6 ms·
To echo a complaint that is common when designers show off prototypes/imagined-redesigns...what does all this look like when your friends aren't as attractive/g
by danso 14y ago
To echo a complaint that is common when designers show off prototypes/imagined-redesigns...what does all this look like when your friends aren't as attractive/good at photography? I'm talking about the Cover Feed function. In the life stage I am now, I'd say that my Facebook Phone would be showing random baby photos 80% of the time, food photos 10% of the time.
I'm also curious how that feature interacts with what I've observed to be normal FB usage. When I want to post a status, I post a status. When I post photos, it's usually as a batch, not many with captions. I think that's how most people do instagrams too.
So, if you have a home screen feed focused on your newsfeed...how will statuses be "attractive" looking? Using the user's default cover image? But those are extremely horizontal. The only newsfeed entities that contribute beautiful photos with substantial text that are in my newsfeed are companies and brands (OK, and George Takei).
- dnlbyl 14y agoI had the same thought. I'd also have too many grainy, out-of-focus pics of my younger brothers doing shots. And don't forget "meme" pictures. That would be lovely.
- hadem 14y agoThis was my first thought. Facebook did a great job at making it look fantastic but in reality, my experience would probably look much different (poor quality photos, memes, spam posts, etc).
- zwieback 14y agoRandom baby photos and food - I'd say you could do a lot worse.
- tahoecoder 14y agoYou, apparently, aren't getting a whole facebook feed full of baby photos. It gets old fast. People really embrace this whole "circle of life" motif.
- rhizome 14y agoDoes a picture of someone's feet on a beach with a comment that "it doesn't get any better than this!" qualify as worse?
- ctdonath 14y agoWait 'til the toddler figures out how to take pictures.
- tolmasky 14y agoLast week would have been pretty annoying -- every single little circle would have contained the exact same red and pink equal sign. The image would have been absolutely useless as any sort of UI indicator. Perhaps this will encourage people to use pictures of themselves for their profile pictures? Might be a chicken/egg situation though.
- camdykeman 14y agoThe reality is, this rarely occurs and really isn't that bothersome. We've been building Frontpage - a similar product for making RSS, news and social feeds all available from the Lock Screen - for a few months now. Same idea, no inputting passwords. No fumbling through multiple apps. Just easy access to your content. http://www.frontpageapp.com http://www.frontpageapp.com
- DGCA 14y agoShameless plug, eh? I don't think your product really showcases how most Facebook photos are poor quality since you pull news images as well. I know most of the pictures in my feed are some that I don't give two cares about. Cool concept, by the way!
- camdykeman 14y agoThis is HackerNews, of course the plug comes first :) In answer to your question though, yes, quality is not a guarantee. Luckily Facebook has its own built in ranking system - are your friends commenting on the picture? If so, it will probably be worth viewing regardless of image quality
- frankacter 14y agoGot this when I attempted to install it: "This item cannot be installed in your device's country."
- camdykeman 14y agoWell for starters, where do you live? Let me know where you're at and we can fix this for you. Google Play requires that you list the countries that you would like your app to be available in. We kept our list relatively short for our beta release, which is effectively what you're trying to download.
- rlanday 14y agoI’ve heard that this was a concern when Graph Search was being developed, and that the query they used in testing to find people with crappy profile pics was “people who like Insane Clown Posse”.
- breakall 14y agoQuick, sure-fire "unfriend" test: My friends who like Nickelback https://www.facebook.com/search/6248267085/likers/me/friends/intersect https://www.facebook.com/search/6248267085/likers/me/friends...
- Sodaware 14y agoDon't forget all the "Like if you hate cancer, ignore if you love Hitler" pictures. Then again, marketing doesn't really work when you show the reality of the product. The Wii probably wouldn't have sold as well if the ads showed people slouched on the couch in their underwear rather than fit, active people with Big White Smiles.
- kyrias 14y agos/Smiles/Smiles™/
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoSuch images litter my Facebook news feed. I remember FB must have used me as an involuntary beta tester, because one day the news feed for me was replaced with just newly uploaded photos by friends. It was beautiful, it was actually about my friends, it was wonderful. I would love it if Facebook would make that a feature proper, because the URL for that feed only worked once for me.
