7 ms·
Amazon turns Cloud Drive into a Dropbox rival with file syncing
- hsshah 14y agoTimely update. Currently am exploring cloud storage options for ALL my files. Anyone has experience with Bitcasa? How do Dropbox/Cloud Drive/Google Drive line up?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- btgeekboy 14y agoI used Bitcasa for a bit, back in the free version. The UI left a bit to be desired, and their encryption is lacking. (See http://blog.bitcasa.com/2013/03/18/we-dont-show-and-tell-infinite-storage-you-can-trust/ http://blog.bitcasa.com/2013/03/18/we-dont-show-and-tell-inf...). Right now it's not 100% cloud-ified, but my current favorite is AeroFS for syncing between machines. It works quite well. Here, the security risk is that someone gains access to your account and syncs all of your files to their system. I'm planning to work around the lack of a web client by installing a WebDAV server for myself, when I finally get around to it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- joenathan 14y agoIf you are a Microsoft Office user, Skydrive is pretty great, I use it to keep my documents and pictures in sync between my desktop and tablet, they even have Android and iOS apps. 7GB of free storage is also pretty great. MS's price breakdown http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/skydrive/compare http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/skydrive/compare
- jonemo 14y agoBeen using Dropbox for all my files (I keep it under 100GB) for several years now. So far never had any problems, in fact they saved me from lots of tears when they recovered an accidentally deleted folder beyond the 30 day limit for me. The collaboration and sharing options are another huge plus. I frequently give out the link to a folder which results in a beautiful and intuitive website view of its contents for the recipient. I also have a shared folder with every member of my family which is much more convenient than sending file attachments around. These last two sentences are also why I wouldn't want to jump ship to Amazon despite the attractive price: At least in my case Dropbox has realized a network effect that more or less locks me in. I did quite a bit of research into other options before and while using Dropbox: Tried GDrive and found the online interface (GDocs) not suitable for the amount of content I have, tried SkyDrive when it was still Live Mesh and had tons of problems with it (hour-long delays when syncing). At one point I tried a peer-to-peer type system (I remember their logo being red, forgot the name) and it was Java based which made it annoying to me. And I tried a system where files were encrypted before transfer (some Dutch company, again forgot the name) and the problem with that was that it was way too slow at dealing with all my files.
- Mithrandir 14y ago> (I remember their logo being red, forgot the name) Wuala? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wuala https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wuala
- hsshah 14y agoI want to stick with "reputable" and stable service providers since I plan to upload all my files. Feature wise Dropbox seems to be ahead of everyone. But want to consider Amazon as it fits my criteria mentioned above and the price is very attractive. Tried GDrive at work but not too happy with it. Do you encrypt your files? Most of my sensitive documents are in PDF format, so I am adding passwords to them; but not sure if there is a better solution with Dropbox.
- conception 14y agoBitcasa actually is pretty good, surprisingly, if you have lots of small files or good bandwidth. The clients are pretty buggy still though. I can stream mp3s from my home cable connection but videos and images are -pretty- delayed. It'd be impossible to use for something like storing a photo library. But it's a good place to dump all the legal media you've been torrenting over the years. Dropbox is still the best in terms of experience and support in other apps. Price is quickly becoming not competitive. Google Drive was crashing with folders with largish numbers of files in it (on OSX) so I couldn't test much after signing up and dropped it. It seemed fine, but Dropbox has more integration points. Amazon Cloud was pretty useless until this announcement. But their cloud player is pretty awesome and if you sign up for their cloud drive, you get the cloud player premium. Really, if Dropbox doesn't get something moving price-wise, this could be the end. But man, I love me some dropbox. It's just $$$$.
- chunsaker 14y agoSwitched from Dropbox to Google Drive a few months ago. the UIs are very similar, and Drive is much cheaper. My only complaint has been syncing: 1) After a week of repeated attempts, I gave up trying to get video from Dropbox to Drive. Maybe the files were too large? 2) Also, syncs are faster and more seamless across devices with Dropbox. There are noticeable lags for most syncs with Drive, even small, single files. 3) Event when Drive thinks it has synced, it hasn't and I have to restart the app. There are other benefits to Drive, but I never had any sync issues with Dropbox.
- jadoint 14y agoI was pretty excited about Google Drive when it first came out due to its pricing and integration with my current Google account. The syncing just isn't where Dropbox is right now and not where I need it to be. I would oftentimes get errors for small files that Google Drive couldn't sync but Drive would provide few cryptic descriptions as to why. I've switched back to Dropbox because I'm running multiple OSes and environments and I take their pricing as the cost of being able to use something that just works. I'd be interested in a backup service directly from Amazon though...
- WalterBright 14y agoI signed up for it and am planning to use it, but am disappointed it doesn't work with the regular kindle (just the Kindle Fire).
- lubos 14y agoI guess Dropbox is not going to be too happy about their key supplier competing with them and doing it at 50% cost.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoYou could say that about any company that is mostly digital and uses Amazon for a majority of their infrastructure (i.e. Netflix).
- rschmitty 14y agoIt's not like Dropbox is remotely on the same page with pricing vs others. Really they are a rip off, even before Amazon. Their client was just the best (well still is)
- ridruejo 14y agoWhy is it a ripoff? It just shows that (at least some) people are willing to pay more for a well designed product.
- Jgrubb 14y agoI'll gladly pay more for something that works over paying less for something that doesn't. I tried actually using Google Drive for real for about 3 days and it was pathetic. Also no Linux client. Ponied up for a bigger Dropbox and haven't had a single glitch in a couple months.
