3 ms·
My point is that you're taking what is and then applying the label "meritocracy" to it. But the world itself has no moral content, it's humans who create and ap
by jacques_chester 14y ago
My point is that you're taking what is and then applying the label "meritocracy" to it. But the world itself has no moral content, it's humans who create and apply it.
Meritocracy is essentially a statement that people are rewarded according to their merits, whatever those might be. It carries baggage in the form of an unstated moral component riding shotgun. If you ask people whether "meritocracy" is the same as "natural selection", they will tend not to agree, because merit implies a degree of human agency that is more than merely current emergent phenomena.
The confusion of value and virtue, or natural selection and meritocracy, causes all sorts of trouble. The philosophers have had long beard-stroking discussions about all this under the heading of "teleology".
- chrischen 14y agoI'm confused about what we're talking about now. My definition of meritocracy has no moral content either. I'm not saying meritocracy is the same as natural selection. Meritocracy is the system which aligns itself with natural selection. Merit is assigned by humans, and if assigned perfectly well it should align with natural selection. However, humans are error prone and therefore can never create a completely meritocratic society so meritocracy will never be on the same plane as natural selection. I guess you can say meritocracy is natural selection emulated by humans. However the universe ultimately forces the selection by merit (perfectly, as whatever the universe chooses is fair) and the humanly chosen merit is gauged by how accurately it aligns with it.
- jacques_chester 14y agoAnd now we're back to circular logic.
- chrischen 14y agoI'm not using meritocracy to define meritocracy. I'm reframing the definition of meritocracy so that saying "creating" meritocracy is a moot concept because meritocracy is not created.