3 ms·
> I meant per-country local actually, so for the USA that would be the FBI. Are you against that? No, I'm not especially impressed with the FBI. Their crime
by anamax 18y ago
> I meant per-country local actually, so for the USA that would be the FBI. Are you against that?
No, I'm not especially impressed with the FBI. Their crime "lab" turns out to have been a sham and that's supposedly one of their best features.
> Plenty of examples of national/federal law enforcement, they seem to work OK.
Oh really? How about some actual evidence instead of quotes cribbed from their funding requests.
> Large governments have their flaws, but it's hard to see a viable alternative.
Small govts of limited scope are pretty easy to see.
> Greater international cooperation would hopefully act against this kind of thing.
Hope isn't a plan. Greater international cooperation doesn't have the properties you assume. We have agricultural subsidies because the contries involved want them. We'll stop having them when they don't. International cooperation won't change that.
> And then you come up with that point, in which it would obviously be a good thing if a supranational body had the power to force the US and the EU to abolish an unjust subsidy.
You misunderstand. You're claiming that the WTO is good. I'm pointing out that it isn't good because it hasn't done the good thing that is obviously within its scope. Claiming that it could doesn't change that fact.
> You were holding up isolationism as something good, and I was pointing out it has been on the decline for a century, with few bad effects and many good ones.
Actually, you didn't point to any effects - you merely pointed that it was in decline.
>>How does getting a bunch of evil together in the same room produce good?
> My suggestion was that you'd have the major trade blocs sitting around a table, and empowered to authorise, or not, wars.
Trading blocks are composed of nations and we've already heard about nations, namely "I would be a lot more persuaded by your points about an evil supranational if we didn't see so much evil perpetrated by mere nations all around us."
> It would produce "good" in the same way that getting a bunch of evil people together to make the laws they all have to live by would produce "good". Even a society of murderers doesn't want to make murder legal, since they all have to live in it!
Except that it doesn't work that way. The murderers don't want folks murdering them, but they don't extend that courtesy to others. You need mostly good to pull off good govt and that's not an option at the supranational level.
> You can question the IMF's methods but they're hardly a "disaster".
Actually, I can question pretty much everything about the IMF as it has been a disaster in both methods and results.
> There are plenty of good supranationals, and they all seem to be working OK, or at least not actively bad.
The good ones have extremely limited scope and are in areas where standards have huge benefits to all parties and almost no downside to anyone. (That's why I mentioned the radio folks.) The WTO is on the edge of that and starting to fail. The organizations that you propose are well beyond that threshold.
> I don't understand the kneejerk antipathy to the idea.
That's okay - I do understand the fanboy reading of the press releases.