5 ms·
This isn’t a particularly nuanced or balanced presentation of the outcomes of such a policy. Any agricultural product with a long lag between planting and harv
by jacobolus 14y ago
This isn’t a particularly nuanced or balanced presentation of the outcomes of such a policy.
Any agricultural product with a long lag between planting and harvest ends up getting sucked into cycles of boom and bust, which are terribly destructive for all involved. The cycle goes like this:
Insufficient supply one year results in very high prices
Everyone and his grandmother decides to plant raisins
5 years pass
There’s a giant glut, and prices drop through the floor
All the raisin farmers decide to ditch such a shitty product
Repeat
This cycle absolutely wrecks agricultural economies which are dependent on one or a handful of key exports.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThis is why we have agricultural derivatives, e.g. forwards and options: to transfer food price volatility from lightly capitalised farmers to investors better able to absorb the risk. In fact, farming is the original raison d'être (raisin d'être? :D) for these derivatives. "the notion that the government’s raisin-administrators ward off chaotic gyrations in prices far-fetched: walnut and citrus farmers, after all, have abandoned similar systems in recent years without any ill effects" This issue has been studied extensively - "agricultural central banks" are a bad way to deal with a perishable commodity because they shift demand volatility onto the government's balance sheet and so dull the incentive for supply to adjust, or find ways to become more versatile.
- jacobolus 14y agoDoes anyone know more about the walnut/citrus story? Casual googling isn’t turning up much. When were these systems abandoned? If it’s been <10 years, then we probably don’t have a good idea of the effects yet.
- gusfoo 14y ago> This is why we have agricultural derivatives, ...and, indeed, many other financial derivative products. They have a terrible reputation but smoothing the curve between boom and bust in commodities is a very useful service.
- jellicle 14y agoAnd back when investing in such derivatives was limited to, e.g. buyers of such commodities, it worked fine. Now the average commodity "investor" just sees a differently-labeled slot machine and cares not at all about the underlying commodity, and never intends to accept delivery of same. For speculators, increasing (not decreasing) the boom-bust cycle is beneficial.
- Retric 14y agoFor farmers a boom bust cycle is fine as long as they cam match the product being sold. If they sell a futures when planting they get out of the market and stop carring about the eventual price.
- confluence 14y agoGood argument. Fails in reality. Derivatives began as insurance contracts that worked fairly well between interested parties that actually wanted to move physical product and reduce risk (say farmers and supermarkets). However, most of these markets have mutated and are mostly used for speculation by agents who have little to no interest in the actual delivery of said commodities (Glencore) - and are in fact more interested in pricing manipulation and monopolistic/oligopolistic market control than acting as a volatility store. Derivatives work well when the agents in the contract actually care about locking in the price of the commodity (say oil miners and airlines) - but when the people on either side don't care about reducing risk (say speculators and speculators) - things fall apart. In turn, pricing volatility and rents accrued to speculating market participants increase, harming both supply/demand parts of the physical commodity curve, and doing the exact opposite of what was intended. A more humorous take on this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=QPf-D_r3Ni4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=Q...
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoGlencore owns farms, mines, and production facilities around the world. It also has direct supply relationships to manufacturers, power generators, and food processors. It is not the example you were looking for. If you want an example of someone who has "little to no interest in [accepting] delivery of said commodities", pick me. I'm a trader. What I do is analogous to the person at the Department of Agriculture who decides how much supply at a given price should be produced. Central planning has an aesthetic appeal, but especially when it comes to consumer discretionary products like raisins, it is a messy way of shifting the burden of forecasting from those unable (the farmers) to those with little incentive to get it right and an even lower chance of being displaced.
- confluence 14y ago> Glencore owns farms, mines, and production facilities around the world How is this evidence against my point? De Beers does the same with diamonds. Looks like they can manipulate prices easily enough. My argument against yours cannot be taken as me stating that central planning is good - but merely that derivative markets can become bad. Just because I hold a critical a position on a thing, it does not necessarily mean that I'm advocating for the use of an opposing thing. If I criticise capitalism for doing such and such - it does not follow that I advocate replacing capitalism with communism/socialism to fix such and such. I like derivatives and financial markets just as much as the next guy - but only when they are used properly - to reduce, and not to increase risk.
- CoffeeDregs 14y agoAlso, known as the Bullwhip Effect: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect We played the Beer Distribution Game @ MIT to simulate this phenomenon. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Distribution_Game http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Distribution_Game) While my initial reaction is to shudder at the thought of a Raisin Czar, I gotta say that I'm not sure it's a bad idea after seeing how out of control long time constant supply chains can become.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 14y agoThe BDG demonstrates oscillations in conditions of isolation -- the participants aren't allowed to communicate and nobody has any insight into the global status of the system. Agriculture is not like that. In particular, the supply of any crop is known and publicised as harvesting begins, and it can be predicted with some confidence based on seasonal conditions. Current worldwide market rates and futures provide guidance on what is happening elsewhere. So in fact all participants have partial insight into the global state of the system, which changes behaviour considerably from the BDG scenario.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 14y agoFarmers tend to be quite conservative about crop changes and new techniques, technologies. Interestingly, they possess the capability to form long term memories. This means that no, actually, they don't stampede from crop to crop. The boom/bust cycle in agriculture prices is largely driven by the weather and shifts in consumer preferences.
- malandrew 14y agoThere's a second problem too. There are a lot of derivative products that are impacted by these cycles. Take Raisinettes for example. If you were the company making Raisinettes and one year you can make them available because the market is functioning, but the next year you can't because the market collapses, you know what happens? You simple remove that product from your product offerings. It's possible that once the market returns to normal, the derivative product is no longer offered because the company making such a product doesn't want to spend time and money making the product, taking it to market and marketing it if the market may just collapse again the next year. This is a serious issue for any agricultural product where there are a lot of derivative products. The maple syrup industry in Canada for example keeps large reserves to make sure companies making derivative products can bank on a solid supply of maple syrup at non-volatile prices.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoPetroleum has more derivative products, e.g. plastics, than almost any agricultural commodity. It is telling that oil companies prefer to sell on the open markets versus locking into long-term contracts with single counter-parties. Granted, I'm sure they would be thrilled to have the government step in as a buyer-of-last-resort.