6 ms·
Tecfidera's Price
- ctdonath 14y agoPunchline of old joke: Hitting engine with hammer - $1 Knowing where to hit engine with hammer - $9999
- dodo53 14y agoIt's a bit more surreal when it's general knowledge what to do with the hammer but you have to license your placement-of-hammer IP.
- ctdonath 14y agoMore like we were used to hammers as fine art and flyswatters, when someone went "hey! what a great idea!" and patented smacking metal spikes with them. Such is a large part of the patent field: doing obvious things with common objects, before anyone else says "hey, that idea is obvious and the parts common!" and making others pay to do it.
- redcap 14y agoThat sounds like a doctor's job - they might prescribe a fairly cheap medicine, but knowing what kind of medicine to use is a different art entirely. Here the only reason why the company is able to charge a large amount of money is because they've gone through the whole process of tests and clinical trials to get the drug available for consumption. That's an entirely different kettle of fish than the expert knowledge $9999 you mention above. The gist of the article isn't about expert knowledge, it's that a fairly simple chemical compound (the name itself gives the simplicity away - dimethyl fumerate is too short to be anything horrendously complicated) is jacked up in price, and that someone suffering from the disease could presumably get the drug made themselves for much less than $50,000 per annum.
- epmatsw 14y agoThe more I've learned about how the medical system works, the more it seems like the future is going to tend towards replacing doctors with systems like Watson, concentrating knowledge in a quick, easily updatable form and keeping doctors around for patient comfort.
- andrewcooke 14y agothat's also a similar price to other MS drugs (eg beta-interferon). my understanding is that none of these (existing and new MS drugs) is a 100% applicable fix. they all are effective on only a subset of patients, and they all have different side-effects (which is still good news as it improves the chance that any one patient will find something that works (the subset of affected patients changes with the drug) and is not harmful). also, fwiw, the govt here in chile pays 80% of the cost. i don't know if that means it can also negotiate a lower price, but i would suspect so. and does this also suggest help for other auto-immune diseases (lupus etc)? [update:] also, talking more about the economics - the market is probably very inflexible. existing patients with a drug that "works" (and these only work in some statistical sense - they reduce the chance of outbreaks) is not going to want to switch, because (1) there's a large chance that you'll start having outbreaks again and (2) often they take months to become effective. so the main pressure in lowering prices has to come from either large purchasers (national health systems, insurers) or from new patients. for new patients i guess that oral delivery (i think?) is a big win over injections. that is something people will pay for.
- nonamegiven 14y agoInteresting comment from the article's comment thread, from Janne. A patent is for the commercialization of an idea. Anyone is free to implement any patent for personal use, as long as you don't sell it. If the use of this common chemical, and its transformation, is understood well enough for this to become a home brew possibility, then people could do exactly that. Not that this is possible or advisable for most drugs, but this particular drug may be one.
- dodo53 14y agoThat's interesting! I wonder if a charitable company decide to make say AIDS drugs and give them away without breaching patent law?
- maxerickson 14y agoMy not particularly well informed understanding is that it is more a of a practical exception than a technical one. So a patent holder could try to use the legal system to stop personal use, it just isn't worth doing.
- nonamegiven 14y agoI suspect "making available" would be treated similar to selling. But if the law is as described in the ref'd comment, I wonder why there aren't sites or books that walk you up to the point where you can provide the invention for your personal use.
- kens 14y agoIANAL but US patent law does not have a personal use exception. 35 USC § 271 covers "makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells" (with some exceptions). http://www.bpmlegal.com/patqa.html#1 http://www.bpmlegal.com/patqa.html#1 http://www.iusmentis.com/patents/crashcourse/rights/ http://www.iusmentis.com/patents/crashcourse/rights/ http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/35/271 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/35/271
- ebbv 14y agoThe blog post seems to frame the issue as: "Should this company be allowed to make massive profits off of their investment in clinical trials?" Any reasonable person would say "Sure they are allowed to make a profit off of that." I don't think there's going to be much objection to that question. But that's not the real issue, and I think if the author is honest he knows that. The real issue is: "Should MS patients, many of whom are poor, be forced to pay $50k/year for medication to help with their condition." The answer to that is obviously no. Now you can say that the insurance company will take care of it, but that's presuming people have insurance and that the insurance company isn't going to dump them, they're not going to have a deductible they can't afford, etc. When it comes to medicine, ethics have a larger role to play than say, home decor. Anyone who doesn't acknowledge that is being disingenuous.
- refurb 14y agoAs an added note, Biogen has a patient assistance program with no income limit. If you don't have insurance you get help and even if you do have insurance you pay nothing more than $10 per month. I'd say that's a pretty good deal.
- marmot1101 14y agoSo the counter side to that is basically Biogen is bilking the hell out of the insurance companies. While it is noble of them not to screw over poor MS patients, they're screwing over the rest of the healthcare system instead.
- ctdonath 14y agoIt took 'em a big pile of money to prove a cheap chemical is suitable treatment for a major disease. Who, by you, should make it worth their while to do so? and to do such things more than once?
