3 ms·
Patents are for mechanisms, not principles. Patenting quantum indeterminacy isn't possible. Patenting a machine that makes it possible to exploit that phenomen
by jacques_chester 14y ago
Patents are for mechanisms, not principles.
Patenting quantum indeterminacy isn't possible. Patenting a machine that makes it possible to exploit that phenomenon is.
Every machine is reducible to mere physics. That doesn't mean there aren't inventive steps to make them practical.
- lisper 14y agohttp://www.google.com/patents/US7126691 http://www.google.com/patents/US7126691
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI think my point was that almost every phd quantum physicist had actually done that experiment. Extending it to "generate a random number" was obvious. Which probably is a flaw in patent granting process than inherent in patents I am mostly complaining that IMO a patent should be so narrow as to be hardware design ie copyright and as such it is much much harder to get broad applicability - which instantly reduces the ability to effectively patent principles Lets take a well known example - the use of a cyclone induced to create a vacuum used to suck up dust (Dyson) - he could not patent that it is too broad so he had to patent exact angles of fan to cylinder and so forth - which were eventually gotten around via different manufacturers - but he held the patents on the well known means of generating cyclones, for vacuums.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> Extending it to "generate a random number" was obvious. I am prepared to bet that the patent was not granted for the concept of a random number generator based on quantum phenomena. You can't patent ideas, you actually need to do some engineering with at least one inventive step. Experiments in a lab are not manufacturable, reliable, productionised products. They're just not.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI think lisper's link refutes that - to my untutored eye, that is a bench experiment as a patent application.