5 ms·
Ayn Rand's Literature of Capitalism
- brianmckenzie 19y agoSomeone whose philosophy can be summed up in a Depeche Mode song is probably not the brightest light in the history of western civilization.
- gibsonf1 19y agoOr could it be, in being able to essentialize a message in elevator-pitch fashion, that a person actually really knows what they're talking about?
- davidw 19y agoWould that John Galt had been able to deliver an elevator pitch, rather than a 90 page rant:-)
- gwenhwyfaer 19y agoWould that Ayn Rand had gone into banking rather than writing...
- curi 19y agobut it can't be, that's why she wrote a number of lengthy books instead of just one song.
- gwenhwyfaer 19y agoThat's one explanation, and possibly not the best...
- uuilly 19y agoThe Fountainhead was written in 1943. Depeche Mode saw it's first success in 1981. If even one of the best economic minds in 2045 cite Depeche Mode as their influence then you have a point. 2007 - 1943 = 64 1981 + 64 = 2045
- brianmckenzie 19y agoYou're taking what I said waaay too literally. But if we're gonna go there (and this is all in jest), I see it like this: in 1981 Depeche Mode were a bunch of drama-whoring junkies with Casio keyboards, yet they managed to express the same basic ideas in far fewer words, plus a catchy euro-pop beat. I appreciate some aspects of Ayn Rand's thought, but find her books a chore to read. Alan Greenspan considers Ayn Rand a major influence? It's an interesting factoid, but falls far short of implying causality. I could make another Depeche Mode reference here, but it would be extremely tasteless. When Greenspan and his ilk characterize people as 'parasites', I parse that as 'anyone who gets between me and the forests of money to which I am entitled'. I might see where he's coming from, but his rhetoric is needlessly violent.
- randallsquared 19y ago"Direct influence" may be too mild; Greenspan was one of her "inner circle" of followers.
- SwellJoe 19y agoAll the Ayn Rand you'll ever need is in Anthem. Much shorter than Atlas Shrugged, and better literature to boot. I'm a long-time fan, after finding one of her books at a flea market when I was a kid (bought it coincidentally at the same time as Walden Two, a socialist manifesto by B.F. Skinner...one was delightfully rational and rang true while the other's greatest feat of intellectual brilliance was the use of glass dinner plates so you don't have to flip them when washing them to know that both sides are clean), but I'll never re-read the John Galt speech. Atlas was just too long. Ayn clearly never heard of DRY (or assumed her readers were too stupid to understand it the first several times she said it).
- rrival 19y agoThe Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged are magnificent. To suggest that anyone -not- read them (for the sake of brevity, no less) is to suggest a reader not experience great, life-changing literature. Her objectivist philosophy may be a bit overt in the latter, but never for a second could I sleep well knowing I'd proposed that others -skip- these books.
- rms 19y agoWe should be explicitly working towards the advancement of human civilization instead of working for rational self-interest.
- dfens 19y agoThe way you've phrased that makes it sound as if you're telling people to be irrational.
- uuilly 19y ago"Man's ego is the fountainhead of human progress." -Ayn Rand Her books make the case that individuals working in their own self interest are the best thing for "human civilization." Disagree if you will, but you'll have a tough time coming up with a definition of "advancement of human civilization" that everyone can agree on. In the end you fight for your own vision of what the world should be and ignore the rest. Might is right. Ignore that at your own peril. Especially if you're in a startup.
- mikesabat 19y agoI think that every aspiring entrepreneur should buy and try to read the Fountainhead. Howard Roark (main character) is the prototypical entrepreneur fighting to get his ideas to a world that needs them. It works intellectually, but it is best used for inspiration. How often do you find a piece of literature for $12 that MAY change your life.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- patrickg-zill 19y agoOne need only look at the current mess of Zimbabwe, where all the productive people both black and white, were driven out or killed, to see "John Galt" in action.
- jrmurad 19y agoCare to explain? It is my understanding that they are being driven out and killed by armed thugs. I'm not sure what percentage of said thugs are government agents but I know it's not 0. How is this John Galt (who desires a world free of the aggressive initiation of force) "in action"?
- uuilly 19y agoMr. Mugabe nationalized all farms in Zimbabwe. There were many British Empire leftovers (white guys) running farms quite successfully. Zimbabwe was actually one of the rare African hopes pre Mugabe. Many said it would be the "bread basket" of Africa the way Ukraine is to Europe and Kansas is to the US. Mugabe siezed all "white owned" land and had native Zimbabweans run the farms. Predictably this all went to shit and their inflation rate now hovers between 6,000% and 10,000%. No exageration. When nobody could run the farms he actually buldozed tenemants and told the inhabitants to go work on the farms. Very little edible food has materialized. The way this relates to Ayn Rand is that in all her stories the captains of industry are pervceived as evil profit mongers by the masses. The masses evantually rise up and take back what's "theirs" and the entire economy grinds to a halt. This is what Rand witnessed in the Russian Revolution and this is exactly what is happening in Zimbabwe today.
- jrmurad 19y agoThanks for clarifying... I read the parent as claiming that the looters (who you refer to as the "masses") are "John Galt in action". It makes more sense to say that the productive farmers picking up and leaving ("striking") would be John Galt in action. However, I think they were generally forced out by the thugs rather than (more Galt-like) voluntarily abandoning their industries.
- shawndrost 19y agoIs Ayn saying that the individual is more important than the collective, or that the best route to collective improvement is through selfishness? I suspect it's the latter, but Ayn and her followers frame the debate so combatively that it's hard to be sure. I see this confusion rearing its head throughout this page. (I read the first 100 pages of Atlas Shrugged, and got sick of it. I thought it was uninteresting as a novel and inefficient and not rigorous as a treatise. This part of the novel seemed to intentionally perpetuate my confusion: the conflict, as I recall, was between truly selfish people and collectivists that were too incompetent to see when the selfish people were doing collective good. Why conflate incompetence and collectivism?)
- gwenhwyfaer 19y agoIn any case, competition - and therefore the market - is necessarily a collective endeavour. You can't come second in a race with only one participant (well, except for some snobbish cake competitions in tiny English parishes).
- shadowplay 19y agoMight want to get out the pesticide before the Ayn Rand-ers pull a Ron Paul-ing of YC News.
- brennannovak 19y agoI have not read any Ayn Rand but I will immediately. I can not help but think of our current situation with our President and how the public views him. As I grow and experience more, being a business owner, etc... It seems that no matter how much one human knows or thinks they know- there is almost always another human who knows something else and that something else just might be what the first person needs to know.