9 ms·
Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy
- jfernandez 14y ago"This future is going to happen – and it is too late to debate. However, the problem is that Facebook is going to use all this data — not to improve our lives — but to target better marketing and advertising messages at us." A little sensationalized? It's most definitely a strong mix of both sides, not everyone at Facebook is "evil". Honestly I think most of us can agree Facebook on average is useful service that has improved our lives. So yes it will probably help target us, the product, better to marketing/advertising. As more and more promising services get absorbed or shutdown maybe it'll get clearer and clearer that if you dont want your data to be the product itself then we should start paying for the services we care about.
- dsfasfasf 14y ago>>It's most definitely a strong mix of both sides, not everyone at Facebook is "evil". Devil's Advocate: Note everyone in the third reich was evil. p.s. No need to mention Godwin's law. I know about it.
- Noted 14y agoDuly noted
- rhizome 14y agoDoes creating their own launcher give them any data on non-FB applications used on the phone?
- untog 14y agoNot automatically, no. But in theory they could see who you call if they built their own dialer, see who you text if they build their own SMS client (Messenger already does this), etc. etc.
- rayiner 14y agoI don't use the word "evil" pretty much for anybody, but I think the business model is at the very least screwed up. If it's a valuable service, why do they have to be so shady? I'd happily pay facebook $10/month or whatever (I can't imagine they make more than that on ads on me) to use their service. The problem is that they make it seem free, and people just don't understand the extent to which it tracks you. It's the same business model car dealerships use when they try to steer you towards negotiating in terms of monthly payments to avoid your focusing on the bottom line cost--you can get more out of people when you hide the ball about how much your service actually costs them. Indeed, my non-technical friends have only the vaguest idea that their usage has a correlation with the ads (Facebook isn't exactly full-disclosure about how their targeted ad model works). This is especially true with kids. You think my 13 year old nephew understands the privacy implications of using Facebook? There is also the worry of what happens when Facebook stops being "the good guys" (which is a possibility for any corporation). What happens when the constant push to meet analyst expectations causes them to monetize user data in more and more insidious ways? I don't think anyone thought at first that the credit card companies were "evil", but the whole credit card/credit score mafia is doing legitimately devestating things to many peoples' lives now. Some people can't get jobs because of their credit scores. What happens when Facebook starts selling user data to employers doing background checks? Do we just assume that Facebook is full of "people like us" so they would never do that?
- onedev 14y agoIs Google's business model screwed up as well?
- rayiner 14y agoWell, to the extent that Google+ is a wannabe Facebook, it can't be any better, right? Without getting into an argument of which is worse, I think ultimately Facebook is more dangerous. Facebook has tremendous network effects and lock-down effects. I can switch from Google to DDG easily, but as long as my family in Bangladesh uses Facebook to post pictures of my nieces and nephews, my ability to switch away from Facebook is limited. And I don't personally care--I'm not a private person and anything you want to know about me is probably on the internet. But I'm making an informed decision (within the constraints of the fact that Google and Facebook don't disclose exactly how they use your information, but I assume the worst). In my experience, most people who use Google and Facebook aren't. Don't get me wrong. I think this stuff is useful. But there needs to be more transparency and more restraint than there is. A ban on collecting data on minors would be a start.
- VeejayRampay 14y agoRight, cause pre-Home Facebook was so respectful of people's private lives...
- kmfrk 14y agoThere's an Apple-tastic motto for you: All your privacy is gone. Again.
- rhizome 14y agoGive up your privacy again for the very first time.
- Systemic33 14y agoGiving up privacy has never been this much fun
- newman314 14y agoIt is a magical experience!
- msutherl 14y agoAll your privacy is gone again. Better.
- gavinlynch 14y agoIf this is a problem for you, then don't use it.
- smiddereens 14y agoYou don't get it man, there won't be a choice. You will be forced to use Facebook Home.
- Karunamon 14y agoOn one phone by one manufacturer. If you don't like the OS, don't buy the phone.
- icebraining 14y agoThat assumes you know about this in the first place. It's not like everyone reads Hacker News or GigaOM; this kind of news often doesn't trickle down to MM.
- yalogin 14y agoThe article brings up a very good point about FB getting access to a lot more user data on the phone outside of their app since they essentially are replacing the app launcher as well. Google gets access to all this data by owning the OS. FB in that sense made a brilliant play. It kind of corrupts google's data collection as well since all user interaction will be going through the FB Home app now. Also its kind of naive to expect facebook to respect privacy when all they do is deal with data.
