3 ms·
In extremely free market health care systems, pricing tends to be extremely transparent. I had surgery in India. The doctors could all quote a price to me, acc
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
In extremely free market health care systems, pricing tends to be extremely transparent.
I had surgery in India. The doctors could all quote a price to me, accurate to within about 5k INR (final price ranged from 85k-150k). A price list with common procedures (blood test, urine test) was usually printed on a sign behind the receptionist.
- VLM 14y agoNote the important point that "system" is not free market, merely at least some pre-planned surgery and common diagnostic procedures have a fixed price. I'm sure that the average purchaser is at an extreme knowledge disadvantage making comparison shopping nearly impossible, and critical care/emergency care does not allow the time for comparison shopping. Finally you did not elaborate on the competition... is there any? So its a free market in that some prices are posted, but not in pretty much any other way.
- mjn 14y agoI'm not sure if he went to one of these kinds of facilities, but my impression there is a reasonably competitive market in medical tourism: there are hospitals in Jordan that target themselves at enticing foreigners to fly there for treatment, and compete directly against similar hospitals in Thailand, India, and other places. They generally target an upmarket crowd, though, with some increasingly specializing to target Americans specifically. (I've noticed some of their websites attempt to delicately telegraph, "this is a hospital for you, well-off foreigner; don't worry, it's not full of locals.")
- VLM 14y agoThe point I was kinda getting at is without a well informed consumer (good luck!) the best free market you can hope for is something rather like the process gamblers use to select a specific slot machine from a bank of slot machines. Or maybe a better analogy would be selecting a poker table in that you can select to sit down at the $5 ante table or the $10 ante table. Oddly enough given the strong asymmetry of knowledge and capital, the house always wins. Not much of a free market. Although I would agree that in the extremely limited area of price discovery of certain procedures, I'm sure they do better, mostly because we do so poorly its almost just statistically likely by random chance to be better.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThere was competition. I got several price quotes, though I rejected the city hospital due to dirtyness rather than price. I have no idea where this "you can't shop for medicine" meme came from. India prove it false.