved.
- rurounijones 14y agoOracle appears to be a victim since they were planning on integrating their own JS engine into webkit. Apple's webkit looks like it will only support JSC I would be surprised if chromium decide to support anything but V8 Oracle might need to maintain their own fork of either webkit or blink just to support their JS Engine.
- dasmoth 14y agoChromium (kind-of) supports DartVM. The fact that they're working on Dart will be a big incentive to keep the abstractions between the browser and the scripting language implementations as clean as possible.
- rurounijones 14y agoNow that is a very good point. So while webkit is most likely a no-no blink may be possibility for Oracle.
- ceautery 14y agoI noticed a striking lack of snark in this link and the prior announcement of Blink. Either these are pros who are working in good faith toward their respective ecosystems, or there's bad blood and vitriol all around that goes deep enough to not get expressed right away. I'm hoping for the former, but human nature being what it is...
- zethraeus 14y agoThe lack of responses to the announcement post makes me sad. https://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-dev/2013-April/024384.html https://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-dev/2013-April/024...
- onli 14y agoThere is one now. And the author of the mail posted in the thread linked here and offered help, seemed professional to me. Of course, I don't know whether there was any arguing going on before that decision, but that thread doesn't seem to point to that.
- krakensden 14y agoProbably because there is little to no hobbyist community involved. It's no one's baby, just their day job.
- randomfool 14y agoStrongly disagree- many people have put years into these projects and are incredibly passionate. They will all still have to cooperate on standards committees and I'm sure there will be a lot of interaction- the browser community is fairly small and all of the companies collaborate to some degree (even Microsoft, somewhat ;). No reason to burn bridges, I see it as more of a sad separation of ways- each knowing it was for the best.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoSo it seems you'll need to choose Blink+v8 or WebKit+JSC, I had thought WebKit+v8 was relatively common but perhaps its just Google. https://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-dev/2013-April/024408.html https://lists.webkit.org/pipermail/webkit-dev/2013-April/024...
- signed0 14y agoOpera planned to adopt WebKit+v8, but since they are moving to Blink they will be fine.
- azakai 14y agoOpera was planning to move to Chromium all along, not WebKit. So it was a given they would be using v8.
- Samuel_Michon 14y agoAlso, given how recent Opera decided to switch to Chromium, surely they knew about Google’s plans?
- glasshead969 14y agoI was expecting something similar, but looking at the responses it seems like it was just there mostly for google. Any way , supporting v8 on webkit would be a burden when it's main developer is no longer there.
- nod 14y agoPhantom.js does use WebKit+JavaScriptCore, though they were musing about moving to V8: https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups=#!topic/phantomjs/GUPUw-XfqEw https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups=#!topic/phantomj...
- hkmurakami 14y agoBack in 2011, I got my first exposure to WebKit and OSS in general as I was hanging out at my friend's office in downtown MV, 9pm on some random weekday. I recall him working on submitting a patch (which I think got accepted after a few necessary revisions) to WebKit, and him explaining to me how WebKit is behind both Safari and Chrome, and how even though the companies and its fanboys are grabbing at each others' throats, the developers are happily working together, conversing casually on the mailing list and on twitter. It reminded me of the great sports rivalries, where the fans and media rile up the heat and hatred, but the players themselves remain respectful to their brethren on the other side of the lines. In the years since, I've been able to help out some OSS projects as a non-coder, and I look back and think that learning about the collaboration behind WebKit certainly nudged me a little bit towards this direction. It's a bit sad for me to see the Google and Apple teams split in this manner, since it was such a visible and prominent example of how OSS can bridge corporate divides, but I am hopeful that down the line we'll all look back at this moment in history with fondness.