- wvenable 14y agoA launcher is just another app; it doesn't have any extra powers. It just happens be the app that is launched/restored when the home button is pressed -- that's it.
- Zikes 14y agoIt also replaces the app drawer, which means when you click an app icon to launch an app -- from either the home screen or the app drawer -- FB Home can make a note of it and send that information to FB.
- wvenable 14y agoIt'll only take someone with a network sniffer 5 seconds to discover if it does this and then there will be bad news about it for weeks. More likely they just want people to spend more time using Facebook.
- jetru 14y agoPray may I ask how anyone can use than information to harm me?
- skeletonjelly 14y agoThere's obvious privacy issues, you don't want say, your employer finding out you just used certain apps like a job seeker or something else that posts to Facebook that you use it and ergo Facebook automatically likes it for you like they do with keywords.
- killion 14y agoSo previously your private information went to Google/Samsung or HTC or Motorola/Your carrier, now it will go to Facebook/Google/Samsung or HTC or Motorola/Your carrier?
- bhaile 14y agoRight. Between Google Now and other location services by Google (Latitude), Google knows when I'm home, work, traveling, etc. Now Facebook will want to get into that information via their "Home" app/launcher. Many services want location data. Context based location data is getting more popular.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- arindone 14y agoSome thoughts: 1) this article is based upon hypothetical notions about what Home "may" do, despite it being not even released yet 2) Google has collected user data for ages via Android for Google Now and few complained about privacy issues -- all data from its various accounts are aggregated into one centralized location to target ads more effectively for users. If you're really going to cry about privacy issues you need to be fair here and hold everyone accountable, and not just sites you may not like. 3) The majority of people may not care, frankly -- people optimizes their utility differently.
- u2328 14y agoIt's concerning to me, because I'm worried about this social network creep over our phones. Of course, I'm not going to install this crap, but if Facebook Home proves successful for Facebook, will Google move in the same direction? (Yes.) We've already seen Google kill off Google Reader in hopes of driving more traffic to Google Plus. This is what prevents me from getting too invested in a mobile ecosystem like Android or iOS. I like smartphones, but I want the device to serve me, not Google or Facebook's advertisers.
- untog 14y agowill Google move in the same direction? They could already have if they wanted to- they own the code for the stock launcher, after all.
- u2328 14y agoRight, but it's all about the incentives. If they did that now, there would be a big backlash against Google and Android. However, with Facebook leading the way, it could become a plausible scenario to see some similar behavior from Google. Hopefully not, though. I hope this whole thing is a disaster for Facebook.
- leeoniya 14y agoi will just say that Firefox OS cannot arrive quickly enough.
- Zikes 14y agoI'm not sure how Firefox OS vs Android OS really factors into the discussion. If Firefox OS is fully-featured and open enough to become an alternative to Android, FB Home could conceivably be built to run just as well on Firefox OS as on Android.
- r00fus 14y agoExactly, of course, unless the licensing terms to modify FirefoxOS as much as Android are onerous to the likes of Facebook. I think the pining for FirefoxOS is only meaningful if Mozilla takes a stand on privacy or the like. And they're not in a strong position to do so.
- leeoniya 14y agoyes, but i'm expecting mozilla will have vastly more granular and privacy-first oriented permissions than android. since google wants your data, and mozilla does not. ideally, i would like to hook and script a conditional firewall of sorts between any apps and my hardware or data. for example, i dont want any app querying my location when i am at home or at work. how awesome would it be to set rules like this? some invasive permissions are ok when i choose to allow them, but not indefinitely so long as the app lives on my phone, which is the situation right now. i can do a lot of quasi-scripting with Tasker for android, but not nearly enough.
- Nursie 14y agoI'm not sure why I would allow Facebook on to my phone in the first place, let alone to run the whole show. Their privacy record isn't exactly great and runs contrary to their business model. I don't trust their app (look at the email address change nonsense), let alone a bigger one, and the page renders just fine in a mobile browser. I also find the whole "ping me when a close friend does or says anything" aspect of the app as I've seen others use it to be a little obsessive and possibly even creepy.
- unreal37 14y agoIf you don't trust them, you wouldn't install this app. So... whats the issue? Nobody will be harmed by this.
- Nursie 14y ago"If you don't trust them, you wouldn't install this app. So... whats the issue?" Other people will install it without thinking about the implications. "Nobody will be harmed by this." What definition of 'harm' are we using? Because they've already shown that given access to people's address books they cause trouble.
