2 ms·
"You (or at least I, rather) want the competition to be in brain power or behavior rather than just gimmicky hardware." To be honest, I don't really care. They
by jerf 18y ago
"You (or at least I, rather) want the competition to be in brain power or behavior rather than just gimmicky hardware."
To be honest, I don't really care. They need to embrace the fact that it's a show, an artificial competition where rule #1 is "the fights must be interesting to human beings" and #2 is "the fight must be fair in the sense that everybody knew this year's rules at the same time and everybody is working under the same rules". How they get there is up to them.
I think to fit into their original niche, they need to be real, physical robots for most people to care, and unfortunately given the nature of the competition it seems unlikely that autonomous logic is going to play a big role.
Although one thought did occur to me that I feel stupid for not realizing before. I am very skeptical of the ability of complicated circuitry to survive on the robot itself, but of course there's no reason not to put the logic up there with the human, getting remote sensor data and issuing commands. Duh! Now we're cooking with fire. Full autonomy still seems like asking for trouble but I often thought some computer-aided targeting assistance could have been helpful.