- robszumski 14y agoI can't wait until Dropbox runs one of the largest deployments of Openstack Swift in the world. I'm sure they get very generous price discounts from AWS, but running it in house must make sense at this point.
- gcr 14y agoMmm, given my (limited!) experience with AWS, I think Dropbox has a pretty solid advantage in the "Making a sane, user-friendly UI" department.
- 14y ago
- joseph_cooney 14y agoHaving to install java is a deal-breaker for me, as Java on windows seems to be a recurring source of drive-by vulnerabilities.
- rschmitty 14y agoJava as a plugin in the browser yes, I've been bit by that earlier this year (thank you MS Security Essentials!) However Java on your system like the .net framework is no less secure than any other runtime. You are running an executable you are at that executable's mercy
- trimbo 14y agoYeah, really a critical PR mess that Oracle hasn't stopped installing the browser plugin. Who uses that anyway? It's not worth the confusion anymore.
- joseph_cooney 14y agoTrue - it was its vulnerability as a browser plug-in that is most disconcerting to me.
- overshard 14y agoThis requires Java, is desktop only and doesn't have a solid command line client. How does this rival Dropbox at all.
- Paul_D_Santana 14y agoIt syncs files.
- WalterBright 14y agoEh, no wonder it's a 69Mb compressed download!
- niclupien 14y agoI stopped reading at "Java security flaws are well-known"
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- malandrew 14y agoThe decision to use java was obviously made by a product manager that doesn't care about creating a competitive user experience. You want to compete with Dropbox then you'll have to make a native client for each of the platforms you choose to support. No silver bullet.
- TomNomNom 14y ago"File Sync puts your files at your fingertips from any computer" ... "Sorry, we only support Windows and Mac OSX at the moment" I can't say I'm surprised, but that doesn't stop me from being disappointed. I know they would probably claim puffery, but it's just as bad as companies peddling 'unlimited' usage, IMO.
- StavrosK 14y agoDoes anyone know of a good service that does backups? I don't much need syncing, but I have a headless Linux server that currently backs up 50 GB of files to SpiderOak every night (they're usually the same files, so not much data transfer). Is there something like tarsnap for around $25/yr? SpiderOak is pretty good for backups like that, especially since I can check that it's working on any computer and restore files, but it costs four times that and doesn't have a decent headless client. Any recommendations?
- fakeer 14y agoYou have mentioned backup and not 'sync' so for backup there are some cheaper (and good options) - BackBlaze, CrashPlan, Amazon Glacier (dirt cheap). First two are not exactly 25/Yr but are cheaper than SpiderOak especially if you go for longer subscription. Have been using CP for an year now but BB's interface is a lot better. See if you can setup your own OwnCloud on your Linux server(this is an open source Dropbox like service).
- andymoe 14y agoI install crashplan on everything. Cross platform (java I think) crashplan+ is 60 bucks a year for "unlimited" storage and I'm pretty sure you can set up the client to be headless. You can also have them generate the encryption keys or just provide them with your own and not upload the private keys to their servers.
- venus 14y agoGood to see some competition, even though it's not quite as advanced. I have been having grave doubts about Dropbox's management since they bought Mailbox and it will be good to get some depth into the field.
- saosebastiao 14y agoSo does this mean that I would have a persistent JVM daemon running in the background monitoring file system events? I don't know why, but that gives me a nasty feeling in my gizzard. Besides, something tells me that I don't really need a ~100 MB process to do something like that.
- rsanders 14y agoIt appeared to be syncing my entire Cloud Player music folder to my local machine. That's quite a few GB of data -- 12,000 songs or so out of a possible 250,000. So it's not going to be of much use to me until they add some kind of selective sync option.
- jpalomaki 14y agoDropbox feels expensive when think about the storage space it provides, but maybe we should think more about the syncing side. Usage patterns may differ. In my case I have maybe just 20 gigs of stuff in my Dropbox, but probably I generate quite much traffic since I host all my software development projects there. That also means all the build results etc end up in the Dropbox folder. And as everybody knows, the syncing mostly just works. And it is fast, almost real-time. I regularly work with the same projects (Java/Eclipse, .NET/Visual Studio, node.js) from three different computers and haven't seen any sync related problems. I believe is easy to challenge Dropbox on the pricing side, but it will be much more difficult to replicate their syncing functionality. Two things I would like to see from Dropbox is support for client side encryption and support for long path names. Currently I'm using Boxcryptor to do the client side encryption.
- nodata 14y agoI recently tried SpiderOak, which supports client side encryption, lan sync, shared folders, backup, AND syncing. It was dreadful: sync took hours for a single file, and once they fixed that it took five minutes. Dropbox took a few seconds.
- bambax 14y agoTotally agree. Dropbox is perfect. It's super fast, even when you make duplicate copies of huge files (like Lightroom catalogs!). I have a local backup using rsync, and it's much slower than Dropbox. Dropbox also syncs over LAN, which is a big deal if you use several computers from the same location. I don't think $99/year is expensive. (Search doesn't work too good, though).
- cmkrnl 14y agoThe setup fails for me (in Norway), timeout while downloading assets from CloudFront. App seems to be using Jersey; Downloading https://d29x207vrinatv.cloudfront.net/Sync/Windows/Application Files/AmazonCloudDrive_2_0_2013_0841/LocalServiceJars/jetty-servlet-8.1.0.v20120127.jar did not succeed.