2 ms·
BMI is a pretty silly measure - a professional rugby player could have a BMI over 30 and be pure muscle - probably the same for American football players.
by arethuza 14y ago
BMI is a pretty silly measure - a professional rugby player could have a BMI over 30 and be pure muscle - probably the same for American football players.
- DanBC 14y agoThis is mentioned everytime BMI is mentioned. Most people with BMI over 30 are not olympic athletes or professional rugby players.
- arethuza 14y agoI didn't imply that they were - just meant that a simple rule that says "BMI over 30 -> obese" needs to allow for the fact that there are a small number of cases where this isn't true. [NB A couple of hours ago I was watching professional rugby players train - so that's my excuse for mentioning this] :-)
- dfxm12 14y agoOne of the two inputs of BMI is weight. This situation is about the weight of people. In this case, it might actually make sense.