3 ms·
Cash flow crisis - Lawyers, prostitutes, and architects
- zcrar70 18y agoDevelopers (in consultancies) usually charge by the hour too, but thankfully we don't tend to get screwed over that often. My GF works in advertising/design, and things are pretty much the same there; work on pitches for free, then get paid to do the actual work if you win the pitch (pitches happen more often than architectural competitions, and involve less work and less competition, and as such are less risky to do, but the basic principle of working for nothing to get a job is still there.) In any case, lawyers, architects and prostitutes are definitely not the only professionals with clients :-)
- Tichy 18y agoIsn't it also a matter of ego? There probably are not many competitions for designing small family houses, but they don't add much to an architect's fame, so instead they compete for the big, prestigious projects. I don't think there are different economic rules for architects than for the rest of the world.
- gibsonf1 18y agoI've never seen a competition for a small family house. The competitions are usually for larger projects as organizing and running a competition is not inexpensive and requires jurors, marketing and prizes. I try to never do competitions as you are right on point 2, the economic rules are the same.
- rjprins 18y agoMy experience at my university; there are simply too many architects. It's fun to study it and in essence it's a fun job, but the needed skills are not very sophisticated (although they will tell you otherwise). A good recipe for a poor job market.
- gibsonf1 18y agoAs far as the skill argument, you are quite wrong. Most architects don't really get good until they're about 50 years old, as there is an insane amount to learn. I tend to try very hard not to hire people right out of school as they are so unable to add value to a project because of an intense lack of needed knowledge. In fact, the usual experience when I waver and take an intern is that we spend more time fixing the mistakes than the time made making them.
- rjprins 18y agoOkay, that could be true. I admit my assumption was based on the fact they don't learn construction mechanics (i.e. calculating if structures are strong enough). And from a few Master thesis presentations I generally got the idea people just make what they think is nice, instead of giving solid reasoning for their choices.
- jeremyawon 18y agosounds like there's something wrong with the relationship between architecture schools and real-world practices, if they aren't graduating with needed knowledge.
- saturdayplace 18y agoI'll second that. Having dropped out of an undergraduate architecture program a few years ago (for unrelated reasons) and having worked (until recently, laid off) at an architecture firm, I can attest to the gap between education and professional competence. I felt the program I was in focused almost entirely on things that were subjective (aesthetics), and prided itself on driving students into the ground by rewarding those students who were there in the wee hours of the morning. (I knew a professor who'd stroll through the studio at 3am just to see who was there toiling away). In the US, The Intern Development Program (IDP) is the industry's attempt to 'educate' architecture graduates, but the training you get depends entirely on the nature of the firm you work for out of school. Graduates can either get real experience working on and solving architectural problems, or they can become CAD monkeys, becoming the stenographer for another architect; draftsmen gaining little in their professional development. The difference in assignment is obviously decided by the guys at the top of the firm, so you're essentially at their mercy.
- gibsonf1 18y agoCash flow is definitely an issue these days. My policy now is to stop all work earlier rather than later. If the client has the ability to pay, they will to keep the project moving. If not, they can't, so stopping makes sense.