- WillP 14y agoI believe his point was that you don't trust them enough to install their normal app, so you wouldn't be expected to install Facebook Home. However, someone who has already installed the normal app doesn't need much more trust to add Home as well.
- scott_meade 14y agoIt's interesting to consider if it's really your or my job to call on the government to "protect" other people that don't think about the implications. My answer would be sorry, but no.
- Nursie 14y agoWho said anything about the government??
- jcomis 14y agoI want to know how permissions will be handled on Facebook Home when preinstalled. Going through the play store, you will more or less see what you are agreeing to (likely, a huge list of everything possible). But preinstalled?
- desas 14y agoI doubt it would prompt you for the permissions in a similar way to the play store, I imagine that everything they need legally is probably covered by the facebook ToS, or will be in an extra ToS clicked through on first use.
- mattmaroon 14y agoThis is idiotic. For one, it's no secret which apps are popular. Facebook doesn't need a trojan horse to figure that out, they just need to look at App Annie. For another, any app with location services permissions can do exactly what he's describing. Also what does "Android allows Facebook to do whatever it wants on the platform, and that means accessing the hardware as well," mean? Unless you're rolling your own version of Android (is that what's on the HTC First?) that's simply not true. You have access to a few things you don't on iOS but it's not "whatever you want" if you're putting it in the Play app store. As far as I can tell this is just another third party launcher with the same privacy implications as any app that has GPS permissions.
- _jackwink 14y agoExactly, I don't see this any more privacy invasive than Google Now. It really boils down to how much you trust the company/app.
- infinita740 14y agoYeah, google know your home and where your workplace is but doesn't publish it to everyone. Facebook did that with a lot of information. Plus it may change how things behave without you agreement (think of @facebook.com emails) Google also use that data to provide a service (automatically call the navigation app to came back home at night or just give you a reminder on places you go every week). I doon't think facebook will give any kind of service other than keep my friens updated about whatever I do and wherever I go and this is frightening (not the fact that a big company has this data but the fact that everyone will know it)
- criley 14y agoFacebook doesn't publish that information for me. It's PAINFULLY EASY to mark that information private, and to go into the Platform settings and make sure your friends "cannot bring your information with them into apps and websites". It's two screens and takes about thirty seconds for you to control your Facebook and how much data leaves it. Seriously guys, don't blame Facebook for your incompetence with their privacy settings.
- SkittlesNTwix 14y agoI know this doesn't ring true for most people, but I'm actively looking to distance myself from facebook. It doesn't make me "happy" for the most part. It doesn't add to my overall level of fulfillment. Most of my "friends" on fb aren't real friends and often I'm not truly interested in what they're doing. These are all common complaints - nothing new here, but they're all the reason why I'm not interested in incorporating what fb already does, more deeply into my life.
- msutherl 14y agoIt's a great idea! I've removed everybody from my news feed and use it for events, email, and finding keeping track of people I meet (Rolodex).
- Havoc 14y agoNever trusted FB to begin with. I've got a profile that forwards notifications to my email in case someone needs to contact me. Good luck extracting data from that.
- saintx 14y agoThe problem with online privacy, is that people believe it exists.
- Executor 14y agoThat's why you need people to fight for it. Consider movements such as silent circle and megabox. At the very least, people should worry about blocking companies from abusing user data, removing Patriot Act, so on. Truth is, people have to give a shit.
- edouard1234567 14y agoFacebook "open house"
- Vinnix 14y agoFacebook has a lot to offer and its design is showing to be top notch. I think based on numbers they are a 'mobile' company, but all this fluff and desire to sandbox them from the others just proves that they aren't competing, but just being thrifty.
- voxmatt 14y agoI think the more obvious and immediate threat to privacy is that anyone can see the contents of your facebook stream right on the lock screen; and they can even interact with the contents without unlocking the phone.
- CrazedGeek 14y agoDo we know if that's true if the phone is password protected? (Honest question, I haven't been able to watch the video.)
- Zikes 14y agoAndroid already offers lock screen widgets, so it's possible FB Home will include something to that effect that would show even while the phone is locked. It would be entirely optional to use that widget, however, unless FB Home is able to replace the lock screen itself. As far as I know, that can't be done without rooting the device.
- voxmatt 14y agoIt's pretty clear from the website and the coverage that it does replace the lock screen itself: https://www.facebook.com/home https://www.facebook.com/home Now, whether or not it replaces the lock screen when it has a passcode/security, is a different story. But, by default, your FB info is available just by tapping the unlock button/home button BUT BEFORE you unlock.