- general_failure 14y agoThere's nothing to be sad about. Some people seem to think this is some sort of tragedy and failure of webkit the opensource project. It's not. The fork happenned to a large extent for a want of control on the code base. So, it's mostly technical. WebKit has atleast 8 ports in trunk. Every part of it - networking, os, javascript engine, bindings, plugins, graphics has been hacked to death. And it has abstractions galore. Now imagine you worked for WebKit. If you wanted to commit something, you had to test it against 8 ports. Many of these ports are cross platform. So, you are really talking about like gazillion combinations (mac, windows, linux, retina vs non-retina, os versions). It was not a happy place to develop and everyone in the project recognized this. The pace of development was getting very slow because of the above. Apple faced this and said WebKit2 is all theirs and nobody else should really use it. Google faced this and decided to fork. In short, most webkit devs are happy about this. It's worked out well for everyone.
- macrael 14y agoWhat about the ports? They seem to have lost out
- suyash 14y agoYay...common Safari beat Chrome!
- pjscott 14y agoWhat? Safari is substantially less common than Chrome. I'm confused.
- badgar 14y agoYou are responding to a stray Apple fanboy who spelled "come on" as "common." I recommend disengaging.
- suyash 14y agoRefer to #6 http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=common http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=common
- sliverstorm 14y agoCommonly used by uneducated teens and young adults So you're trying to sound uneducated?
- suyash 14y agoNo, because it's another way to talk in social media. Now, let's not get into the semantics, we all know how much correct grammar is used in social media/web.
- sliverstorm 14y agoHN is not Facebook. Hold yourself to a higher standard.
- ricardobeat 14y agoSo it's a spelling mistake. Who would've guessed?
- fierarul 14y agoThey seem really eager to make the forks as hard to merge as possible.
- badgar 14y agoUndo a fork is at least an order of magnitude more difficult than making the decision to fork in the first place. Nobody has that on their minds right now.
- hackernewbie 14y agoGoogle pumping and dumping. Seems kind of shitty to me. E: I do realise it's a very long term pump. But it has that feel.
- sdqali 14y agoCould you explain how this is "pumping and dumping"? What I have learned from the material floating around is that there are fundamental difference in the architectures of Chrome and Safari and how they talk to WebKit. Google decided to go their own way because maintaining the common code base was a pain for both sets of developers.
- glasshead969 14y agoThere is no pumping or dumping. Google and apple have different goals and ideas to how the projects should move forward.
- rurounijones 14y agoUnless I am mistaking things* it looks like there is a rather big problem brewing regarding the JS engines in webkit. Webkit guys want to remove support for V8 (and any JS engine apart from their own JSC engine) due to maintenance and complexity conerns BUT: * Qt 5.x uses V8 in Qt's Webkit * Samsung uses V8 (In a unofficial fork of WebkitGTK+ by the looks of it). * Oracle want to add support for their own JS Engine to webkit. Resolving this one amicably should be interesting. If you want to use Webkit on windows with anything other than JSC it looks like you might want to start investigating blink in detail. * I probably am.
- blinkingled 14y agoFWIW, I thought of the exact same thing. I think Samsung/Oracle/BB etc. are going to end up maintaining their own WebKit or Blink forks. (Not sure why Google will agree to add stuff that doesn't benefit their cause. Just like how Apple is saying JSC or bust Google might down the line say V8 or bust.)
- rurounijones 14y agoYea, it looks like we might have some pretty severe fragmentation ahead.
- mbetter 14y agoI sure hope so. I'm already getting sick of the "Show HN: Only Works In Chrome (only works in dev version of Chrome)" links that were starting to show up.
- chr1 14y agoAs a firefox user i agree, it's a little bit annoying, but don't think this fragmentation will have any effect on it. Problem is that most developers use chrome, and chrome have more cool stuff, so they wouldn't care about safari just like they don't care about other browsers now.
- 14y ago
- sudhirj 14y agoSo which browsers on the market are currently using webkit proper? I've heard that Apple uses their port called Webkit2 for Safari, and now with Chrome and Opera using Blink, who's left? Or will Webkit2 and Blink still pull changes and improvements in from Webkit?
- glasshead969 14y agoWebkit2 is a branch of webkit project supported by parties other than apple.