3 ms·
A year or two ago a group in .ch (which is not China, BTW) organized a group buy of Debian logo'd swiss army knives. I got in on the deal and unfortunately end
by VLM 14y ago
A year or two ago a group in .ch (which is not China, BTW) organized a group buy of Debian logo'd swiss army knives. I got in on the deal and unfortunately ended up paying well over 50% the cost of the knife in various transfer fees. So my "$25 knife" or whatever it was ended up costing me about $50. First I needed to convert from dollars to euros, then an international xfer, then into something kinda like a cross between what americans would call paypal and a checking account I believe it was the iban system where I basically sent money to a number almost exactly like paypal would send money to an email addrs. Nobody would do stuff like this unless they were desperate or crazy or just didn't care so the financial cartels tacked on incredible fees at each step. Oh if only we could have made a transaction with BTC. It takes about 5 minutes to make a BTC transaction so the currency risk is pretty minimal compared to the 50%+ fees from traditional currency changers. Given those numbers, even during an active crash its safer/cheaper to use BTC than traditional forms of transfer.
Anyway the value of a bitcoin solely due to transfers is (how much money the world is transferring across borders with BTC today) / (how many BTC are available for that kind of transfer/trading today) with a correction factor for velocity of money today. So if a billion bucks a day flows outta $dying_country and there's ten thousand BTC in the trading pool being used to transfer the money, and the velocity of money is the btc change hands a thousand times a day, then the price delta due to Cyprus/whatever would therefore be "about" $100 per individual BTC on top of whatever existing value due to other transfers and such. These numbers are pretty well made up but this is generally where very long term price estimates end up. So assuming BTC someday approaches 1% of paypals volume, then given paypals well known transfer volume stats, and some realistic estimates of the BTC trading pool size, the price per BTC would be...
Much like EE work this valuation benefits from a hydrologic comparison. So given hoover dam, how much does a gallon of water weigh? Well if you know how many pounds of water fell over the dam per day, and you know how many gallons of water fell over the dam per day, and one day's worth of water takes exactly one day to fall over the dam, then a gallon of water would seem to weigh x pounds...
- Nursie 14y agoWowsers. Whereas I've sent money between accounts in all sorts of countries for next to nothing. I think whoever organised your group buy screwed up, badly. And by the sounds of it so did you.
- VLM 14y agoLOL content free post. It does bring up the interesting question of what is the cheapest way to transfer money internationally. Obviously my example won't set any (good) records. Neither side were willing to use paypal so that's off the table (does paypal even do business in .ch?). Silver coins in a postage envelope maybe? A fat stack of Postal IRC (international reply coupons)? I think its going to be pretty hard to transfer money cheaper than "basically free" like BTC.
- Nursie 14y agoI'm just pointing out that your convoluted example of the knife (which I've heard somewhere before...) isn't necessarily a typical experience. There are a variety of ways to transfer money around for a variety of fee structures. For instance I used a company called moneycorp last year to transfer a few tens of thousands of dollars between Australia and the UK. They had a low conversion fee, used market exchange rates and there was no fee at all between them and the banks involved at either end. Painless and cheap. BTC may be basically free if BTC are wanted at both ends, otherwise there are conversion fees there too, as well as a variety of delays. And there are transaction fees (though these are small).