- freshfunk 14y agoIf Facebook is ranking content such that that's all you see your feed, then Facebook as a whole would be less appealing anyway, let alone Home. I'm guessing there's more to your feed than babies and food and that othe content is ranked higher due to your aversion of then.
- ritchiea 14y agoWell you could try making some attractive new friends.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThat has MVP written all over it. "Friend me and we'll inject awesome, and tasteful, photos into your photo stream."
- anonymous 14y agoAnd then you set all your other friends to not show up on the home screen? This has to be the most roundabout way possible for making your home screen a slideshow of random nature photos. I love it.
- modarts 14y agoThis would be like a 20-30 mil acquisition right here.
- codeulike 14y agoPerhaps similar to this? http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/apr/05/fake-facebook-girlfriends http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/apr/05/fake-facebo...
- sodomizer 14y agoI guess it's a good time to post pictures of my junk to Facebook, then?
- mbrock 14y agoJust unfriend them. Life's too short.
- chrischen 14y agoThat assumes the need for high quality distracting content is greater than the psychological effort of unfriending.
- irollboozers 14y agoI like that this is a first world problem.
- nthj 14y agoor uncheck "Show in News Feed." I don't even want to know the ratio of people I'm friends with vs. people I actually see in my feed. Probably 1 in 10 at this point.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoMore significantly, how do ensure I don't flash someone's inappropriate party pictures at work?
- pc86 14y agoIf your workplace is one that you wouldn't feel comfortable with a quick flash of anything that might be on Facebook, you shouldn't be on Facebook. It's not a sterile environment and you can't control what's there. Either employers will understand that and not care that you're on Facebook during a short break, or they won't understand and will be upset that you're on Facebook in the first place.
- hackmiester 14y agoIf Facebook is your phone's home screen, it is hard to not be "on Facebook" for a second.
- cb18 14y agoIt's not hard to not make facebook your home screen.
- jacalata 14y agoIs it hard to make facebook your home screen for part of the time? That'd be pretty cool, hit a button to give your phone a huge facelift* as you walk out the office door each evening, or set it to switch automatically at 5pm and back at 9am. *if you see what I did there.
- mcintyre1994 14y agoIt definitely would be possible by combining something like Tasker (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.dinglisch.android.taskerm https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.dinglisch....) with a custom application that swaps the home screen. Some of them automation apps support a scripting language too, so it might be possible without the custom app.
- lnanek2 14y agoThe default view of the feed is actually highly filtered. One of the strongest signals it uses is the posts you like and comment on. So if you don't want to see baby pictures, food, etc. then make sure not to comment on those posts. :) It's pretty easy to go to a party, get a few new facebook friends, and comment on their pages regularly so facebook thinks they are your close circle to show you posts from.
- uptown 14y ago"what does all this look like when your friends aren't as attractive/good at photography" That's why Instagram was so important. We'll just slather on filters till things either look better or imperceptible as human.
- froo 14y agoI showed my girlfriend this app. Her first words were "That is dangerous. How much do I just want to post pictures of dicks for everyone with that app" While not my first thought (I had baby photos etc come up in my mind), to be fair, if this app does gain any traction, inappropriate photobombing people's phones will become a thing - and that's not good for Facebook.
- robszumski 14y agoIf they really stood behind the product and wanted you to see it for real, the landing pages would have used your real FB content if you were logged in.
- tagliala 14y ago> In the life stage I am now, I'd say that my Facebook Phone would be showing random baby photos 80% of the time, food photos 10% of the time. and 10% cats :)
- batiudrami 14y agoI've noticed posting single photos is becoming much more popular - it went from 'posting 50 photos of the party last night' to 'here's a photo of what I'm doing now'. I'd say it's a result of people simultaneously getting phones which work as reasonable cameras, and better data signals which allow instant sharing - you're not sharing lots of photos after the fact (once you copy photos from your camera to your PC), you're sharing a photo as it happens. This is a significant feature of Instagram also - because every single photo is a new story, you only share one photo at a time - Instagram is built on sharing your best photos, rather than all the photos from an event.
- zmonkeyz 14y agoI've always wondered this myself. I'd love to see someone with video editing skills put some of the low res crappy meme and self shots that appear on most facebook feeds.