- voxmatt 14y agoNo idea. I have been looking for some indication in the coverage but there's been none that I've seen. It seems clear (see my reply before) that it replaces the lock screen when it's not password protected.
- archivator 14y agoLuckily, Android's lock screen has deep dependencies (purges in-memory passwords for VPN, for example), so it can't be disabled be an app. That said, it can be prevented from appearing due to a timeout. Pressing the power button should always lock your phone.
- ivankirigin 14y agoThe phone’s GPS can send constant information back to the Facebook servers, telling it your whereabouts at any time. I really hope someone can finally make something like Loopt work on smartphones. I can't believe we need to manually check in to see where friends are right now. FindMyFriends on iOS requires your apple password, and much like GameCenter, the social design is horrendous. Focusing just on the privacy side ignores all the benefits from giving a service more information. Facebook isn't tricking users into this. Users want it.
- tlrobinson 14y agoHighlight?
- ivankirigin 14y agoI get that they needed to drive engagement before they had ubiquity, but the interaction became about seeing people I didn't know. Like most social products, the experience changes when more people are on it. In my opinion, Facebook, Apple, Google, and device makers are the only companies that can solve this problem.
- tlrobinson 14y agoSo Facebook can now do everything Apple and Google has been able to do for years.
- damoncali 14y agoApple and Google have a don't have a long track record of intentionally exposing information that was entrusted to them as private.
- badgar 14y agoI don't think we should be too surprised with how FB will use the new data. I'm just wondering who Facebook is going to share this data with. I know a guy who works at one of Facebook's "partner companies" that pays gobs for FB user data. This partner company gets (as far as they can tell) fully-populated user data in Facebook's user dumps - way, way more information than they need or ask for. So the partner company puts this data through arduous preprocessing steps to filter out most of the details before any user data hits real systems. They're scared of the legal liability of holding onto all the personal details they receive don't need but Facebook shares anyway because Facebook genuinely doesn't care as long as they're monetizing. So yeah, I'm scared of where this new data is going to go. Not what FB uses it for themselves.
- monkeynotes 14y agoI deleted my FB account when they IPO'd as I could then plainly see that the only worth in the company was user data and it would certainly be monetised as much as possible. But 'deleting' an account probably doesn't do much more than remove the data from the immediate web services. My data has probably been sold to multiple 3rd parties by now.
- badgar 14y ago> But 'deleting' an account probably doesn't do much more than remove the data from the immediate web services. If you think they delete the data at all from anywhere you're out of your mind. Records are tombstoned, moved to cold(er) storage for efficiency and then not displayed. Certainly not deleted.
- HarrisonFisk 14y agoWhen you delete your account, the data is actually removed. As part of the recent privacy audit, the Irish DPC reviewed the account deletion framework and verified that it does indeed work: http://www.dataprotection.ie/docs/21-09-12--Facebook-Ireland-Audit-Review-Report/1232.htm http://www.dataprotection.ie/docs/21-09-12--Facebook-Ireland... (section 2.10 - page 41)
- jetru 14y ago
- zmmmmm 14y agoI find this line extremely cynical: > Facebook is going to use all this data — not to improve our lives — but to target better marketing and advertising messages at us It's entirely possible that better targeted marketing and advertising can "improve" our lives. To state this outcome as a dire dystopian end point is making a huge cynical assumption about the motives of companies and commerce in general. I honestly believe that Facebook (and Google for that matter) actually want to improve our lives. I honestly believe that they think that they can introduce advertising in such a way that it's a win win for both parties, at least for a significant number of people. That doesn't mean I'm naive about things, or even agree. But to see this assumption - that these companies are out to intentionally make our lives worse - written into editorial reporting as if it's a foregone conclusion, is disappointing.
- eplanit 14y agoI believe you mis-characterized the statement you're objecting to: "...not to improve our lives — but to target better marketing and advertising messages at us." "but to target better marketing and advertising messages at us" does not equal "are out to intentionally make our lives worse". His point is that is clear that FB _will_ benefit from the newly acquired data. You have confidence we all _might_ benefit. The OP points out FB's history, which is undeniably historic in how it has challenged social norms for privacy. It is also no secret that FB (and Google, and ...) make money from advertising, and that rich datasets of details about people make for financially richer advertisers. Skepticism (maybe a little cynicism, even) is not unhealthy or "mean", in this context.