- nateabele 14y agoI'll grant you the ethics issue, but the entire healthcare industry is now riddled with so many perverse incentives that ethics barely even enter the picture anymore. However, consider your question in the abstract: is a buyer entitled to the products or services of a seller on terms the buyer deems fair? (Solve for any values of 'buyer', 'seller', and 'fair').
- rurounijones 14y agoOff-topic: For anyone interested the guy who wrote this post also has a hilarious section of his blog called "Things I won't work with" http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/things_i_wont_work_with/ http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/things_i_wont_work_with... which documents various insanely dangerous chemicals along with very humourous descriptions of their history, usage, what crazy people tried do do with them and in what ways they have killed people. You do not need to be a chemist to appreciate it.
- mauvehaus 14y agoIt looks like there's at least one other fan of stuff blowing up here. I heartily agree that you needn't be a chemist to get a laugh out of it. Anybody who has gotten through 2 years of high school chemistry or a year of college chemistry would probably raise their eyebrows looking at his diagram for hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane [1]. And if you haven't had that much chemistry background, he'll shortly explain why your eyebrows should be retreating towards your hairline at maximum speed when you look at it. [1] http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2011/11/11/things_i_wont_work_with_hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane.php http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2011/11/11/things_i_won...
- Retric 14y agoI still think this takes the cake. http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2010/02/23/things_i_wont_work_with_dioxygen_difluoride.php http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2010/02/23/things_i_won... The heater was warmed to approximately 700C. The heater block glowed a dull red color, observable with room lights turned off. The ballast tank was filled to 300 torr with oxygen, and fluorine was added until the total pressure was 901 torr. . . And suddenly O2F2 aka FOOF. Which as you might guess is just all kinds of nasty. Explosive reaction with water at 100 Kelvin etc.
- AlexandrB 14y agoMy favourite is: http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2008/02/26/sand_wont_save_you_this_time.php http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2008/02/26/sand_wont_sa... The compound also a stronger oxidizing agent than oxygen itself, which also puts it into rare territory. That means that it can potentially go on to “burn” things that you would normally consider already burnt to hell and gone, and a practical consequence of that is that it’ll start roaring reactions with things like bricks and asbestos tile.
- mauvehaus 14y agoThis is a bit off-topic, but if you enjoyed his writing on this, I would also recommend perusing the category "Things I won't Work With"[1], but maybe only if you have the afternoon free. It's a hilarious compendium of chemicals that are simply too unpleasant to work with for his tastes. For values of unpleasant including explosive, smelly, corrosive, or some combination thereof. I'm not a chemist, but his tellings of not just how things could go terribly wrong once you have the substance, but the myriad ways it can wrong merely trying to make the substance had me in stitches for the better part of an afternoon. Then again, I was always the one setting stuff on fire, breaking glassware, or trying the reaction with more reagents in high school chem lab, so maybe it only appeals to me... [1] http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/things_i_wont_work_with/ http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/things_i_wont_work_with...
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoAs a taster Yep, [the stable-to-explosion sensitivity was] below the detection limits of a lab that specializes in the nastiest, most energetic stuff they can think up. When you read through both papers, you find that the group was lucky to get whatever data they could - the X-ray crystal structure, for example, must have come as a huge relief, because it meant that they didn't have to ever see a crystal again
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThis is interesting - as 3d printers mature, and as home brew drug manufacture improves how the hell will pharma companies be able to enforce this - I mean at some stage soon we can download a recipie for aspirin, why not dimethyl fumarate? To be honest because the DEA will drive such printers underground, which with 54,000 reasons to go underground is an amazingly bad idea If you are interested in recreational drug legalisation this is the industry to support - something will change
- potatolicious 14y ago3D printing != molecular synthesis. This may be an issue, say, next century, but we're nowhere close to it. If 3D printing an iPhone is going to the moon, 3D "printing" molecules from elemental sources is like going to Alpha Centauri.
- pash 14y agoThe idea is not to print molecules. Instead, you print reagents into a matrix designed to guide a reaction. The reactor vessel itself becomes a template for synthesis. There's a team at the University of Glasgow working on this. They published in Nature Chemistry last year [0] and garnered a lot of attention in the popular science media. 0. http://www.nature.com/nchem/journal/v4/n5/full/nchem.1313.html http://www.nature.com/nchem/journal/v4/n5/full/nchem.1313.ht...
- spartango 14y agoUnfortunately, for much of synthetic chemistry, positioning a bunch of reagents in a matrix is not sufficient to produce a target molecule. And even if you do manage to get to your target through a relatively trivial process, isolating it from other compounds is an enormous challenge. Reactionware has traditionally made this problem worse, as solvents and reagents tend to interact with the containers and contaminate the synthesis. There's a reason that most chemistry is still done in glass. Further, the reagents and catalysts involved in drug synthesis vary wildly, so it will take a substantial amount of shopping to even get the raw materials you would need to setup a viable reaction. While this is a cool setup, it's best not to overstate it's capabilities.
- Alex3917 14y agoWhy not just buy it for research use? You can buy a year's supply for $22 bucks online that's at least 99 pure. Then for an extra couple hundreds bucks you can just put it in a mass spectrometer to make sure that none of the impurities are going to be dangerous.