- rakeshsharmak 14y agoNo one doubts that better targeted marketing and advertising can "improve" lives. The dystopian part of this scenario is vesting just two companies with so much power. For example, FB (and Twitter) have already begun restricting API access to apps that are too big or unwilling to be bought out. In the absence of an alternate (or competing) network, they control your experience (and user data). Besides the negative consequences for commerce, there are wider implications for individuals. Dictators and totalitarian regimes sincerely believe they are doing best for their people. That may not be the case.
- ferongr 14y agoInstead of bloggers and "journalists" complaining about a service they do not pay for, they should do the only thing they can. Delete their accounts. I saw the writing on the wall 3 years ago and did it. I was not worse off afterwards. Passively complaining (while at the same time, ironically, including FB buttons) without taking actual actions does nothing.
- nonamegiven 14y agoAds suck, but the bigger danger is that the uber-profile will be available for subpoena, or the govt might just flip the fuckit bit and take it because they can. Being allowed to run a billion dollar business unmolested by the govt would be a strong incentive, especially for a company not known for privacy advocacy.
- anigbrowl 14y agoGet rid of the sharing buttons and tracking cookies on your page and maybe I'll take your argument seriously.
- arthulia 14y agoGoogle Now already does all of this. It deduced my address by scraping my emails, and somehow it knows where I work, too. When my airline tickets were emailed to me, it brought up flight tracker information and weather for both arrival and destination cities. Creepy.
- trhtrsh 14y agoYeah, and they make like 6 copies of every email you send or receive also. Creepy.
- recloop 14y agoThis is one of those posts with a scandalous headline to draw you in, but without anything substantial to back it up. I am quite disappointed that this came from a stalwart of a tech blogger like Om Malik. I can understand this coming from an MG Siegler or an Arrington or from the joke of a blog, Gizmodo. It hinges on the GPS location, which Apple does, quite publicly with theing like Find my iPhone. Google does that already, and so do every other GPS device on earth. I don't even need to know if you are stationary at one location every night. I can just connect the dots on your end points of your trips and figure it out. Heck even an app like Yelp can figure my home address, based on my restaurant searches. Facebook already knows much more about us, with or without our permission; just by using the website.
- malloreon 14y agoI have an iphone and even if I had an android, I'd never install this app or get an HTC First. I cannot say the same for everyone I'm fb friends with. Question: if one of my fb friends installs this or buys that phone, will fb have any additional access to MY personal data?
- joshguthrie 14y agoTL;DR: "I already tell Facebook all it needs to know, but this new thing is gonna destroy all my privacy (like the Timeline did, like the Graph API did, like FBConnect did,...)"
- Ideka 14y agoWow. It's like the, what, fifth time Facebook destroys any notion of privacy?
- cbeach 14y ago"the problem is that Facebook is going to use all this data — not to improve our lives — but to target better marketing and advertising messages at us" If "the problem" is more relevant advertising, I for one, welcome Facebook Home. When advertising becomes useful to me I might stop blocking it.
- freehunter 14y agoIt's a controversial topic, but I agree. If the privacy issue is handled properly (advertisers are not allowed to access any data about you) and the ads are not terribly intrusive, advertising based on what I'm actually interested in and looking for is useful. I'm not the kind of person who gets irrationally angry about any advertising at all, only if it gets in the way of what I'm trying to do at the moment.
- alanctgardner2 14y agoEverything he's complaining about is a feature in Google Now. Google Now does know where my house is based on where I stay during the night. It figured out where my girlfriend lives, and tries to route me there sometimes. It knows where I work. It knows when I'm expecting a package from eBay, where I shop, where I go to eat out. Based on those signals, it probably knows how much disposable income I have. This is just Facebook getting jealous over how well Google has sucked all of this data out of it's userbase. As an aside, Google Now is pretty awesome, and I trust our Google Overlords to not use my personal information for evil.
- leephillips 14y ago"I trust our Google Overlords to not use my personal information for evil." What do you consider "evil"? You must already accept that they are, or plan to, sell your personal information to advertisers - because why else would they bother setting this service up? Purely for your convenience? So you've made your peace with that, and don't consider it evil, which is entirely up to you. But someone else may feel very differently about this.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoI am so... so... fucking sick of Facebook privacy articles. Don't want Facebook? Don't install their app and use their service. End of discussion - years ago.
- aet 14y agoI just noticed that gigaom.com has at least 9 tracking services on their site.